Marriage And Discrimination

Pete Wehner is offended that his view that his relationship should be worth more than mine under the law because he’s heterosexual can be described as "discriminatory." How can it not be discriminatory? You may want to describe your view as merely wanting "to preserve the traditional meaning of marriage," but when that preservation is entirely limited to keeping gays out, and you want the law to enforce such a distinction, then it is simply a fact that discrimination is your policy. You think it’s good discrimination, but it’s still discrimination unrelated to any civil marital responsibility a gay couple is prepared to fulfill.

This remains true however such a policy is maintained or arrived at – by courts or legislatures or, as is usually the case in the US, some combination thereof. What neither Wehner nor Obama have fully grappled with is that there are really only two coherent positions: civil equality or civil discrimination. Obama wants to end discrimination but not embrace equality; Wehner wants discrimination but not the moral taint of being a bigot. These straddling positions are not unusual in the midst of social change. But we have reached a point at which the useful fictions on which they rest are crumbling.

Obama = Re-Branded Bush? II

A conservative reader writes:

Note Obama’s recent embrace of Israel’s attack on Syria’s nuclear facility (an instance of pure Bush preemption doctrine); and his strong insinuation that he might do the same to Iran. Note his support for the FISA reform bill that will pass the Senate on July 8: Although he criticizes immunity, he supports the warrantless surveillance mechanism that is the essence both of the new bill and of the president’s old supersecret Terrorist Surveillance Program, which this bill would prospectively and perhaps permanently legitimize. (Incidentally, if the TSP was unconstitutional as Obama once argued, the procedure cannot be saved by legislation: Feingold is right about that). 

Note also Obama’s promise to Iraq’s foreign minister not to do anything that would jeopardize current gains or Iraqi security;

taken together with his commitment to withdrawing as fast as such circumstances permit, there is now no practical difference between Obama’s prospective Iraq policy and the Petraeus plan embraced by the President. In essence, there is now little practical difference between the candidates on national security issues — but that still leaves a lot of room to create the appearance of difference in the arena of rhetoric and political fantasy.

Another way of looking at it, of course, is that Obama is simply responding to events on the ground, has never been a pacifist or non-interventionist, and has to operate within the empirical boundaries of the legacy he’s responding to. In office, the kind of pragmatism Obama represents will chart a gradual, not radical, course away from the current impasse. That’s why I’m increasingly interested in how Obama describes the ultimate goals of his Iraq strategy. There is a real difference between an attempt to retain control over an Arab Muslim state in the Middle East, and finding a way to leave it without fomenting a hotter stage in its civil war.

Copying The Communists

Go to Memeorandum and check out the blogs commenting on the NYT exclusive on the undisputed fact that the Bush administration knowingly used Communist torture techniques against prisoners in wartime. You will find no right-of-center blogs commenting. It’s an astonishing story – especially for any anti-Communist conservative who fought the good fight during the Cold War. But they won’t mention it. I guess when a Republican administration copies communists, conservative writers need to copy Stalinists.

Obama = Re-Branded Bush?

Marc writes about the faith and government initiative:

Obama’s principle is clear, but how he’d put them into practice is not clear. Would Catholic charities be allowed to refuse to hire gay people for federally-funded programs? Obama thinks they shouldn’t be able to, but it’s not clear how or whether Obama would intervene to prevent them from doing so. It’s also clear that Obama wants to expand the Bush initiative and rebrand it a bit. His new name for it is the Council for Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnerships.

The WaPo And Obama’s Mortgage

Nate Silver has a point:

Unless the Washington Post has access to Obama’s FICO score — and unless it has rented an apartment to him, it probably doesn’t — it is missing a pretty important piece of information on what Obama’s mortgage rate ought to have been. What was Obama’s FICO score? I don’t know, but considering that…


* Obama had just gotten a $2.27 million book deal from Random House — about $1 million more than the value of the mortgage.
* The Obamas each had exceptionally secure jobs that paid them a combined annual salary of about $500,000 per year.
* The Obamas had just sold their condo, on which they had realized a $137,500 profit.
* The Obamas were prominent public figures whose political futures depended in part on maintaining a reputation for responsibility and trustworthiness.
* The Obamas are known to be relatively thrifty and have no credit card debt but substantial savings.

…I would think that the Obamas were exceptionally creditworthy. So indeed, Obama received a "discount" — the same discount that any borrower in his position would have received.

The Angry Left

Greenwald is livid:

Feeding distortions against someone like Wesley Clark in order to please Joe Klein and his fact-free media friends, or legalizing warrantless eavesdropping and protecting joint Bush/telecom lawbreaking, or basing his campaign on demonizing MoveOn.org and 1960s anti-war hippies, is quite harmful in many long-lasting ways. Electing Barack Obama is a very important political priority but it isn’t the only one there is, and his election is less likely, not more likely, the more homage he pays to these these tired, status-quo-perpetuating Beltway pieties.
 

Attacked From All Sides

Atrios complains:

One thing about blogging during the campaign is that you end up pissing people off on all sides. There are those who, understandably, think it’s vitally important that Barack Obama be elected and so important that asshole bloggers like me should refrain from any and all criticism lest my mighty blog powers cause Obama to fail. And there are those that get mad because I’m completely in the tank and don’t criticize Obama enough. And everyone in between.

I know the feeling. I’ve grown to like it, actually.