Quote For The Day

"Lewis Carroll notwithstanding, the fact that the government has “said it thrice” does not make an allegation true. See LEWIS CARROLL, THE HUNTING OF THE SNARK 3 (1876) (”I have said it thrice: What I tell you three times is true.”). In fact, we have no basis for concluding that there are independent sources for the documents’ thrice-made assertions," –  Judge Merrick B. Garland, of the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, on the most recent Gitmo farce.

The Rise Of Nerds

From a review of Benjamin Nugent’s American Nerd:

From the late 19th century onward, it was more or less accepted that the ideal purpose of American education and parenting was to produce athletic, popular young men and women, the sort who end up in business, law, or politics. But sometime during the 1980s it began to be a lot harder to dismiss the awkward kids with thick glasses, obsessive interests, and no social skills. Sure, life was still rough for those kids, but they were learning they weren’t alone, thanks to TV shows like "Square Pegs" and movies like "Sixteen Candles." As computers began to play a larger role in business, education, and life in general, the former class presidents were learning that the former class geeks held everyone’s future in their hands. Soon one nerd (Alan Greenspan) was running the economy, another nerd (Al Gore) was running for president, and two unbelievably rich nerds (Bill Gates and Steve Jobs) were changing the ways a lot of us lived and worked.

Remember "Sixteen Candles"? (Hat tip: 3QD)

Science And The MSM

Not so great:

Gary Schwitzer used to be a journalist, but now he has turned to quantitative analyses of journalism, and this month he published an analysis of 500 health articles from mainstream media in the US. The results were dismal. Only 35% of stories were rated satisfactory for whether the journalist had "discussed the study methodology and the quality of the evidence": because in the media, as you will have noticed, science is about absolute truth statements from arbitrary authority figures in white coats, rather than clear descriptions of studies and the reasons why people draw conclusions from them.

Lileks On Wall-E

Wall_e_trailer1

He loved it. It is, in my view, the greatest Pixar picture yet, although I was very, very fond of "A Bug’s Life." Classic Lileks passage on how human CGI robots can get:

Note the following: At the start of the clip, and elsewhere, Eve’s eyes channel Maximillian from “Black Hole,” which is probably intentional.

How many fricken’ robots-in-love movies would stop the action to make the main character compare his hands to the elegant extremities of his beloved? Wall-E’s actions when he sits down, knocks his treads together and pats the seat next to him may, I suspect, have been vetted and discussed and considered at great length. (Or not.) It’s the most overtly human action he makes in the entire film – it’s not emulative of humans, it’s instinctive.

Eve’s vocalizations change here, if I recall correctly – there’s nothing in her previous utterances that reveal any emotion that’s not consistent with top-level programming. “No – no” is the moment that makes us see what Wall-E saw in her – and just to underscore the Pixar gift, the moment is understated.  Prior to this she’s been an impatient professional.

Bonus nerd-nexus: 2001 escape-pod reference with Ripley from “Alien” doing the countdown for self-destruct.

It’s odd that a movie that predicts ecological doom can in fact make one more certain that the human race will survive our current predicament. Any civilization that can produce something as technically and artistically sublime as Wall-E cannot be doomed.

Clark-Lash-Lash

A reader comes to my defense (and I’m unrepentant, by the way):

You’re right.

"Well, I don’t think riding in a fighter plane and getting shot down is a qualification to be president.”

The problem is not the correctness of the statement.  It’s the tone-deafness and the insult implied. "…riding in a fighter plane and getting shot down…" makes it sound as if John McCain’s imprisonment and torture is somehow John McCain’s fault.  It makes it sound as if McCain were some dilettante who happened to be riding around in a fighter plane and that it was his incompetence that got him shot down.

I am a devoted Obama supporter, I have never served in the military, and I won’t be voting for John McCain, but that sentence pisses me off.

Me too. And yes, I know he was parroting Bob Schieffer. And I do think that the MSM meme that anyone who was in combat is automatically more qualified on foreign policy than a civilian is brain-dead. But the way you put things matters. And Clark is one of the most ham-fisted politicians in the US today. My reader continues:

Obama needed to denounce Clark’s statement, and I consider it neither cowardly nor politically opportunistic to do so.

If Clark had made the point more precisely- something along the lines of, "Why do we think that serving in the military automatically gives someone greater insight into the complicated political, military, and diplomatic calculus it takes to formulate a foreign policy?" that would be a good point to make.

If Clark had pointed out that McCain tries to equate military experience with foreign policy judgment, and that tactical judgment as an aviator is quite different from the strategic judgment required to be a general, an admiral, or a commander-in-chief, that would be a good point to make. But this statement obliterates what could have been a very good point to make for Obama at this point in the campaign (military service does not automatically equal superior judgment on foreign policy), and screws it up so badly that Obama has to step all over himself on the day of his big patriotism speech.

Clark screwed up, and Obama had to denounce him so that Clark’s statement wouldn’t dominate the day any more than it did. You’re right, and Obama was right.

Gay Marriage And Sports

There’s more:

Denmark introduced gay marriage in 1989 and went on to win the European Championship in 1992 – surely (football fans around the world would agree) an impossible event.

I’m surprised Stanley Kurtz hasn’t noticed the correlation. Clearly marriage equality causes national teams to play better. What other explanation could there possibly be?