Staring Slack-Jawed Into The Middle Distance

Nige kicks the newspaper habit:

Apart from a quick, dispiriting skim of a single Sunday paper, I have ignored the newspapers altogether – a risky course in my line of business perhaps, but what the hey? I can report that I feel a great deal less miserable about things, a good deal less mentally cluttered, confused and ground down – and I have done more of the things that are worth doing (reading books, listening to music, staring slack-jawed into the middle distance) with the time saved by not ploughing through the depressing, banal, ill-written, self-important, vastly oversized publications that make up our much prized ‘national press’.

A Swift Boater Attacks Swift Boating

A little late, I’d say:

One of the participants in McCain’s conference call today was Colonel Bud Day, a longtime McCain ally who was also a member of the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth in 2004. I asked Day whether how he’d compare the attacks he was saying McCain faces today — from Wes Clark and other Democrats — to the attacks on John Kerry’s war record from the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth in 2004. "The Swift Boat ‘attacks’ were simply relevation of the truth," said Day, a former prisoner of war and Medal of Honor recipient who served i the Air Force. "The similarity does not exist here."

McCain himself disowned the Swift Boat nutters in 2004 as "dishonest and dishonorable." I find both attempts to smear the war records of people who volunteered to fight for their country to be repellent. But the far right is too invested in the politics of Vietnam to take the high road.

The Clark-McCain Spat

K-Lo’s thoughts:

Conservatives should not let this Clark moment pass. Barack Obama should distance himself from efforts to dishonor McCain’s military service. Obama should be disappointed and saddened. This is not the Wesley Clark he knew. And he should drop Wesley Clark as an adviser. That would be general progress away from the paranoid style of American politics.

In his excellent speech this morning Obama did exactly that:

"For those like John McCain who have endured physical torment in service to our country — no further proof of such sacrifice is necessary," Obama said. "And let me also add that no one should ever devalue that service, especially for the sake of a political campaign, and that goes for supporters on both sides."

James Joyner is more temperate:

On one level, Clark has a point.  Commanding a training squadron isn’t the same as running a wartime theater. And, as I argued when John Kerry was relying too much on his Vietnam experience and I’ve continued to counsel vis-a-vis McCain, being a war hero only goes so far in making a case for a presidential candidate.  Nor is Clark “Swift Boating” McCain; he’s not questioning his wartime accomplishments.

Still, at the larger level, this strikes me as a poor argument.  While “getting in a fighter plane and getting shot down” might not be sufficient qualification to be president, it’s certainly more than Barack Obama ever endured.  And, while Obama has experience at the community level that McCain can’t match, it’s a dangerous game for him to send out surrogates to minimize McCain’s service.  As Bruce McQuain asks, “if the willingness to fight for your country, put your life on the line and suffer the brutality McCain suffered as a POW doesn’t make the cut as far as qualifications go, how far below that does a ‘community organizer’ show up on the list of non-qualifications?"

Malkin is less temperate:

If Gen. Wesley Clark had vice presidential aspirations, they went out the widow yesterday when he opened his mouth and removed any lingering doubt about his idiocy.

My take here.

The General Election Begins!, Ctd

Stanley Fish is as listless as I am:

The lines of battle are predictable and are unlikely to change from now to November. Obama will try to tie McCain to the war’s beginning, McCain will emphasize Obama’s inexperience in military matters, and each will move closer to the other on the question of troop withdrawals. Obama will promise (almost) universal health care and McCain will tout the wonders of the free enterprise system. Both will claim to be a better friend of the environment than the other and both will chide the outgoing president for fiscal irresponsibility. In short, a familiar party-line struggle that won’t look all that different from what we saw in 2004. Where’s the excitement?

My different sense of how far we’ve actually come is here.

Who Knew?

Gay marriage is good for sports:

[L]egalizing gay marriage is good for sports teams. Spain did it a few years back, and wham, they win the Euro for the first time since 1964. Canada did it just before the 2006 Winter Olympics, and bingo, they had their best-ever medal haul. South Africa legalized gay marriage in 2006, and won the Rugby World Cup the following year. Massachusetts gave same-sex couples the right to wed a few years ago — and ask Red Sox and Celtic fans about how nicely things have gone for their teams since. For all those folks who insist that God’s punishment for gay marriage will be obvious, so far the evidence is, um, lacking. The evidence for the opposite is growing.

(Hat tip: Jeff Fecke)

Re-Reading Kristol

Kristol

I have a bunch of books in my Ptown shack, remnants of summer reading from years gone by and I stumbled across a classic yesterday: "The War Over Iraq" by Lawrence Kaplan and Bill Kristol. It’s an Encounter book from 2002/2003 before the invasion, and Kristol should hope it’s out of print. Reading it years later, its tone and content are shockingly off-base, and most of its core assertions and arguments categorically refuted by history. In fact, it would be very hard to think of a piece of analysis so riddled with misconceptions and errors and so self-evidently wrong in almost every respect only five years later. For errors this huge, of course, and a tenacious refusal to admit them and account for them, is what gives a writer a prestigious perch at the New York Times. But more revealing in a way is the book’s focus: it’s almost entirely on internal American debates, on the ancient post-Vietnam boomer split on foreign policy, on settling scores with the first Bush administration, and extrapolating the roll-back of the Reagan years to a post-9/11 world. The complex, difficult, murky reality of Iraq and its people remains clouded behind a Berlin wall of ideology. But among the core points of the book with respect to Iraq: there are no deep sectarian divisions, there would never be a civil war or anything approximating it once we removed Saddam, and the smallest of forces and lowest of costs would be needed for turning the place into a beacon of democracy. A typical passage from page 98:

The United States may need to occupy Iraq for some time. Though U.N., European and Arab forces will, as in Afghanistan, contribute troops, the principal responsibility will doubtless fall to the country that liberates Baghdad. According to one estimate, initially as many as 75,000 troops may be required to police the war’s aftermath, at a cost of $16 billion a year. As other countries’ forces arrive, and as Iraq rebuilds its economy and political system, that force could probably be drawn down to several thousand soldiers after a year or two.

So let’s be very, very clear: Kristol – not Rumsfeld or Franks or anyone else who bungled the execution – favored and supported a tiny post-war occupation force, less than half what was required even five years after invasion to prevent a metastasizing civil war. The civil war raged with enough ferocity to kill and maim and traumatize millions of Iraqis and thousands of Americans. Kristol sold the war on what turned out to be the preposterous sum of $16 billion a year. The figure has ended up at around $12 billion a month. So Kristol was off in his troops levels by a factor of two at the start of the occupation and by up to 20 today and he was off in his cost levels by a factor of ten. He also predicted "several thousand" troops by 2005, compared with 150,000 today.

Now, we all get things wrong, and I certainly got things massively wrong.

But when you’re this prominent a war-backer and you get things this wrong on a subject this important, don’t you think a smidgen of self-criticism or self-analysis could be in order? (I’m omitting the fact that the WMD casus belli Kristol also asserted as fact was a total chimera, but gien the number of Kristol’s errors, this now seems small beer). Kristol has indeed criticized the war’s execution but always against others, especially Rumsfeld. Kristol has never fully copped to, let alone apologized and accounted for, his own profound errors and responsibility for the catastrophe in Mesopotamia. And yet Kristol now writes with an assurance about Iraq – yes, the subject on which his credibility among intelligent people should be precisely zero – as if his critics are still the ones who need to prove their point beyond the benefit of any doubt.

It seems to me that we demand accountability from our politicians and we should demand accountability from our intellectuals. Not that they always get things right – but that they give a full accounting when they are wrong. Instead we reward and celebrate those who not only get things wrong – Kristol and Rove now have prominent columns in the New York Times and Wall Street Journal – but those who have never taken personal responsibility for their own mistakes. Until we purge all these tendencies from Washington, we will not learn from history and we will keep repeating it.

Obamatsunami

The media over-drive continues – online and on TV:

I searched for stories that mentioned Obama but didn’t mention McCain in Google News. 69,473 stories. And stories that mention McCain but not Obama? 19,135. That’s a stunning 3.63 to 1 ratio … In today’s Internet age, this kind of disparity does not exist in a vacuum. It translates seamlessly into online activity, particularly search engine activity. … Here’s how it works. Free media drives search traffic. Search traffic drives website traffic. Website traffic drives contributions and signups who can later be resolicited for money.

This will re-balance, I suspect. And I don’t see it as some kind of conspiracy. Obama is an historic candidate for obvious reasons, compelling, and new to the public. McCain has been around for ever. Who are you more interested in?

The Internet’s Contextual Morality

A defendant in an obscenity law case is arguing that he hasn’t violated "contemporary community standards" because google trends shows the community’s sexual mores are not what they appear. William Saletan’s thoughts:

Here’s my advice to the courts: The Internet has fundamentally altered the meaning of community. The guy in Pensacola visits international Web sites and belongs to interstate online forums. He lives in multiple communities and follows different standards in each. Maybe he says things in forums that he’d never do in the flesh. Maybe he looks at pictures of things he’d never talk about in forums. Maybe he imagines things in his head that he’d never look for in pictures.

Respect these differences. Don’t equate fake child pornography with the actual use of children. Don’t condemn a judge for "unacceptable behavior" because somebody peeked into his family’s file share and found a few dirty pictures. And don’t judge a porn site operator by the open-air standards of his geographic community. That’s not where he peddles his smut. He peddles it online, where the standards, as we now know from Google, are different.