Gun Control: We May Never Know

A paragraph from a 1996 article on gun ownership:

Like moral and legal claims about gun owners’ rights, the practical consequences of widespread gun ownership are highly debatable. No one can say with any certainty whether it increases violence or decreases crime. Don Kates speculates that magically reducing the approximately 200 million firearms in circulation to five million would have virtually no reductive effect on the crime rate: according to a 1983 National Institute of Justice-funded study by James D. Wright, Peter H. Rossi, and Kathleen Daly, about one percent of privately owned firearms are involved in criminal activity, suggesting that eliminating 99 percent of the nation’s guns would not ameliorate crime. Or would it?

Philip Cook, an economist at Duke University and a leading researcher on gun violence, considers Kates’s speculation about the uselessness of reducing the number of guns "patently absurd."We can’t predict which guns will be used in crimes, he says, even if a relatively small number are used feloniously overall. Reducing the availability of guns would raise their price and therefore reduce their accessibility, to adult felons as well as juveniles. And even if a drastic reduction in the number of guns wouldn’t necessarily decrease crime, it would decrease fatalities. Guns are particularly lethal, Cook has stressed: the "fraction of serious gun assaults that result in the victim’s death is much higher than that of assaults with other weapons." Since not all gun homicides reflect a clearly formulated intent to kill, Cook reasons, access to guns can increase the lethality of assaults. A decrease in the use of guns, however, might lead to an increase in nonfatal injuries. Robberies committed with guns tend to involve less violence than other robberies because the victims are less likely to resist.

Don’t Tread On Us

In honor of DC vs Heller, a section from Richard Slotkin’s 2000 review of Michael Bellesiles’s Arming America (the book’s research methods have since been disputed):

The militia issue highlights a critical difference in the way American and European cultures permit violence. American culture has tended, from the eighteenth century on, to assign an extraordinary value to individual rights, desires, and property. So we came to treat weapons, and the right to use them, as we treat all forms of private property—granting the widest possible latitude of action to the owner. Our self-defense statutes are more permissive than those of any other industrialized nation. Under English law if a person menaced with deadly force is able to flee, he is obliged to do so. American laws since the Jacksonian period have typically declared that a man may defend himself with deadly force when he has a credible belief that he is menaced with deadly force. Under this rule a Louisiana man was acquitted in 1993 after having shot an unarmed Japanese exchange student who came to his door looking for a Halloween party.

Panglish

Michael Erard explains why English is fast becoming a language "we may not even understand":

Thanks to globalization, the Allied victories in World War II, and American leadership in science and technology, English has become so successful across the world that it’s escaping the boundaries of what we think it should be. In part, this is because there are fewer of us: By 2020, native speakers will make up only 15 percent of the estimated 2 billion people who will be using or learning the language. Already, most conversations in English are between nonnative speakers who use it as a lingua franca.

The Conservative Future

Ezra comments on Brooks’s cadre of young conservatives:

These new thinkers on the Right seem fairly disengaged with the machinery and centers of power within their party. I agree with quite a bit of their critiques, but in the case of the libertarians, there’s not much interest in engaging with the Republican Party, and in the case of Ross and Reihan, there’s not much effort to seriously engage with the task of reforming the Republican Party. Now, it may indeed be that the work of these folks is to create the ideas infrastructure and wait for a propitious moment when a broken and desperate party adopts it. As Ross said at a book event the other day, this is a decades-long project. But for now, it is entirely an intellectual one. Brooks is right that these are immensely interesting and provocative thinkers. I read most of them daily. I’m still waiting, however, for the dedicated and cynical reformers.

They may have to lose a couple of elections first.

Wehner On Dobson On Obama

Obamajeffhaynesafp

It’s good to see a conservative evangelical write this:

Dobson paraphrased this as "unless everybody agrees, we have no right to fight for what we believe in." But that’s not what Obama was saying at all. Rather, he was arguing that in a pluralistic nation like ours, politics depends on people of faith being able to persuade others based on common and accessible ground and appeals to reason — which sounds entirely reasonable. Christians who oppose abortion can make an effective case by talking about sonograms, fetal development and the moral imperative to protect the most vulnerable. That doesn’t mean one’s faith shouldn’t inform the question of abortion — or, for that matter, war, poverty and other issues. After all, President Lincoln’s argument against slavery was partly grounded in faith. But appeals to the Bible or church teaching aren’t sufficient in a pluralistic nation.

Pete is right: Obama has moved far more to the position of the Christianists than the Christianists have moved to his. And that gives Obama a great opportunity electorally. I say this with reluctance. Obama’s comfort with religious politics, and his connection of the Gospels with the redistributionist state, are far closer to the Bush-Gerson position than my more secular preference. But this is very clever politics and Dobson has taken the bait.

This is one of the more fascinating aspects of this race: Obama is a more appealing candidate to moderate Christianists than McCain is. And if Obama can break through the propaganda and reach the under-40s among evangelicals, we’re talking about a landslide.

(Photo: Jeff Haynes/Getty.)

The Perils Of Extreme Wealth

In an election cycle dominated by economic distress, John McCain could do without stories like this one. Put it with his silly gas tax harrumph and it couldn’t be more off-message. His campaign does seem pretty ramshackle from this distance right now. Maybe it’s the only way he knows. And maybe it will take a total polling collapse to get him into the scrappy underdog free-wheeler mode which is the only way he knows how to campaign successfully.

Bill Clinton: Obama Can “Kiss My Ass”

Well, it worked, literally, with Ms Lewinsky. The bitter ex-president is in classic form, according to the Sunday Telegraph:

Mr Obama is expected to speak to Mr Clinton for the first time since he won the nomination in the next few days, but campaign insiders say that the former president’s future campaign role is a "sticking point" in peace talks with Mrs Clinton’s aides. The Telegraph has learned that the former president’s rage is still so great that even loyal allies are shocked by his patronising attitude to Mr Obama, and believe that he risks damaging his own reputation by his intransigence. A senior Democrat who worked for Mr Clinton has revealed that he recently told friends Mr Obama could "kiss my ass" in return for his support. A second source said that the former president has kept his distance because he still does not believe Mr Obama can win the election.

If McCain Were A Democrat

He’d be tagged as an "elitist" by now. But the real problem with his gas price gaffe is how easy it would have been for him to have avoided it. I mean, I don’t drive at all, but I sure know that gas is now over $4 a gallon. Doesn’t McCain?

Update: I misread the quote. It’s the following:

WICKSOL: When was the last time you pumped your own gas and how much did it cost?

MCCAIN: Oh, I don’t remember. Now there’s Secret Service protection. But I’ve done it for many, many years. I don’t recall and frankly, I don’t see how it matters.

He was being asked how much it used to cost. So his answer isn’t so dumb – just the prickly attitude to the populist question.

The Impossible

From deep in the archives, a snippet of Kenneth Chafee Mcintosh’s 1921 article on the advent of the airplane:

In fifteen years aviation has superimposed itself upon civilization. Its future is limitless, not predictable. It is daily demonstrating its ability to extend the scope of our economic fabric to lengths undreamed of, and in ways which were but yesterday fantastic dreams. And it has already proved the power to destroy utterly the world as we have built it; has forced us to take sober and urgent thought as to how this mighty and as yet proportional and yet irresponsible force may be subordinated to the common good. The industrial changes following the introduction of steam and electrical machinery are trifling and infinitesimal compared with those already following in the wake of mankind’s new-found ability to fly.

The Stigma Of Non-Belief

Lori Lipman Brown, Director of the Secular Coalition for America, on the PEW report showing that a surprising number of atheists claim belief in God:

When atheists are telling you they believe in God and Catholics are admitting they don’t, that’s evidence of the stigma our society puts on nontheists. Americans repeatedly tell pollsters that an atheist is the last person they’d want their children to marry, the last person they’d vote for as President. This prejudice also appears in the widespread impression that atheists lack ethics and values.

A commenter on an atheist blog remarks on the obvious problem with this argument:

The Secular Coalition says that they gave mixed answers to the questions because of the stigma. But why would some people be afraid to say "atheist" but not "don’t believe in god" while other people are afraid to say "don’t believe in god" but not "atheist?" Though there is a stigma, that answer doesn’t satisfy me.