Dana Perino Isn’t The Only One

A teacher laments:

I have now received three (3) student papers that discuss Iraq’s attack on the Twin Towers on 9/11. All three papers mention it as an aside to another point. I’ve had two papers on the virtue of forgiveness that argue that if we had just forgiven Iraq for the 9/11 attacks, we wouldn’t be at war right now. I just read a paper on the problem of evil which asked why God allowed “the Iraq’s” to attack us on 9/11. The thing that upsets me most here is that the the students don’t just believe that that Iraq was behind 9/11. This is a big fact in their minds, that leaps out at them, whenever they think about the state of the world.

Kieran Healy sighs.

Women In Iraq

In Basra, liberation doesn’t sound so great:

Religious vigilantes have killed at least 40 women this year in the southern Iraqi city of Basra because of how they dressed, their mutilated bodies found with notes warning against "violating Islamic teachings," the police chief said Sunday.

Maj. Gen. Jalil Khalaf blamed sectarian groups that he said were trying to impose a strict interpretation of Islam. They dispatch patrols of motorbikes or unlicensed cars with tinted windows to accost women not wearing traditional dress and head scarves, he added…

In September, the headless bodies of a woman and her 6-year-old son were among those found, he said. A total of 40 deaths were reported this year. "We believe the number of murdered women is much higher, as cases go unreported by their families who fear reprisal from extremists," he said.

In Defense Of Fallujah

"Most Americans think Fallujah is such a bad place. They’ve been hearing about it from Day One. It’s a holy city. I don’t know how many people know that it’s a holy city. The extremists, since it is a holy city, were hiding behind it, were using it for the cause…

I don’t think people really know what to expect from any of this. It’s like people say: you only get the bad news on TV. They don’t get to hear about how Fallujah is doing good now. I’m sure they’d hear about it if something bad happened. But these people are doing better, the schools are open, businesses are open, people are cleaning up their own city. They’re starting their own neighborhood watch. They have their own police force now, their own government. People don’t get to hear about that. I think that’s important for people to know. You shouldn’t focus so much on people who mess up. I mean, people have messed up. Bad stuff has happened. But you should focus on the percentage of people who are doing good as opposed to the percentage who are doing bad. There’s a lot of good going on over here. And there’s a lot of good people in this city," – corporal Brandon Koch, of the 3rd Battalion 5th Regiment’s India Company, in Fallujah, talking with Michel Totten, in a new dispatch from the city.

The General And The Veep

“There’s nobody in uniform who is doing victory dances in the end zone. Success in Iraq is not akin … to flipping on a light switch. Rather it emerges slowly and fitfully with reverses as well as advances. There will inevitably still be tough days and perhaps tough weeks ahead, but fewer of them over time, inshallah," – General David Petraeus.

"We have in fact achieved our objective in terms of having a self-governing Iraq that’s capable for the most part of defending themselves, a democracy in the heart of the Middle East, a nation that will be a positive force in influencing the world around it in the future," – vice president Dick Cheney, predicting the state of affairs in Iraq by mid-January 2009.

“The System Is Working”

My attempt to make sense of where we are in the war on terror – a slightly more rational place than we were two years ago – is here. One reason for very chastened and provisional hope is the astonishing professionalism, humanity and sacrifice of so many troops. Here’s the war-blog of one such individual, making a difference – moral and tactical – in a hell-hole.

The Old Man In The Slum

A reader tipped me off to this haunting and beautifully written blog by an active duty soldier in Iraq. Read as much as you can. It’s a humbling experience. My favorite recent post among many is about the soldier’s accidentally trashing an old Kurdish man’s car with his military truck. He breaks protocol, and gets out to apologize. He tells the old man he will repair the damage. A week later, he returns to the scene of the mishap and looks for the man:

The old man, the elder of this part of the endless slum meets me at his door. He is doubled over, hobbling along with the aide of his cane and his son. His wife is crying and smiling, a unique combination that catches my attention. The old man didn’t appear so frail, so broken when we saw him last. But I realize in that moment, that he had never stood, he had sat in the door way and refused to move all those nights ago. He extends his frail, almost shattered looking hand that bears the scars of foregone dictator, and we shake hands. I look at him the eye, clutch his other shoulder with my free hand and say to him, "I kept my word sir. I told you that I wouldn’t do you wrong." My interpreter and him exchange some durkas and then he replies through sammy, "I never expected an American soldier to understand his word, his promise"…

Our exchange goes on for several minutes and I lay out the details of how he is to collect the money entitled to him for our damage. In fact, the money will be enough probably to replace the entire car but I don’t tell him that, why ruin the surprise. At one point the conversation goes from business to personal and takes on an air of familiarity. This old man begins to feel not like an old man in a ghetto in some city in northern Iraq, but rather an old man, broken and impoverished by a society that moves too fast to notice, much like many of the older men and women back home…

Towards the end of our talk, that has gone from politics to sports (soccer). We even talk of our our women, he shows me pictures of his grandchildren and I show him a picture of my own heart, my lady. At the end of our time together, he pulls me in close, almost to an embrace, grabs my arm and almost in a raspy whisper says "You are a good man. You have the kindest eyes I have known in my life, too kind to be a man of soldiering. You are a man of honor and your heart is kinder than your years.". He releases me, shakes my hand and then turns to walk back into his house. There are tears in my eyes, my legs are shaky and a strong chill startles my spine. Despite being blown -up, shot at, hated, spit at, had shit thrown at, in the middle of this ghetto in some no name neighborhood in the backwoods of a city in northern Iraq, two men met and became friends in the gravest of places. I couldn’t invent that man’s words if given all the time in the world. "You have the kindest eyes.." I will tell my girl that later on the phone and she says nothing, but I can hear the tears on her cheeks and the soft sniffle in her nose. Whats wrong baby I will ask her, why are you crying… I will never forget the old man in the slum.

Libertarianism and the Iraq War

The debate continues. Megan sees complexity:

Libertarians should be inherently more suspicious of the American government’s ability to make things better than other groups–but by the same token, it seems to me that they should be inherently more suspicious of repulsive states such as the dictatorship of Saddam Hussein.

Larison rejoinders:

Isn’t the principle of non-aggression supposed to be at the core of libertarianism? Or has that, too, now ceased to be trendy?

This strikes close to home:

The idea that Hussein’s regime plausibly posed a threat to this country was fantastical. The fact that a lot of people shared this fantasy did not make it any more reasonable.

Guilty as charged. I believed Colin Powell. More thoughts here.