McCain’s “God’s Children” Ad

Here’s the pitch on immigration that seems to target Tom Tancredo. The hard right is offended:

This sounds now like a deliberate provocation to the Right, who in fairness have never — never — discounted the contributions of Hispanic citizens and legal residents, especially not their long history of service to this nation.  The issue is illegal immigration and border security, not whether we know that Americans of Hispanic descent have risked and given their lives for us.

This is a monumentally stupid ad. It spends a full minute saying nothing about the issue it supposedly addresses, and it insults the intelligence of the people whom McCain is trying to woo. And I’m someone who has a little more sympathy for McCain’s efforts on immigration than most on the Right. Take two big steps backward, Senator McCain.

I loved it.

Someone Got It Right

In September 2006, in some of the darkest hours in Iraq, Mario Loyola wrote a very prescient piece in NRO on Iraq. Since so many – including me – have gotten so much wrong (and understandably in the opaque chaos of post-Saddam Iraq), it’s worth tipping the hat to someone who got it right and for the right reasons. The piece is reprinted here. Money quote:

As the months pass, the struggle for Iraqi democracy is rapidly becoming Iraq’s fight. Nearly all military operations in Iraq today are either joint or Iraqi-led. Coalition casualties have evened out, while those of the Iraqi security forces have increased dramatically. These are grim but telling statistics. Iraq’s government of national unity is not out of danger yet. But given its broad representation of Iraq’s communities–and the absence of any real competition–it is getting harder to see how it can fail. And victory by default is victory all the same.

The Latest From Hewitt’s Cocoon

He’s decided to stick with his original plan of describing Obama as a commie alien. To buttress this idea, he writes:

Obama strongly supports same-sex marriage, and opposes the California amendment to restore the definition of marriage and rebuke the California Supreme Court’s usurpation of the people’s authority to define such a basic right, in a stroke putting himself on the far left edge of the crucial debates on marriage and the role of the judiciary.

Actually, of course, Obama has consistently (alas) opposed marriage equality. Obama supports civil unions that provide the same benefits as civil marriage, but not full equality within the same civil institution. More to the point, if you look at the most recent national Gallup poll on the subject, fully 30 percent support marriage equality and a further 27 percent favor civil unions. So, according to Hewitt, some 57 percent of Americans are on the "far left edge" of the debate. It’s only the "far left edge" if you want to deny gay couples all legal rights and stigmatize them permanently in the constitution of their own country.

The Boot Drops Again

Max Boot once again attacks my position on Iraq. He concedes:

I will end on a note of concurrence. “If the Iraqis ask us to leave, we have no business staying,” you write. I agree. My point was that the Iraqis aren’t asking us to leave because, unlike you and other anti-war voices in the United States, they realize that the consequences of a an overly hasty American pullout would be catastrophic.

But the Iraqis aren’t asking for an "overly hasty" pullout. They are asking for assurances of an eventual withdrawal. There’s more:

"perhaps you could provide some convincing evidence that the U.S. can invade a country, topple its regime, leave immediately – and expect a lasting, positive outcome."

Leave immediately? Does Max know what year it is? But maybe he could ask Bill Kristol the same question. Kristol and Kaplan argued for the war thus:

As other countries’ forces arrive, and as Iraq rebuilds its economy and political system, that [75,000] force could probably be drawn down to several thousand soldiers after a year or two.

Several thousand after a year or two. We are now in year six with 150,000 still there. You’d think that people who had made such confident predictions might show a little humility at this point. But let me remind Boot that there was no mention before the war that we were there to secure oil supplies as he now argues.

In fact, that very idea was regarded as a left-wing smear. Nor were we told that we would invade and occupy a country indefinitely in order to "protect our interests" in the region. We were told there was a terrible threat to our security; and this was untrue. And then we were told that leaving would be a terrible threat to our security. And now we are told that a commitment to leaving by 2011 would be a threat to our security. It is not unreasonable for people to ask when the neocons will ever feel it is safe to leave – or if leaving was ever their intention in the first place.

Look: the good news is that for reasons I didn’t see, Iraq is now in a much better place than almost anyone foresaw a year ago. The better news is that even those of us who have argued about this for years can now agree that we have a better chance of getting out now without catastrophe than we did at any time in the past five years. No one wants to foment chaos there. And extricating will be tricky and require pragmatism. But I do not think I’m being unreasonable or reckless in hoping that we can finally bring closure to this debacle after eight years at a cost of up to $3 trillion, hundreds of thousands of innocent deaths, and approaching 5,000 dead Americans and tens of thousands of Americans severely injured for life. If that is "leaving immediately", or a "precipitous withdrawal", then heaven knows what Max Boot thinks is empire.

PEPFAR Next Week

The threat to removing the HIV immigration ban comes from a point of order. Here’s what can happen:

Opponents of the bill will likely raise a Budget Point of Order against the bill. This is nothing but a thinly veiled attempt to kill the bill.

The non-partisan Congressional Budget Office has examined the bill, and – based on its calculations – believes the bill would result in $83 million, over the next ten years, in direct spending in domestic costs – the anticipated costs of additional immigrants to the United States that would result from the provision lifting the statutory ban on HIV-positive individuals coming to the United States.  In order to cover these costs, the bill requires the U.S. Department of State to raise the cost of applying for a visitor’s visa by $1 for years 2010-12 and by $2 for years 2013-2018.  Using very conservative averages of recent years of some 8 million visa applicants per year, such a structure will easily raise over $100 million, thus providing more than sufficient funding to cover these costs. 

The $50 billion authorized in the bill is subject to future appropriations, and hence is not subject to any budget points of order. The bill is PAYGO compliant because it does not increase the deficit over the next ten years.  It is also not subject to a long-term deficit point of order. However, because the costs outlined by CBO were not included in the Senate Budget resolution, a budget point of order vote lies against the bill.  In order to win that vote, at least 60 Senators must vote to waive the point of order.  If that threshold is not crossed, the bill will fail.

The CBO estimate, however, doesn’t take into account the taxes that many productive HIV-positive immigrants will pay. But the bottom line is that we need 60 Senators. Please email yours if you haven’t.

Bush Targets Obama

More details are emerging about Obama’s Germany trip and the president’s determination to meddle with it.:

Deputy Treasury Secretary Robert Kimmitt told the mass circulation tabloid Bild that "it would be nice if the German government would focus on strengthening its contacts to us rather than already beginning to look for our successors."

And this:

"It’s said that the Chancellor’s foreign policy advisor, Christoph Heusgen, was berated by a member of the Bush team over Obama’s plans at the G-8 summit in Japan."

And it turns out that speeches at the Brandenburg Gate are pretty much a dime a dozen. It looks to me as if the Bushies are desperate to prevent Obama getting an ovation in Europe. Given the disdain and contempt of much of the European public for Bush, and the powerful advantage the Europe trip will give Obama, it’s understandable. But no less tacky.

Obama In Europe

Obama08chipsomodevillagetty

My English gut tells me Ambers is right:

Obama’s trip to Europe will be a huge event…maybe as big as his convention, maybe as big as a debate. Sheer curiosity will translate into enormous crowds, even as most of Obama’s events will be small and pooled. The European press will climax, repeatedly.

I predict an extended media orgasm as well. Europeans are desperate to fall in love with America again. This young, black Kennedy figure will likely create iconic scenes – reminding the old of the America that once inspired them and the young of the capacity for change that America still contains. And it’s simply great theater.

One thing we have learned about the Obama campaign that has been overlooked: they understand theater. In fact, no campaign has understood theater this way – and its powerful relationship to politics  – since Deaver managed Reagan.

(Photo: Obama in Virginia this week by Chip Somodevilla/Getty.)