Pick An Issue, Any Issue

Ruffini is worried about McCain:

Message wise, McCain seems to be paralyzed by indecision between multiple different ways to get at Obama — is he a phony? a naif? too liberal? There has been nothing as disciplined as the Kerry flip flopper meme.

The body language I hear from the campaign is that Obama will not be defeated on issues, but on attributes, mostly stuff like the Clark kerfuffle when they can scuff the other side up with their own hypocrisy.

I’m a big fan of attributes and meta-narratives as the centerpiece of campaign strategy, but those attributes must be tied to some semblance of a winning position on the issue landscape. And especially in an election year, a candidate’s advocacy for a specific issue position can change the dynamics of the issue for the better. So, in 2004, Bush’s personal decisiveness contrasted with Kerry’s indecisiveness in a time of war. That message was not introduced in a vacuum.

McCain must decide to engage on the issue landscape and win a key battle on it in some fashion, either by outright winning or by bringing it close enough that McCain’s reputation can seal the deal. If McCain appears out of synch with the issue landscape, none of his leadership attributes will matter.

Tories, Republicans, Obama

Maybe my roots are showing. One striking facet of many European conservatives and British Tories is their relative comfort with an Obama presidency, compared with American Republicans. Check out this little blog post by British Tory Daniel Hannan. Here’s a classic foreign view worth airing:

Consider, more or less at random, some of [Obama]’s policy positions. He wants to cut corporation tax. He plans (disappointingly) to grant immunity to telephone companies that help the federal government to eavesdrop on its citizens. He seems to have dropped any notion of criminalising the private ownership of guns, and made no protest when the Supreme Court struck down the District of Columbia’s ban on pistols last week. Having made some protectionist noises in order to appeal to the know-nothing Pennsylvania Democrats in advance of their primary, he has returned to reaching the virtues of free trade with an enthusiasm matched by few Republicans.

A couple of days ago, he made a lengthy speech about patriotism, his lapel sporting the little flag that has become a permanent fixture. He is even – again, rather to my disappointment – watering down his commitment to remove the garrison from Iraq.

Like many Tories, Hannan regards the Iraq adventure as foolish utopianism – not a criterion for right-wing credentializing. He doesn’t share American conservatism’s culture-specific love of guns and gun culture. So what’s not to like? Here’s the first reader response from an American:

You forget that he has the hallmark of a true leftie: he supports abortion. In fact, he believes an unwanted pregnancy to be a punishment. He also has leanings towards same-sex marriage (though doesn’t fully endorse it), and favours embryonic stem cell research.

But British conservatives don’t regard first trimester abortion rights as a right or left issue; and, as in most other civilized countries, Brits now uncontroversially embrace legal rights for gay couples. Toryism is also agnostic on embryonic stem cell research. So remove the Christianist elements of Republicanism, assume that conservatism has some interest in fiscal responsibility (no longer true of the GOP, alas), and why exactly should a Tory fear Obama?

In a British context, Obama is a one-nation Tory. Not a Thatcherite, to be sure, but well within the historic boundaries of British conservatism. Maybe that’s why I don’t fear him in the slightest. And I don’t think of myself as in any way a lefty either.

Brokeback Mountain’s Alternate Ending

In reality, that is:

Jeff Barr and William Wes Wilkinson, two cowboys from Elverta, were the first male couple married in Woodland on Monday. "We met at a Gay Rodeo Association barn dance eight years ago," said Wilkinson, 43. "We’re both officers of the association. … I proposed to him and he immediately proposed to me, and we accepted at the same time while we were driving down the road in our truck."

The couple have 5 acres with three horses, three calves, nine chickens and two dogs. "That seems to be our family," Wilkinson said. But Barr’s parents, Walter and Louise Barr of Moraga, were present to witness the ceremony. "We have to do that," Walter Barr said of supporting their son …

That last moving sentiment is proof that in reality, rather than in the abstract, support for gay marriage is a deeply, deeply pro-family position.

Obama Indulgences

Victor Davis Hanson is flummoxed by elite support for Obama:

To sum up, Obama offers a reassuring sense of self-image: one can still maintain all the current mechanisms one is accustomed to in ensuring privilege, but visible support for Obama offers a sense of atonement and alleviation of guilt at rather modest cost…Somehow an Obama sticker, sign on the lawn, or a lapel button has become the equivalent of a crucifix around the neck of a prosperous 16th-century burgher: easy fides of inner good and a valuable totem in reconciling the apparent irreconcilable.

Hilzoy counters. It may be that, despite tax hikes, many simply think he’d be a better president – temperamentally, diplomatically, and in terms of overcoming some of the polarization that Bush and Rove fomented for their own purposes.
 

Connerly On Proposition 8

A hero of the right – and a hero to me too – in opposing affirmative action, Ward Connerly, is one of those few anti-discrimination Republicans who sees gay people as real citizens. Along with Arnold Schwarzenegger and the Republican appointed justices on California’s Supreme Court, he therefore opposes the November initiative to remove marriage licenses from thousands of California’s gay couples:

“For anyone to say that this is an issue for people who are gay and that this isn’t about civil rights is sadly mistaken. If you really believe in freedom and limited government, to be intellectually consistent and honest you have to oppose efforts of the majority to impose their will on people.”

I’ve long since seen opposition to affirmative action, support for a flat tax and marriage equality as lynchpins of limited government equal-rights conservatism. I still believe it’s the future for the conservative movement – and far more compatible with Goldwater’s legacy than the moralizing, Christianist authoritarianism of the current crew.