The Daily Wrap

Pope Benedict XVI Steps Down And Officially Retires From The Papal Office

Today on the Dish, Andrew bid a not-so-fond farewell to Benedict XVI and fisked Bob Woodward’s claim of White House intimidation. Amy Davidson analyzed the bottom line for marriage equality while Jesse Green anticipated a wave of same-sex divorces, Erick Erickson reminded conservatives about the basics of reporting, and the Supreme Court entangled privacy advocates in a Catch-22.

As sequestration loomed, Mike Riggs grinned at the possibility of DEA budget cuts and we predicted that the gradual phase-in will slow but not stop growth. We debated whether smart people had “flip-flopped” on the deficit, contemplated the long-term Republican strategy, and Kornacki put Hillary at the head of the 2016 Democratic class. In foreign policy coverage, Douthat found reason for optimism in Rand Paul and we considered America’s next step in Syria in light of restrained interventionism at home.

In assorted new and views, Christina Larson sifted through Chinese secrecy on soil pollution while we struggled to adapt to melting at the poles. Andras Forgacs manufactured meats, 3-d printing redefined the parameters of the gun control debate, and Robin Sloan butted up against online language barriers. Ivory Toldson pulled apart the stats on college-bound black men, Sarah Kendzior worried over the effect of internships and adjunct professorships, Andrew Mason shocked us with his honest resignation, and readers looked for alternative motives in Yahoo!’s ban on working from home. The trans community found a surprising ally in its push for insurance coverage and A. Barton Hinkle condemned cities for being choosers when it came to beggars.

Elsewhere, Benjamin Lennett forecast trouble for Netflix addicts, Keith Ellison expressed ambivalence about deleted scenes, we deconstructed hatred for Anne Hathaway, and watched an audition for Lena Dark Thirty. John Patrick Leary shared tales of untimely doggie deaths, gluten-free diets elicited mixed feelings, and we exposed the sinister side of a sartorial movement. A young pilgrim waved a goodbye to the outgoing pope in the FOTD, drought knocked out a Texas dock in the VFYW, and we gesundheit’d through a super-cut of canine sneezes in the MHB.

D.A.

(Photo by Oli Scarff/Getty Images)

The Staggeringly Bad Judgment Of Bob Woodward

Well, he asked for it. He is a stenographer, who is very, very well connected to the old Washington (which Obama’s online political revolution disturbed), and a dutiful gatherer of whatever those in power say they do and have done. But after his implosion over the last 24 hours – exposed as a whiny liar by his own email – Chait puts the boot in:

His more recent books often compile interesting facts, but how Woodward chooses to package those facts has come to represent a barometric measure of a figure’s standing within the establishment. His 1994 account of Bill Clinton’s major budget bill, which in retrospect was a major success, told a story of chaos and indecision. He wrote a fulsome love letter to Alan Greenspan, “Maestro,” at the peak of the Fed chairman’s almost comic prestige. In 2003, when George W. Bush was still a decisive and indispensable war leader, Woodward wrote a heroic treatment of the Iraq War. After Bush’s reputation had collapsed, Woodward packaged essentially the same facts into a devastating indictment. Woodward’s book on the 2011 debt negotiations was notable for arguing that Obama scotched a potential deficit deal. The central argument has since been debunked by no less a figure than Eric Cantor, who admitted to Ryan Lizza that he killed the deal.

The Shock Of The Truth

You never really expect to read it – especially in the business world where lies and public relations and reputation management are endemic. And then suddenly, it pops up, shocking in its candor. Here’s the resignation letter of Andrew Mason, Groupon’s CEO:

“People of Groupon,

“After four and a half intense and wonderful years as CEO of Groupon, I’ve decided that I’d like to spend more time with my family. Just kidding – I was fired today. If you’re wondering why . . . you haven’t been paying attention. From controversial metrics in our S1 to our material weakness to two quarters of missing our own expectations and a stock price that’s hovering around one quarter of our listing price, the events of the last year and a half speak for themselves. As CEO, I am accountable.

Now if only the Pope could have been as honest.

Our Melting Planet

Due to declining ice coverage in the Arctic, the NOAA is being forced to quickly generate maps of previously uncharted Arctic waters for commercial vessels. Meanwhile, John Timmer talks to geologist Richard Alley about glacial melt in the Antarctic:

The key thing that regulates the flow of these glaciers is what’s called a “grounding line,” or the place where the glacier’s end is in contact both with the ocean floor and with the ocean itself (this is in contrast to the floating ice that sometimes spreads past this site). While a glacier is on the grounding line, Alley said there are a lot of feedbacks that tend to keep it there. … The problem is that, when the feedbacks are finally overcome, the grounding line fails catastrophically, and the ice tends to retreat rapidly to the next potential grounding line.

Alley identifies areas in which this effect could “raise sea levels by two meters”, faster than we would be able to adapt. Unfortunately, worldwide concern about the need for action on climate change is fading:

Despite years of studies showing the impact of global warming on the planet, only 49 per cent of people now consider climate change a very serious issue – far fewer than at the beginning of the worldwide financial crisis in 2009. Worries about climate change first dropped in industrialised nations but they have now also fallen in developing economies including Brazil and China, according to the survey by GlobeScan Radar.

Hating On Hathaway, Ctd

Ann Friedman ponders dislike of Anne Hathaway and our feelings towards celebrities more generally:

What does it really mean when we say an actress “annoys the shit” out of us, anyway? That we hate the roles she chooses? The paparazzi’d version of her life we see in US Weekly? Her insufficiently funny quips on the red carpet? Or, as Salon asked today, is it her face? In some ways, the point of sitting on the bleachers of celebrity culture is the thrill of judging with impunity. Unlike our neighbors or co-workers, we convince ourselves that famous actors, by dint of making their living entertaining us, have chosen to be judged. And judge we do. (This isn’t just a byproduct of our Twitter-enforced instapundit culture, either: “Let’s get Entertainment Weekly and play my favorite new game: Love Her/Hate Him,” exclaims Will in a 1999 episode of Will & Grace.)

Sasha Weiss theorizes that certain people detest Hathaway because “she represents the archetype of the happy girl, which is one that many people resist.” TNC chips in his two cents:

I recognize that there is an entire publicity industry designed to get us to “like” people whom we essentially pay to see work. And perhaps it’s fair to judge whether or not that industry has been effective in making you think you know Hathaway in a way that you probably do not. But the fact remains that you don’t really know any of these people.

Earlier Dish on Hathaway here.

From The Cutting Room Floor

Keith Phipps finds that watching deleted scenes can radically alter interpretations of a film:

Take Blue Velvet: When David Lynch’s landmark 1986 film was released on Blu-ray 25 years later it contained nearly an hour of previously lost footage. That’s nearly half the running time of the final film, which allows for plenty of room for perception-altering scenes, even one in which the film’s hero Jeffrey (Kyle MacLachlan) watches and initially fails to stop an apparent date rape, a moment that, as Bill Wyman noted in Slate “would have made Blue Velvet a different movie.”

On the one hand, I’m not sorry I watched that scene or the other lost Blue Velvet footage. They’re examples of a filmmaker working at the height of his powers. On the other hand, I wish I had the ability both to watch those scenes and forget it. I’ve seen Blue Velvet many times over the years and I’m sure my next viewing will find me attempting to plug what I’ve seen into the narrative. So that’s what the college Jeffrey’s left to take care of his ailing father looked like [here]. And who knew he dated Megan Mullally while there? [above]

No More Phoning It In, Ctd

Readers sound off on Yahoo’s new policy:

I am a software developer at an interactive agency, I work from home, and I have two insights on Mayer’s decision to eliminate telecommuting. First, our company employs talented people all over the world, because it is very difficult to find enough skilled technology workers; to insist that they also physically live in the same vicinity as your company headquarters is a certain kind of madness. This is slightly less of a problem for companies headquartered in technology hubs like SV or major cities, but it’s a problem nonetheless, so it’s not uncommon to see companies in smaller markets who welcome telecommuters. (As an aside, the synergistic effects of physical interaction and “water cooler time” is offset by all manner of unproductive office distractions. Have you ever been to a meeting? They’re awful.)

Second, I’ve interviewed at Yahoo’s Silicon Valley campus recently.

What I observed was surprising (to me): there are a relatively small number of engineers and designers among an ocean of employees. What do these non-technical people do for Yahoo? I’m not really sure. But there are crowds of them, and Yahoo could probably cut their numbers by a third and never notice the difference. It may be that Mayer is trying to do just that.

Another elaborates on that theory:

Have folks considered that this is just a layoff by another name? Of course Mayer knows that great things are possible with remote workers, and that many Yahoo employees were hired with the understanding of various levels of flexibility. And of course there were alternative approaches of having leaders ask individual teams to come together when brainstorming on new product ideas. But certainly a result of this move is some will leave Yahoo. And maybe that’s needed. Compare it to a conventional layoff, which has some negative publicity (fear of a ‘downward spiral’ of future rounds) but managers get to get rid of the less productive workers (in their eyes). In this case it is likely that some of the more creative folks may attrit.

The Dish of course no longer has an office, but even when we did, we only occasionally went into it. The intense editing of the site is actually far more efficient when we are solo in our blog caves or coffee shops. And naturally the new Dish’s uncertain budget greatly benefits from not having to pay for office space.

Chart Of The Day II

Black Males College

Ivory Toldson discovers that, contrary to popular belief, there are far more black males in college than prison. He thinks the myth has perverse effects:

Consider this: If all 1,127,170 black males who were enrolled in undergraduate programs in 2010 eventually graduated, the total number of black males with college degrees would increase by 71 percent, nearly achieving parity with white males. However, we will not sufficiently support black male college students — nor college-bound students — if we simply keep perpetuating the myth that juxtaposes their needs with those of black males in the criminal-justice system.

(Hat tip: Bouie)

Who Dares Run Against Hillary?

Kornacki wonders:

I would say there’s a decent chance Clinton actually could clear the field and face no serious opposition for the nomination. Not a good chance, but a decent one. This has never happened for a non-incumbent in the modern era, but then again, it’s not like we’re dealing with a huge data set here. And Clinton really is approaching the ’16 race with a set of advantages we’ve never before seen for a non-incumbent. Yes, there’s plenty of time between now and Iowa – time for Clinton to stumble or take a pass on the race, time for Obama to really step in it, time for a real split to open up within the Democratic Party. I’m not calling Clinton a shoo-in for the nomination, or even predicting she’ll run. I’m just arguing that if she does, she could break the mold for non-incumbent candidates of the modern era.

Face Of The Day

Pope Benedict XVI Steps Down And Officially Retires From The Papal Office

Pilgrims wait for Pope Benedict XVI to wave, for the last time as head of the Catholic Church, from the window of Castel Gandolfo where he will start his retirement today on February 28, 2013 in Castel Gandolfo, Italy. Pope Benedict XVI has been the leader of the Catholic Church for eight years and is the first Pope to retire since 1415. He will stay at the Papal Summer residence of Castel Gandolfo until renovations are complete at a monastery in the grounds of the Vatican and will be known as Emeritus Pope. By Oli Scarff/Getty Images.