The Magnifying Glass Effect, Ctd

Perhaps not as original. A reader writes:

Such products have been for sale for about 5 years. Unfortunately, its not as simple as that blog entry contends. With silicon flat panels, you are not so sensitive to the direction of the sun. With a magnifying glass, you need to be pointed directly at the sun or all the light focuses somewhere else. This means that you need mechanical trackers turning the units continuously. This adds maintenance cost, etc. In order to get as much power as possible, they use so-called triple junction cells which are about twice as efficient, but substantially more expensive than silicon cells, and made with much more exotic and less prevalent materials than silicon (second most common element in the earths crust). This doesn’t mean it won’t work, because you are tracking the sun with the unit, you get about twice as many hours of effective sunlight which can help. But then you have to space the units further apart which means peak watts per sq ft are lower. Oh, and these cells won’t work if it is cloudy, there is nothing to focus on the chip where as silicon cells still generate power even on cloudy days.

So…for places where real estate is cheap, sun is prevalent, and labor costs are low (think Mojave), concentrated solar power may have a chance, but that has yet to be proven. So far, the cost is 2-3 times the cost per kW-hr of silicon. And for residential roof tops, no way. Or for places where the sun isn’t a constant (think Seattle). Lastly, the silicon guys have so much head start in terms of volume that it is going to be hard for any other technology to catch up. Its one advantage is efficiency, which if carefully managed, could lead to more watts/acre for a utility type installation. To get more involved, the typical silicon installation only has about 40% of the cost in the cells. The rest is installation, mounting hardware, etc.

Any technology will have this cost, and a reasonable approach is to try to win the race on ‘balance of system’ costs. Efficiency is a big key here, since wires, mounting pedestals, etc. all scale with the power generated per cell. Silicon manufacturers are getting 21-22% out of their cells now with a promise of ~28% in the near future, this will make it very hard to beat, even with very cheap solar cell materials. If the material is hyper efficient and using concentrators, the cell can be nearly free but if the hardware (trackers, etc) is twice as expensive, you haven’t won. Of if you are using some of the new ‘thin-film’ technologies where cells are inkjet printed, you again get ‘free’ cells but at half the efficiency (~10%) and twice the number of cells needed and twice the balance of system cost. Still, the scale of the problem is something to consider. To replace current electrical demand in the US with photovoltaic, you would need about 10,000 sq mi of silicon cells. Not to mention the systems to store power for night, and to transmit it to low solar flux areas. And as we convert more to electric from hydrocarbons, the amount of energy needed will only increase.

Testosterone Nation

Mara Hvistendahl reports on the consequences of China’s one-child policy:

Preliminary returns from the first generation of population-controlled kids suggest how all those unwanted men might fill up their time. Over the past decade, as the boys hit adolescence, the country’s youth crime rate more than doubled. In December, Chinese Society of Juvenile Delinquency Research Deputy Secretary General Liu Guiming told a Beijing seminar that today’s teens were committing crimes "without specific motives, often without forethought."

…as Chinese couples make more money, fertility is naturally declining– meaning that today’s bachelors will form an even larger proportion of China’s future population than officials expect. Wang Feng, a sociologist at the University of California-Irvine who’s part of a group of scholars advocating phasing out the one-child policy, says the outlook is grim: "Each successive birth cohort is going to be smaller. When younger cohorts get smaller, you have fewer females. It’s a double whammy."

Evangelical Democrats

Michael Dougherty responds to Ross:

For years progressives have dreamed of getting Evangelicals to connect with anti-poverty and environmental programs. Obama may be the one to do it. As Ross says, he is just better than McCain at framing his progressive policies as part of a moral mission. McCain would be foolish to counter this by using the Rev. Wright card. Many religious conservatives know what it is like to have a pastor called out as an “extremist” and they recognize this as a technique of their liberal enemies.

But I would caution my progressive friends from thinking they can capture these voters for the long-term.

White evangelicals may be for Democrats what Hispanics are for Republicans. Each party has certain policy commitments that make winning a majority among these groups almost impossible. There is no wedge issue that is big enough to divide white evangelicals from economic conservatives — anti-poverty programs won’t do it. Likewise Republicans have been unable to use abortion or family-issues to separate Hispanics from the party that seems a natural fit for recent immigrants.

One Way To Reduce Oil Prices

Balance the federal budget:

The world price of oil is denominated in dollars. The dollar is weak for many reasons, but a big one is the immense budget deficits run by our government. If President Bush and Senators John McCain and Barack Obama were to stand together in front of a camera and solemnly swear that they would balance the budget in four years, even if it required tax increases on people earning millions, the dollar would rise against the euro, and oil would fall in dollars.

But neither McCain nor Obama would do anything that crazy, would they?

A Flat Tax Question

A reader writes:

I have a question about your support of a flat tax. The flat tax that Steve Forbes, Dick Armey, and the like proposed in the 1990s had a standard exemption and then taxed ordinary income at a flat rate.  One of the proponents’ arguments was that a lower rate would reduce the amount of economic behavior driven by tax avoidance rather than rational economic decisions. Makes sense — until you consider capital gains.  Their proposal — which was endorsed by the supply-side establishment, and was thus the one with the most traction — entirely exempted capital gains, dividends, and interest from taxation.  For someone who is truly interested in a tax code that does not alter economic behavior, this, to me, is heresy.

This regime would create a huge incentive for people to classify their income as capital gains, rather than ordinary income. Also, if you tax labor, but not capital, you create an economic incentive for a company to prefer investing in the former and not the latter. So, are you for a flat tax that would tax capital gains, dividends, interest, and ordinary income at the same rate?

In a word: Yes. Having a tax that treats all forms of income alike, with no deductions, is the truly market-friendly proposal. Neither the left nor most of the right will sign on. If I were running for president as a libertarian, this would be a central plank.

A “Leadership Cult”

Jonah seems to think that people adopting Obama’s middle name as their own is cultish. Isn’t it more obviously a rebuke to the racists and xenophobes who will not vote for a man with that name? A signal of the kind of open-minded, unbigoted America so many in the next generation are hoping for? Maybe that just doesn’t occur to Jonah.