Email of the Day II

A mother writes:

"I could hardly believe the piece about the CSPI.  I am myself a Massachusetts-dyed-in-the-wool liberal, but when I see people using their children to shake their fist at the ocean instead of pointing the fist at their own much deserving cheek, it sickens me.  I have a 2 1/2 year old daughter, so I can sympathize with the tantrum that erupts as as you say no, we aren’t buying Nemo Gummy Juicy Fruits, as they are neither juicy, nor a fruit.  However, I chose to have children and I choose to let them watch the occasional TV show exposing them to the commercial world.  I know it’s easy to roll ones eyes at the left going insane again, but I don’t believe this is a left or a right issue (I have an evangelical Christian friend who would agree with going after the companies who market to children); it’s a laziness issue. More and more parents, both liberal and conservative, are afraid of telling their kids no while at the same time expect the rest of the world to bend over backwards to ensure their children are raised in a good environment."

Yes, bossiness and victimhood are neither right nor left. Increasingly, they’re both. 

An Atheist for Religion

Norm Geras is an admirably honest fellow: a leftist who supports democratization in the Middle East, and an atheist who refuses to dismiss all religion as somehow dangerous or untrue. The truth, as he rightly points out, is much more complex. There are many types of religion. Sadly, fundamentalism of all varieties – Christian, Muslim, Jewish – has somehwat eclipsed the other religious pathways. Worse, in the rants of the Christianist or Islamist right, some fundamentalists have begun to assert that they are the only valid forms of faith. Norm provides some perspective. Money quote:

"In Warsaw in 1943, a Polish Catholic risks her life to save an endangered Jew. She does so because she has been taught from childhood that all people are the children of God and it is a sin to take innocent life. How, in the face of that – which has happened plenty, and in many other historical variants as well – can one say there has been no good in religion, or that this good is merely apparent because of what it is mixed together with? I could give more than this, but it is enough. Just two things: that religious believers have often been motivated by their beliefs to act in beneficent, caring, selfless, heroic ways; and that there are universalist variants of religious belief which, in historical context, have marked a significant progress for humankind – that is quite enough empirically, against the notion that the bad in religion undoes the good."

I’m not sure that’s quite enough. Religion can be a force for both good and evil. Fundamentalism, however, skews the balance toward the bad. Which is why it is up to the rest of us people of faith, those of us who are not fundamentalists, to criticize and call to account the extremists now giving faith a bad name.

Email of the Day

A reader writes:

"As an American, Jew and Zionist, one might expect me to feel a stronger connection with the Christian fundamentalists who are political allies on the Israel issue. But as a 25 year-old male with a healthy libido and healthy understanding of sexuality, I’d swim with the Muslim Aussie girls any day before the Christian girls wearing those (dis)respecting outfits. I mean, that’s just a long t-shirt waiting to get all wet, hot, and bothered. Can’t you see that Andrew? Wait, no, I guess you might not be able to. ;-)"

:-(