The Hubris Of Obama?

A few things have unsettled me these past couple of weeks about the Obama campaign. It is not the small adjustments to previously-held positions – FISA, the Second Amendment, Iraq. It’s a sense that Obama’s ample self-regard is lapsing into hubris. The signs of this are pretty trivial on the surface, but they are troubling nonetheless.

That simulated faux-presidential seal was both tacky, silly and presumptive – a small version of "Mission Accomplished" Obama could well do without. The decision to give his acceptance speech in a stadium, rather than the traditional convention hall is also an unnecessary over-reach. The night will be freighted enough with history; it needs no new drama to set it apart. And the drama of the first black man accepting the nomination – with Obama’s rhetorical brilliance – will be more than enough for impact. Lastly, I was gob-smacked by the Obamas’ decision to include their children in a soft-focus TV interview.

I can barely credit that Michelle Obama agreed to this and that Barack Obama went along with it – it’s not what they would have done a few months ago. One great aspect of the Obama marriage has been the way in which they appear to have brought up their daughters as very regular girls, down-to-earth, normal and sane. Displaying them in this way was bad judgment and poor parenting. Fame is a toxin. Children deserve to be protected from it as much as they would from lead paint.

Any one of these misjudgments would be a trivial lapse – and we all make mistakes. It’s the combination that concerns me – and the possibility that this campaign is becoming far too cocky for its own good.

Ezra Is Too Kind

Chait chides Obama bloggers for treating "Clinton and her fans with kid gloves":

I can see the attractiveness of the party line that Democrats are all united, and only Republicans and sexists want to suggest otherwise. I can also see the utility of trying to remember all that was good about Hillary Clinton, and paying homage to the sexism she endured, so that her supporters don’t feel do disrespected. The fact remains, however, that Clinton surrounded herself with some unattractive characters and, not coincidentally, ran a nasty, demagogic, anti-intellectual campaign, and did some non-trivial damage to the causes she claimed to be fighting for. Pointing this out now doesn’t help Obama, but I’m not working for his campaign.

Go Chait!

Exhausting Gallium?, Ctd

The blogosphere slowly unveils the complicated truth. A reader writes:

The issue isn’t how much gallium exists, it’s how much can be recovered economically. Gallium is a trace element, so it can’t be mined; it has to be extracted chemically from other minerals.

It exists in concentrations of only 50 parts per million in bauxite and zinc ores. So yes, there may be a global reserve of 1 million tons of gallium; but you might have to mine 20 billion tons (!) of other minerals to recover that. That’s why only 100 tons of gallium is produced annually. Even that much required the extraction of millions of tons of ores. We’re unlikely ever to run out of gallium, but as other minerals are depleted it will become increasingly expensive to extract and use. It’s the same basic problem that we have with oil: there is plenty of the stuff left in the ground, but we are rapidly using up the portion of it that we can recover economically.

The Same Obama

A must-read from Gail Collins (yes, you read that right). I have yet to see any real change in the kind of politician Obama has always been in the last month or so. Collins is right that the only true U-turn is on public financing, but that is about winning. Obama has already, on many issues, defused polarization, despite frantic attempts by Fox News, the Clinton campaign and the lazy media to force him into a super-blue box. His very emergence has done wonders for the Iraq debate. I see no reason not to think that the hopes I placed on him in "Goodbye to All That" are being slowly, fitfully, imperfectly realized.

Not Ready On Day One, Ctd

Reihan responds to Gordon and Kvaal:

I support John McCain, and I recognize that he’s facing a very tough political environment. That’s why he is often forced to embrace positions that are very much in tension with each other. My suspicion is that if McCain were running far ahead of the competition, if he faced a less polarized political environment, you’d see him embrace a different, more coherent set of policies.

Which means to say: he’s a politician, not a maverick crusader. But I’d say the climate is actually less polarized now than, say, four years ago. And Reihan’s point raises the obvious question: will McCain’s actual policies be incoherent in office – with a Democratic Congress and a restive, disloyal base?

About That Engagement …

Charlie Crist refines his plan to get married before the election:

In fact, Crist said, during the early 1980’s, a few years after his marriage, he had a romantic relationship with a Maryland woman he met at Ronald Reagan’s inaugural, and the two became engaged. They then broke up, but reunited later and got engaged again. Counting Rome, his engagement to his former wife, and the two engagements to the Maryland woman, Crist said, he has been now been engaged a total of four times.

Why I Can Live With The FISA Deal

A reader writes:

In regards to the FISA capitulation, you’ve helped answer one of your oft-asked questions – where’s the anger? You ask this in relation to torture and have ended several posts with "get angrier". I couldn’t agree more, and I can’t understand your indifference to telecom immunity and this FISA BS. The same principle is in play for torture and FISA – whether the country is ruled by men or ruled by laws. Torture may be more abhorrent, but the bar is very low for both issues and this administration’s over-reach so disturbing, that I can’t understand your passion on one and indifference on another.

You say you can’t get worked up about it (as opposed to simply not being worked up about it), your priorities are different to Glenn Greenwald’s, and you’re probably assuming no-one is breaking your civil rights by checking on your communications. It may even be that you wouldn’t mind if someone listened in on your phone calls, while you certainly would mind being tortured. Would you mind if someone in authority took a disliking to you and spied on you to cause you harm? I suspect your indifference here is similar for a majority of people with torture – it only happens to bad people, most likely brown people, and it will never happen to me, so … whatever.

The FISA capitulation is infuriating. Torture is infuriating. If those responsible are never held accountable, then America is a very different place from now on than it was before. I’ve donated to Obama, which I thought was kinda weird ’cause the money in politics is obscene, but he won’t get another cent from me. I’ll also be checking out Glenn’s blog more often, and maybe yours a little less (that Obama ad really is annoying).

I re-read Glenn’s many posts on this subject and listened to his debate with Soderberg and re-read accounts of the bill last night. I hope I’m not indifferent to this, and regret my occasional glibness, although I do think of it less profound an issue – in moral and political terms – than torture. There are important principles here and I respect the case that Glenn has made and admire his passion on it. It’s clear, moreover, that crimes were knowingly committed;

it’s clear to me that the president seized powers beyond his reach and, more importantly, retained those powers after the initial crisis; it’s clear too that the telecom companies should have known they were complying with illegality and refused after an initial period.

But it seems to me the focus of blame should be on the president and should be exercized primarily through political rather than legal means. And the trouble with prosecution is that it does become difficult to determine when exactly we stop forgiving illegal actions designed for the public safety in the immediate wake of a catastrophe like 9/11. I do forgive it in the wake, and see some lee-way for executive energy in moments of crisis or unknowing probably for a while thereafter (even though it horrifies me that the Bush administration would have merrily assigned all these powers to itself indefinitely if it could, and not even told anyone, let alone come promptly to the Congress asking for a reformed FISA law). But how do you prosecute a company on the basis of that kind of blurry line – granting immunity before but not after a point we deem appropriate or defensible?

My concerns are appeased now that the Congress has signed on in the light of day, that a court is there as a safeguard, retroactively if necessary, and that FISA is re-established as the exclusive mechanism for government wiretapping. I don’t consider this a capitulation to triangulation or Beltway insiderism or to Obama-worship. I consider it a middle ground between vital intelligence gathering – the non-coercive type – in an increasingly complex telecommunications system in a very dangerous war.