Putting A Pencil Together

Dani Rodrik challenges Milton Friedman's riff on free markets from "Free to Choose," seen above. Most of the world's pencils today are produced in China, "an economy that is a peculiar mix of private entrepreneurship and state direction":

[T]he present-day pencil story would be incomplete without citing China’s state-owned firms, which made the initial investments in technology and labor training; lax forest management policies, which kept wood artificially cheap; generous export subsidies; and government intervention in currency markets, which gives Chinese producers a significant cost advantage. China’s government has subsidized, protected, and goaded its firms to ensure rapid industrialization, thereby altering the global division of labor in its favor. … Given China’s economic success, it is hard to deny the contribution made by the government’s industrialization policies.