By Patrick Appel
"U.S. presidential candidate Barack Obama talks about 16 months. That, we think, would be the right timeframe for a withdrawal, with the possibility of slight changes," – Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki.
Category: The Dish
Electoral College No More
By Patrick Appel
Matt wants to get rid of the electoral college. Hendrik Hertzberg has similar wishes:
…once Americans have experienced the advantages of one or two national popular elections—dramatically higher turnout, campaigns waged on national issues, political energy in every corner of the country, candidates turning up in more than a dozen or so states, every vote counting equally, and no more red state/blue state blather (to say nothing of no more losers stumbling into the White House)—the new arrangement will quickly be formalized in the Constitution itself.
Turf Wars And The Anti-Lawnists
By Patrick Appel
Elizabeth Kolbert gives a brief history of the American lawn:
What began as a symbol of privilege and evolved into an expression of shared values has now come to represent expedience. We no longer choose to keep lawns; we just keep on keeping them. In the meantime, the familiar image of Dad cutting the grass and then, beer in hand, sitting back to admire his work, is, in many communities, a fiction: increasingly, lawn care has become another one of those jobs, like cooking dinner or playing with the kids, that’s outsourced to someone else.
(Image by Flikr user great sea.)
The Show Must Go On
By Patrick Appel
While Andrew is away, I’ll be checking his e-mail account and posting reader dissents, responses, and window views as per usual. As Politics Of Scrabble remarked this week, blogs act as a "portal to the vast fields of information out there to be harvested" working as "second-by-second synthesizing plants and clearing houses" for news and opinion. We’ll do our best to keep the blog chugging along. Don’t hesitate to e-mail.
A Breather
I’m taking a vacation next week and working on an essay for the Atlantic magazine the week after. I’m leaving this blog in the interim in the very capable hands of Patrick Appel, my aide de blogue, and two Dish alums, Jessie Roberts, my ancien aide de blogue and Chris Bodenner, former Dish intern and now Hotline wunderkind. They’ll be trawling the web and blogosphere for the familiar Dish goodies, and revealing how superfluous I am fast becoming in these parts. Next week, they’ll also be joined by Hilary Bok, Hilzoy of Obsidian Wings, and the week after by Daniel Larison, whose blog, Eunomia, is currently at the American Conservative. I don’t know how to categorize either Hilary or Daniel, which is why they are particularly welcome at the Dish. But I do know they’re two of the freshest, sharpest new voices to have emerged from the blogosphere. Welcome to my parlor, said the spider, etcetera.
I’ll be back in August and balls-to-the-wall till November. Reculer pour mieux sauter. And all that.
McCain’s First Negative Ad
That’s what Domenico Montanaro is calling it. McCain’s new TV ad takes on Obama over Iraq:
Romney In 2012
Ruffini says Romney shouldn’t go for veep:
Mitt Romney is already in line to be the nominee in 4 years if McCain loses under the GOP Law of Primogeniture. Why would he want to muck it up with a VP run? If McCain loses, it is all downside for Mitt. People would forget all the positive aspects of his Presidential run and remember his role on a losing ticket. (See Edwards, John.)
Conservatives For Obama?
The conversation deepens. Steven Taylor admits:
The main positive reason I can conjure for voting for McCain is divided government. However, since the current divided government situation has not generated much in terms of addressing these keys issues about executive power, one wonders about that argument as well. At a minimum I find myself for the first time in my life in a position where I could see myself voting Democratic, Republican or Libertarian. And, I suspect that I am not alone. I was having a conversation the other day with a lifelong friend who is also a lifelong conservative. He concurred that he, too, had a similar view on the choices and his own possible voting behavior.
Bainbridge replies in the comments:
I can sympathise with your position, but I have just three words of caution: Judges, judges, judges.
Joyner counters Taylor:
I see no reason to think that Obama would be less prone to interventionism than McCain. My strong sense is that he’d model himself after Bill Clinton and be eager to use military force for humanitarian and do-gooder reasons, whereas McCain would be more likely to use force aggressively in pursuit of security goals.
Nor do I have any reason to believe Obama would be less prone than McCain to overreach in his use of executive power to advance what he believes to be legitimate and necessary goals. Indeed, Obama’s seeming lack of sense of humor and condemnation of any and all criticism as beyond the pale worries me greatly on that front.
But He’s Super Serial!, Ctd
James Pethokoukis tallies the cost of Gore’s call for 100% renewable energy by 2018:
By my math, using Pickens’s numbers, converting the whole economy to renewable energy in a short period of time might cost $5 trillion—and that is if you assume that government-led projects come in on budget. (Remember, the current U.S. gross domestic product is $12 trillion.) That would be like creating another Japan. Or fighting World War II all over again. The latter analogy is especially apt since the Gore Plan would effectively transform our free-market economy into a command-and-control war economy full of rationing and scarcity. Of course, there are many folks like Gore who view global warming as the moral equivalent of war. But Gore would extend the concept into the economic equivalent of war. Again, all this makes sense if you think we are doomed otherwise.
Sara Barz rounds up blogosphere reaction.
Bill Buckley, Poseur
That accent? C’mon. A reader vents:
Your post on your colleague Megan lamenting the end of the American "upper class" accent was interesting. I would venture to guess that this accent disappeared because it was an affectation more than a genuine accent. I had a Connecticut born, Yale-educated prep school teacher (long deceased) who used to talk like that. We, his students, all knew that if he was given enough gin he was perfectly able to speak "normally." The Texas drawl, African-American speech, the Boston brogue, the speech patterns of the Deep South or Northeastern Maine — all of these are genuine accents rooted in culture and migratory patterns. The "upper class" American accent, which arguably did descend from American Yankee inflections, was also known as a "mid-Atlantic" accent and it was largely a creation of the movies.
In Hollywood’s Golden Age there was a small industry devoted to training "thespians" to talk like this (there’s a wonderful scene in "Singin’ In The Rain" that satirizes this fetish). My ex-mother-in-law, the daughter of a California rancher and a Hollywood starlet during this era, continued to use her "upper class" accent until she died a few years ago. This way of talking metastasized nation-wide through the movies and died out as the old studio system died. It’s been widely reported that even William F. Buckley, an arch practitioner of this way of speaking, was the only member of his family who spoke like that. To the extend the "accent" was phony (even if unselfconsciously so on the part of those who used it), I suppose one could say "good riddance, y’all."
Another reader adds:
The expert on the historical tides underlying the decline of the "upper-class" accent that Megan McArdle mourns is William Labov, a sociolinguist at the University of Pennsylvania. His findings are more subtle, and more interesting, than the sudden death perceived by McArdle. Labov’s work was covered nicely by The New Yorker’s John Seabrook in 2005, available on the web here.

