"Suppose that intellectuals of the left were thinking more clearly about the American nation as (a) a whole and (b) a work in progress? Suppose that ideas about actual American potential proved more appealing on the putatively left-wing campus than sticking up, in code and despair (albeit with flourishes), for all kinds of exotic indeterminacies, theological neo-Marxisms, and third-worldist romantic fancies?" – Todd Gitlin, TPM Cafe.
"There can be no doubt that the left in general, but the campus variety in particular, is profoundly pessimistic and dour in its attitude towards this country. It seems to be built in to the DNA of campus leftist activism to be as over-the-top as possible in describing America as a den of corruption and injustice. It is the luxury of students who by and large have never known what true corruption and injustice look like but who are attracted to the romance of revolutionary thinking," – a reader from TPM Cafe.
Both writers go on to criticize the right, or aspects of the right. Fine. But what we are beginning to see on the honest right and honest left is a genuine attempt to re-think the world after the last five years. It needs rethinking; both "sides" have an internal accounting to do for their positions; and the calcified rhetoric on both extremes is an attempt to stop it.
The Dish 