Have We Hit Peak Apple?

Andrew Sullivan —  Oct 24 2012 @ 7:48pm

Brian Barrett looks at the new iPad Mini and claims Apple is losing its edge:

The iPad Mini is an obvious and bloated—both in size and price—response to last year's Kindle Fire and this summer's Nexus 7. Before it came the iPhone 5, Apple's limp concession that people actually do want bigger phone displays. … Compare the Apple of 2012, then, to the Apple juggernaut of 1998 to 2010. That Apple didn't react to markets. It created them. Who wanted a tablet before the iPad? Who gave smartphones a second thought before the iPhone? Those products defined technology for a decade.

Kit Eaton however sees another product that premiered yesterday as a classic example of Apple leadership: the extremely thin iMac.