Superiority

Bora Zivkovic believes religion evolved to encourage group cohesion:

For the group cohesion to work, one HAS to, by definition, feel that one’s group is superior to all other groups. This sense of superiority is enhanced by the additional "attachments" that may differ between different religious traditions, e.g., the belief in an inerrancy of the leader who gets orders directly from the group’s omnipotent god(s), various trance-inducing chants and dances, behavioral rules, sacred books, etc. All of these also promote internal policing by the group – those of "weak faith" are detected and punished mainly by other members, not necessarily by any kind of official armed forces, though some groups may use the latter as well.

So that’s how the Republican party machine works.

Peak Convenience?

Robert Rapier wrestles with our energy conundrum:

The thought struck me as I got ready for work a couple of days ago that we may have reached ‘peak convenience’ as a result of high oil prices, which I believe are here to stay. Most people are going to find that certain conveniences that we have taken for granted during the age of cheap oil are less attainable (i.e., more expensive) than they once were. I can see a future in which something like the morning shower shifts to later in the day, after the solar water heater has had time to heat up the water. Or we have to drop our electrical usage way down at night because our solar output has dropped off. People are definitely going to have to become accustomed to tracking their electricity usage, to avoid a very big surprise at the end of the month. (On the flip side, I think we will continue to make medical and technological advances, so it isn’t as if I think we are headed back to the Stone Age).

More On That New Yorker Cover

Zengerle hyperventilates:

…the image is satirical only because it appears on the cover of the New Yorker, which, we all know, is a right-thinking magazine read by right-thinking people who couldn’t possibly be among the 10 percent of Americans who believe Obama’s a Muslim. The New Yorker assumes everyone knows it’s being ironic with its cover, sort of the way the white hipster in a gentrifying neighborhood assumes everyone knows he’s being ironic when he wears a "Stop Snitching" t-shirt. But put that image on the cover of National Review, or that t-shirt on a black person in a crime-infested neighborhood, and the message takes on a very different meaning.

Ezra is calmer:

…this is a cartoon.

The very medium mocks and dismisses the content of the picture. Anyone who didn’t get the joke would be left looking at a caricatured illustration, not a believable image of Obama gripping bin-Laden’s portrait. What’s actually happening, I think, is that the New Yorker is a physical institution that can be criticized, while the e-mail forwards and talk radio whispers actually fueling these rumors — in their believable, not their cartoon, forms — won’t stand still long enough to be subject to public opprobrium.

It’s July, isn’t it?

Quote For The Day

"But in all seriousness here, we haven’t had a recession—there is an economic slow down. I share your concern. Everybody I talk to is furious at $4.50 a gallon for gasoline, especially when they know we have more resources than the Middle East, but I want to know. I want to ask you this. I’ve met people that grew up in tyranny. I knew people that grew up in the former Soviet Union for fear of speaking out against their government. Never had an opportunity to pursue their dreams … In this country, maybe we do, is there some truth to the fact, maybe we do whine too much. Maybe we don’t to appreciate this gift we have of freedom. Maybe we don’t take advantage of, maybe too many of us look to the government to solve every problem we have," – Sean Hannity.

A “Huge Swing” To The Dems?

New voter registration in Florida is raising some eyebrows:

Through May, Democratic voter registration in Broward County was up 6.7 percent. Republican registrations grew just 3 percent while independents rose 2.8 percent. Democrats have posted even greater gains statewide, up 106,508 voters from January through May, compared with 16,686 for the Republicans. "It’s a huge swing," says Marian Johnson, political director for the Florida Chamber of Commerce. "I looked at that and said, ‘Wow.’"

Judge Judy Republicans

I think that moniker is a little more fitting – if a little less marketable – for Ross’ and Reihan’s hoped-for constituency than "Sam’s Club" Republicans. After all, the problem with the working poor, as GNP has it, is not that they’re capable of finding shopping bargains and living within their means. It’s that they’re sinking in a welter of family dysfunction and economic distress – and end up like the plaintiffs on Judge Judy. Why are they sinking? GNP blames the elites for getting jiggy with it in the 1960s and 1970s and setting a bad example for those without the resources to cope adequately with extra- and pre-marital sex, contracepted intercourse, divorce, re-marriage, and so on.

Now, in an extra twist of the sociological knife, the yuppies and elite boomers and wealthy urbanites have actually gotten their act together more, are bringing up their kids well, and often sticking together in later, more durable marriages. The poorer Red Staters, meanwhile, are still getting abortions, raising criminal kids, doing drugs and generally failing to stay afloat. I exaggerate, of course. The book adds layers of explanation to this, including, critically, the impact of Bell Curve style assortative mating and social stratification. But this is the gist.

GNP‘s answer is to shift financial resources to working poor families, specifically those with children. To put it uncharitably, they want to tax those who have gotten their act together and give the money to those who haven’t yet. With the extra cash from wage subsidies or child credits, these poorer folks might then have the resources to keep one parent at home, and be better citizens all round. At least that’s the hope.

And hope is the operative word. The newly working poor may also keep their sexual adventures, poor parenting, multiple spouses – and their wage subsidies as well. Who can say? Since GNP doesn’t actually condition the new money on any behavioral changes – they balk at reserving child credits for the married, for example – there isn’t much leverage for social improvement, and one fears that the scheme could end up as essentially a bribe for an electoral demographic the GOP increasingly needs. Say it ain’t so, Ross.

But my deeper question is really about how things like family breakdown can actually be put back together by government. I’m not sure they can. Yes, you can remove actual disincentives for marriage and work, as in welfare reform. But using government to remoralize society on this kind of scale? A fundamentalist religious revival has made no dent on the poor morals of the red states, so why would wage subsidies? And if this remoralization doesn’t work out, aren’t you just left with a vast redistributionist scheme?

Post-Modern Steel

This Nate Silver post strikes me as about right:

"That does not mean that the Obama that emerges from Lizza’s piece is particularly warm and cuddly. He is certainly a very political creature, and there is something a little steely and postmodern about it all. But it is also not clear that Obama is playing some kind of angle. He seems, rather, to hold a lot of fairly mainstream, somewhat empirically-driven views — still an idealist in certain ways, but not highly ideological. The White House may represent to him some sort of final step in his self-actualization, but he’s not going there to get a blow job, or to play out some sort of Oedipal complex. It’s all actually sort of … boring."

“The Defeat Of Al Qaeda”

The new – and, one must say, agreeable – debate over Iraq is whether, even if we manage to get out of there without full-scale catastrophe now, the entire adventure has been worth it. Obama’s op-ed this morning emphatically says no. Pete Wehner makes the opposite case:

It is far from clear that Iraq will be judged a strategic blunder at all, let alone the “greatest strategic blunder in the recent history of American foreign policy.” It is now plausible to argue that the Iraq war will lead to a defeat of historic proportions for al Qaeda. It has already triggered a massive Sunni Muslim uprising against al Qaeda, a repudiation of violent jihadism from some of its original architects, and a significant shift within the Muslim world against the brutal tactics of jihadists. Iraq is also, right now, the only authentic democracy in the Arab world. And Saddam Hussein, the most aggressive and destabilizing force in the Middle East for the last several decades, is dead, and his genocidal regime is now but an awful, infamous memory.

The last part is, it seems to me, obviously true. Whether removing Saddam was worth the deaths of hundreds of thousands, displacement of millions, empowerment of Iran, ethnic cleansing on a massive scale, $1 trillion, $145 a barrel oil, up to 5,000 coalition deaths, and the resurgence of al Qaeda in Pakistan and Afghanistan is another matter.

Whether we could have found a less traumatizing, expensive, fatal path past Saddam will be for historians to judge. But it is worth remembering, as Pete somehow omits, that the fundamental casus belli – the WMD threat from Saddam – was false. And we removed Saddam over five years ago. The war since is what we are discussing.

So then the next argument: "a defeat of historic proportions for al Qaeda." We can hope. But it remains a fact that the only reason al Qaeda needed to be defeated on such a scale in Iraq is because the US created the perfect conditions for its flourishing: anarchy, social disintegration, and sectarian clashes. To have cleaned up the mess we made is not some kind of world-historical step forward. It’s treading water. And it must also be noted that in many ways, al Qaeda defeated itself by its extreme tactics. The same could be said for al Qaeda in Jordan, for example. Democracy in Iraq? Well, it is a fragile achievement so far, but it would be very premature to believe it’s stable or long-lasting or irreversible.

The question now is whether these tentative signs of calm in Iraq are a good opportunity to leave or a reason to stay for the very long haul. Or whether we’ll just stagger on in some kind of unresolved middle.