Deficit v. Debt

A reader writes:

I think your reader is confusing deficit with debt. Setting aside whether we could really get to zero if we’re in Iraq for 100 years, the math does add up. By zeroing out deficit spending on the war, you reduce the deficit. In the credit card example, 10k a month is the deficit. Not adding 10k the next month does indeed reduce the deficit for that month, which is the amount of debt you’re adding. You simply don’t do anything to get rid of the debt.

Hilzoy crunches the numbers.

Those Obama Ads

A reader writes:

I don’t know if you have any influence over the ads which appear on your web pages.  Or, at least, a way to pass messages on to those who design and place the ads.  But if you do, you might share this with them.

I have no problem with Obama ads, per se.  However the new ads, with their moving graphics, etc.  Are a major negative.  Like many people (but perhaps unlike a lot of the Obama staff) I do not have the absolute latest and fastest PC.  Which means that the new ads take forever to load and run on my desktop.  And while they do, I can do almost nothing else either — the impact on my hard drive and my CPU is just to great.

 

The result for you and the Atlantic is that I visit your site much less often than I did a month ago. The result for the Obama Campaign is that I grow progressively more irritated. Building name recognition is one thing. But impacting your brand by irritating those who are otherwise well disposed towards you is quite another. Something a lot less fancy would be a really, really good idea.

I don’t control the ads at all. But I’ve forwarded the email to the relevant parties.

More FISA

Greenwald explains, once again, why telecom immunity matters to him:

They are taking away from the judiciary the power to adjudicate allegations of lawbreaking. They are creating a two-tiered system of justice in which our most powerful corporations can break the law with impunity and government officials remain immune from consequences. And they are, in unity, spewing rank propaganda to the commoners — who continue to be subjected to the harsh punishment for violations of the law and one of the world’s most merciless justice systems — in order to convince them that granting license to our political and corporate elites to break the law is necessary for their own Good and for their Safety.

In the period after 9/11 in question, I do not find these cardinal sins. Venial maybe.

The Other Wilsonianism

Peter Beinart proposes:

A renewed commitment to collective security—to solving common problems and abiding by common rules—also offers the surest way to restore America’s legitimacy. A recent survey of 15 nations by WorldPublicOpinion.org revealed that only two countries (Argentina and the Palestinian Authority) wanted the U.S. to withdraw from world affairs. In fact, when asked who they expect to take the lead in countering global threats, non-Americans still point to the United States (along with the UN). As Steve Kull of the Program on International Policy Attitudes put it recently, “Despite the negative views of U.S. foreign policy, publics around the world do not want the U.S. to disengage from international affairs but rather to participate in a more cooperative and multilateral fashion.” Even commentators such as The New America Foundation’s Parag Khanna, who predict intensifying competition between the United States, Europe, and China, argue that for the U.S. to sustain its power it must revive efforts to solve common problems, which, in turn, can help restore America’s good name.

The Hillaryification Of First Ladydom

Matt Cooper writes:

The Hillaryifcation of First Ladydom continues. Teresa Heinz Kerry took her hits in 2004. Once the floodgates are open and a first lady is no longer seen as removed from politics, no one is safe. Thus the right already pillories Michelle Obama.

Granted, Mrs. Obama’s ham-handed line about being very, very proud of her country for the first time in her adult life over the presidential bid of her husband struck many as off-putting. But the right making her into a latter-day Angela Davis has twisted that bit of spousal hyperenthusiasm. A cover story on Michelle in the National Review made her out to be a grievance monger. They’ve made much of her senior thesis at Princeton, where she wrote with great pain about feeling alienated on a campus surrounded by white privilege. Hmmm, you’re 21, the daughter of a Chicago water-works man, who, in a great American success story, produced two Princeton kids who went on to remarkable careers (Michelle’s brother is the coach of the Brown University basketball team.) You get to Princeton and somehow amidst the eating clubs like Tiger and Ivy and the like, you don’t feel totally at home. I’m shocked.

The left hasn’t pilloried Cindy McCain in the same way, but there’s a lot of whispering. She’s plastic. She’s a crazy heiress–and worse. But here is what we know: She’s worked her tail off to help poor kids around the world, adopting one herself. She came back from a prescription-drug addiction and a stroke that sapped her faculties of speech. She’s by all accounts a devoted mother to her own kids, those from McCain’s previous marriage.

In a world where the spouse is fair game, the spouse becomes an object of vilification, unhinged from any reality. None of this is meant to deify the woman who will be first lady, but they’re points worth considering on their own.

Meanwhile, In Baquba

A useful reality check from the NYT:

Is it normal yet? The three young men did not respond. When will it be normal? “I don’t know how long it will take,” said Muath Abbas, 21, a university student who is studying English, although he is not sure where he will use the language. “It will take time.”

This year? Next year? Abu Mohamed, a 21-year-old taxi driver, shook his head. “It is in the hands of God,” he said.

Ten minutes after the conversation, a bomb exploded less than 100 feet away. It destroyed the building and checkpoint of a Sunni citizen group paid by the Americans to watch the neighborhood. In an illustration of the convoluted world of Iraq, the police said that the citizen group was not the target. Rather, the group itself set the bomb to destroy its building rather than give it back to returning Shiites who had renewed their claim to it, the police said.

If "normal" is our definition of "victory", we will be there for ever.

McCain’s “Peace Dividend”

A reader writes:

I think you gave McCain more credit than he deserves on that "peace dividend" in this quote from his campaign:

"The McCain administration would reserve all savings from victory in the Iraq and Afghanistan operations in the fight against Islamic extremists for reducing the deficit. Since all their costs were financed with deficit spending, all their savings must go to deficit reduction."

The latter sentence does not make fiscal sense.

It’s not a peace dividend because going to zero cost (hypothetically) in Iraq/Afghanistan doesn’t bring in more money.  It just means we lose less money each month because it was ALL deficit spending in the first place.  How can you set aside all those "victory" savings to reduce a deficit if all that spending was out of the deficit?  That would be like charging 10k/month solely on frivilous purchases on credit cards, then saying you’ll pay off that balance with the 10k you don’t spend on future frivilous purchases.

Quote For The Day

"I do know libertarians who think Obama is the Antichrist, that he’s farther left than John Kerry, much farther left than Bill Clinton, and you’d clearly have to be insane to vote for this guy. But there are libertarians who say, ‘Oh yeah? Do you think Obama will increase spending by $1 trillion, because that’s what Republicans did over the past two presidential terms. So really, how much worse can he be?’ And there are certainly libertarians who think Obama will be better on the war and on foreign policy, on executive power and on surveillance than McCain," –  David Boaz, executive vice president of the Cato Institute.

Calling Bush’s Bluff

Maybe we won’t be there for a hundred years after all:

"Today, we are looking at the necessity of terminating the foreign presence on Iraqi lands and restoring full sovereignty," Maliki told Arab ambassadors in blunt remarks during an official visit to Abu Dhabi, capital of the United Arab Emirates.

"One of the two basic topics is either to have a memorandum of understanding for the departure of forces or a memorandum of understanding to set a timetable for the presence of the forces, so that we know (their presence) will end in a specific time."