Spending More And Saving Money

Suderman is unhappy with how healthcare bill costs are being presented:

It's true that the reform bills, as written, produce some savings by cutting certain types of Medicare expenditures. But that money is then repurposed to help pay for subsidies so that lower-income people can buy insurance. And that money only pays for some of the new expenditures in the bill. The rest comes from either a surtax on expensive insurance plans (in the Senate plan) or a new tax on couples who earn more than a million dollars a year and individuals who earn more than $500,000 a year (the House plan). Either way, what these bills do isn't save money. Instead, they spend more, but also bring in more revenue through new taxes, theoretically resulting in a lower deficit over the long haul.

Face Of The Day

GUYFAWKESMikeHewitt:Getty

11-year old Conor Hewitt makes light circles with a sparkler during Bonfire night celebrations on November 5, 2009 in Brighton, England. Guy Fawkes Night, also known as Bonfire night and Fireworks night is an annual celebration that takes place across the United Kingdom to mark the downfall of the Gunpowder plot of November 5, 1605. By Mike Hewitt/Getty Images.

Fort Worth Raid Update

A reader writes:

Just wanted to give you a heads up – the breaking news here in Dallas is that both the Fort Worth Police and TABC are releasing their internal investigations into the Rainbow Lounge incident today.

Unsurprisingly, both the FWPD and the TABC are reporting that none of their officers used excessive force or inappropriately targeted a gay bar for a shakedown. None of the officers involved from the FWPD will be fired; two TABC agents were already fired. The Fort Worth Star-Telegram reports that some of the officers involved will be "disciplined" for such dire infractions as not turning in their incident paperwork on time. In other words, "Johnson, you get me that write-up of yesterday's queer hunt, or I'll have your ass!"

Disappointing, to say the least.

Lessons From Virginia

Some smart observations from Larry Sabato:

Democratic National Committee Chairman and Virginia Gov. Tim Kaine is also high up on the list of losers. He presided over an electoral debacle in his own state. Unlike his predecessor, Gov. Mark Warner, he failed to prepare the way for a Democratic successor in Richmond and probably made a serious mistake in becoming chairman at all. It took him out of state too much and made him a partisan rather than a unifying figure. National ambitions have tripped up four of the last five Virginia governors. When you only have one four-year term, maybe the voters expect you to take care of business at home. Bob McDonnell might want to remember that when he is touted for the 2012 national GOP ticket. 

Turnout played a huge role in the outcomes in both NJ and VA, with Republicans showing up in droves and Democrats going fishing, at least to some degree. In Virginia, one result of absentee Democrats was the lowest voter turnout for a gubernatorial election in the state's modern two-party history (1969 to 2009). The 2009 turnout of 39.8 percent of the registered voters was the lowest in forty years. Even with all the population growth since 2005, the absolute voter turnout in 2009 (1.97 million) fell below that of four years ago (2.0 million). And the electorate was barely more than half that of 2008 (3.7 million). Astounding.

Tears Over Cappuccinos

A reader writes:

I'm sitting in a coffee shop and I watched the video of the girl being surprised by her father, and I'm literally crying. A barrista comes up and asks me what's wrong, and I show her the video, and she's crying. A couple of other people gather, and they're crying. The whole damned coffee shop is crying.

It did the same thing to me. The love in that moment expressed in the child's face is simply unforgettable.

Improving, Ever So Slowly

Jobs

Free Exchange glances at this week's job numbers:

Even as production grows, firms are slashing jobs, wringing more out of fewer workers. Hours worked declined as well, a bad sign for recovery in labour markets. In the manufacturing sector, productivity was up 13.6%. "It’s a favorable environment for profits," deadpanned Barclays Capital's Dean Maki. That's a pretty stunning number. It suggests growth will have to be a lot faster to begin creating jobs, and it indicates, once more, that inflation poses absolutely no threat to the economy. It's a perfect time for a more aggressive approach to monetary policy, and I wouldn't be surprised if this contributed to enthusiasm for measures that subsidise hiring.

Thinking Of The Children, Ctd

A reader writes:

As a straight man, I've found that the best answer to my children's questions about gay couples is the simplest: they love each other just like mommy and me. They have accepted this observation without any confusion on their part.

That's certainly the case with the kids in our family. I remember the first time my young niece and nephew came to Provincetown to visit me and Aaron (before our marriage). We never sat them down and told them we were gay. We didn't tell them what our relationship was (they were 8 and 11 respectively). But after a couple of days, my niece asked about a trip we were planning: "Is uncle Aaron coming?" She got it instantly. Kids not told that gay people are evil do not see us as evil; and they see our marriages as like any others. My niece can actually recite by heart the vows we took at our wedding, which is more than I can do any more. But this is still obviously a work in progress across the country and the world. Another reader writes:

With regard to your reader's comments, my partner and I own a home in a typical neighborhood on the South Shore of Boston.  Every Halloween we carve a pumpkin and buy candy for the trick or treaters.  And for the past eight years we have lived here, we watch as several families with little ones visit every house on our street except ours.  We have watched families literally cross to the other side of the street of the street and glare at our house as they walk by.  We do not know these people, but clearly they have been informed about us, the homosexual couple who lives down the street.  This happens in Massachusetts; this

isn't even Oklahoma.

I am willing to entertain the notion that parents are generally uncomfortable about discussing sex, and especially homosexuality, with their children, but do they vote against gay marriage because of discomfort?  Let's be very clear about this: the anti gay marriage crowd repeats the false argument that homosexuality will be taught in school because it alludes to age old myths and smears about homosexuals as recruiters, corrupters and predators of youth.  That's bigotry.  Perhaps it appeals to a subconscious form of bigotry, but it's bigotry all the same.

Another British reader writes:

In my experience children are extremely pragmatic and totally unburdened by preconceptions and prejudices, unless these have been previously inculcated by adults. Instead they find it more difficult to grasp arbitrary rules and distinctions – for example, the five year old son of a black friend of mine thought she was joking when she gently introduced the subject of racism. Adults may find some concepts embarrassing or awkward, but if they’re presented in a no nonsense, strictly factual way, kids will accept them at face value.

When she asks questions, my five year old daughter is told matter-of-factly that she can marry anyone she wants outside her own family (we choose not to differentiate between civil partnerships and marriage at this stage and hopefully that will be irrelevant when the time comes);  and that while most people choose to marry someone of the opposite sex, you can choose to marry the same sex if you want.  As a result she didn’t bat an eyelid when she found out that a little boy in her class had ‘two mommies’, though most of the parents found it intriguing.

For the record her current plan is to marry her best friend (another little girl, as she is currently very disapproving of boys in general), become a palaeontologist and have six kids.

Good luck with that!

The Not So Best And Brightest

Andrea Stone reports:

The latest Army statistics show a stunning 75 percent of military-age youth are ineligible to join the military because they are overweight, can't pass entrance exams, have dropped out of high school or had run-ins with the law.

So many young people between the prime recruiting ages of 17 and 24 cannot meet minimum standards that a group of retired military leaders is calling for more investment in early childhood education to combat the insidious effects of junk food and inadequate education. "We've never had this problem of young people being obese like we have today," said Gen. John Shalikashvili, former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

Meanwhile, we're throwing out qualified West Point Arab linguists – because they are gay. Insane.