The Walmart Strike, Ctd

Kathleen Geier calls the strikes a "a rousing success." McArdle disagrees. Among the reasons she expects them to do little good:

Walmart's $446 billion of revenue last year was eye-popping, but its profit margins are far from fat–between 3% to 3.5%. If they cut that down by a percentage point–about what retailers like Costco and Macy's have been bringing in–that would give each Walmart employee about $2850 a year, which is substantial but far from life-changing. Further wage improvements would have to come out of the pockets of Walmart's extremely price conscious shoppers. Which might be difficult, given how many product categories Amazon is pushing into.

Earlier coverage here. Update from a reader:

Is Megan McArdle really as out of touch as she sounds? This is truly frightening in its upper-class cluelessness.

Walmart employees are not looking for Walmart to win them the lottery or buy them a stay at the Four Seasons Maui or change their lives. They’re looking for a decent improvement to their current income levels. $2,850 a year would be HUGE to these workers. A $3,000 raise to someone making $20,000 a year or less amounts to a 15 percent plus raise. McArdle looks at the possibility of folks under the poverty line getting about $250 dollars extra per month – which could cover monthly grocery expenses alone – and basically says "bah, not worth it".