Give me today to address his many good (and bad) points. But something strikes me reading the many emails you have sent. They fall into two categories: one batch lamenting his contradictions, intolerance and dogmatism; the other insisting that he has cleaned my clock in the argument. There are few emails taking a middle position, which suggests we are talking past each other. I’m going to try and amend that in my next post. It may be, however, that the very nature of the subject renders consensus or even clarity impossible. Those with faith and those without it actually read the dialogue differently. I think we can do better than that – and I hope to clarify more in my next installment.