Only Connect

E.M. Forster got to Wall-E’s message a long time ago:

As in WALL-E, “The Machine Stops” is set on a future Earth whose surface has been blasted into inhabitability by waste and pollution. Writing when radio was in its infancy, Forster (best known for his novel A Passage to India) imagined an intermediated hypercivilization in which people connect to one another through electronic screens—a videoconferencing dystopia unnervingly reminiscent of some of today’s social media. While WALL-E’s human population has escaped into space, in Forster’s tale they have created a vast subterranean civilization. In both stories, however, humanity has grown fat and sessile thanks to automated systems that serve their every need. Whisked from screen to screen in automated chairs, they’re unable to interact with the world without electronic mediation. And in both stories, the systems break down.

Jonah vs Big Government

You gotta love this:

The key difference [between Obama’s and Reagan’s rhetoric] is that invoking scripture in order to justify shrinking government at home and liberating mankind from collectivism abroad is quite different than invoking government to justify an enormous expansion of the state into people’s lives.

"An enormous expansion of the state into people’s lives". What does Jonah think Bush has been doing these past eight years?

Obama On Marriage

Reihan wonders about Obama’s stance on gay rights:

So as of now, Obama has staked out a strongly Sullivanian position, yet my understanding is that he personally opposes same-sex marriage. I’d be eager to know why — does this parallel his trade rhetoric, where things get amplified and overheated in the course of a campaign?

I have yet to figure out why exactly, except as either an amorphous respect for tradition or as a political necessity. Or both.

The Continuum Of Humannness

Saletan considers animal rights and the "myth of animal equality":

Opening your mind to science-based animal rights doesn’t eliminate inequality. It just makes the inequality more scientific. A rat can’t match a pig, much less a boy.

And it’s a continuum, right? Hence Spain’s new law defending ape rights:

GAP is scientifically honest. And science doesn’t show mental parity between great apes and human adults. What it shows, as the group’s president acknowledges, is that great apes "experience an emotional and intellectual conscience similar to that of human children." Accordingly, the Spanish proposal doesn’t treat apes like you or me. It treats them like "humans of limited capacity, such as children or those who are mentally incompetent and are afforded guardians or caretakers to represent their interests."

I understand the intuition that humans are different in kind than animals. But science won’t allow such absolute categories.

Wes Clark: Ferraro In Drag

Or something like that:

It didn’t work for Ferraro because both her point, and the way she went about making and restating it, were outlandish. But so far it seems to be working for Wesley Clark. He’s not backing down, and the debate about whether McCain’s service is an automatic qualification for being president is now in its second day.

So just to be clear: Wesley Clark isn’t trying to Swift Boat John McCain. That’s so 2004. He’s trying to Ferraro John McCain. And so far he’s proving to be more skilled at it than Ferraro ever was.

Yglesias Award Nominee

"The point is this – and the story is quite familiar already: the netroots become enamored with a particular candidate. Said candidate does something contrary to what conventional wisdom as dictated by a small coterie of prominent bloggers agrees with. Netroots becomes angry, throws up hands in the air, pounds keyboards angrily, fills up pixels with frustration, and does very little to influence the debate… In short, grow the hell up. If you can’t get over being disappointed by your candidate in politics…well, you’re going to be disappointed virtually all the time," – Kos blogger, Psifighter37.