Barr > McCain > Obama

It’s a gun-off. From McCain’s statement on Heller:

Unlike Senator Obama, who refused to join me in signing a bipartisan amicus brief, I was pleased to express my support and call for the ruling issued today. Today’s ruling in District of Columbia v. Heller makes clear that other municipalities like Chicago that have banned handguns have infringed on the constitutional rights of Americans. Unlike the elitist view that believes Americans cling to guns out of bitterness, today’s ruling recognizes that gun ownership is a fundamental right – sacred, just as the right to free speech and assembly.

From Barr’s:

Sen. McCain has not advocated an absolute prohibition, “but he cosponsored legislation which could require registration of attendees at gun shows and even ban such shows,” Barr warns. And Sen. McCain’s campaign legislation “curtailed the First Amendment right of gun owners to protect their rights by participating in election campaigns.”

The Politics of Heller

Eugene Volokh:

This split should be useful to either of the Presidential candidates who wants to make either gun control or gun rights into an election issue — my guess is that this is more likely to be McCain. Expect McCain ads in states where there are likely many pro-gun swing voters stressing, "your constitutional right to keep and bear arms hangs by one vote." Also expect fundraising letters to likely pro-gun contributors stressing this at length.

Marc:

Are guns the keys to the kingdom for McCain? Judging by the rapidity of the RNC’s reaction to DC v. Heller, the craftmanship of McCain’s statement and the sudden appearance of McCain surrogates on the cable networks, the answer is: he thinks [so].

John McCormack:

Before the ruling was issued this morning, the Obama campaign, disavowed its "inartful" statement last year that "Obama believes the D.C. handgun law is constitutional."

Scott Lemineux:

The D.C. gun ban was clearly doomed. Scalia writing the lead opinion made a broader coalition less likely, and indeed the Court split 5-4, along typical ideological lines. And yet, based on a quick stand, Scalia’s opinion wasn’t exceptionally broad — while striking down the D.C. ban it emphasized that the reasonable regulation of gun ownership was perissible.

Tom Goldstein:

Individuals have a constitutional right to possess a basic firearm (the line drawn is unclear, but is basically those weapons in general lawful use and does not extend to automatic weapons) and to use that firearm in self-defense.  The government can prohibit possession of firearms by, for example, felons and the mentally ill.  And it can also regulate the sale of firearms, presumably through background checks.  The Court leaves open the constitutionality of a licensing requirement.

Matt:

From a policy perspective, what DC is trying to accomplish is just futile — as long as the District is a very small patch of land adjacent to Virginia, there’s no way gun regulations of this sort will prevent criminals from acquiring weapons.

Publius:

This part was expected — the key will be how broadly they read it, and whether it jeopardizes federal gun legislation.

Rosa Brooks:

When I bag my first D.C. deer with my handgun, I will send a shoulder of venison to Justice Scalia in grateful admiration. If I manage to take out any muggers—or bystanders caught in the crossfire—I will send him their carcasses as well.

Ezra Klein:

Some disappointing legal positioning from the Obama campaign in the past few days, as Obama put out a statement disagreeing with a 5-4 decision on the Supreme Court’s decision to bar the execution of child rapists (if Obama’s position were adopted, it would be the first time since the 60s that criminals have been put to death for crimes that don’t include murder) and his campaign flipped its position on the constitutionality of the DC handgun ban (were they once said Obama believed the ban unconstitutional, now they say he has no position on it).

As it happens, I actually don’t have a position on the constitutionality of the DC gun ban, don’t much care about Obamas position on it. He’s going to get hit for opportunism, but this is more the campaign being inartful than illiberal. At the same time, thought it’s not hard to see why Obama would want to take a maximally punitive stance against child rapists, he’s placing himself on the right of Breyer, Stevens, Ginsberg, Souter, and Kennedy and fighting their attempts to rollback capital punishment.

Bryan Appleyard:

After today’s decision, gun death acceptance seems to be as embedded in law as it is in the psyche. The bad guys have guns, people argue, therefore the good guys should have them. This is not a bad argument, though it would be refuted if the government seriously decided to remove guns from society as a whole. Others say it’s not guns that kill people, it’s people that kill people. This is a terrible argument for reasons that are so obvious I shan’t bother to rehearse them here. Gun culture remains one of America’s greatest aberrations. It baffles other nations. But there you go.

PEPFAR: Not There Yet

A caveat:

The new and expanded bill has been promoted by the White House, which actively engaged in the negotiations, and supported by presumed presidential nominees Sens. Barack Obama, D-Ill., and John McCain, R-Ariz.

Negotiators cautioned that several conservative Republicans still have issues with the bill, including the $50 billion price tag.

Yoo Testifies

And Marty Lederman comments:

John is testifying that his torture memos could have had no bearing on the abuse that took place in Iraq, because "the Geneva Conventions provided the relevant rules for the war in Iraq." There are several problems with this statement.

Most important is that OLC itself, when John was there, had advised the Pentagon that the Fourth Geneva Convention did not protect "unlawful combatants," which includes most if not all of the insurgents in Iraq.  (See page 4 of the April 2003 DOD Working Group Report.) …

This explains why, according to several reports (most importantly those of Sy Hersh and Jane Mayer), the Pentagon and CIA placed Special Forces and CIA operatives in Iraq in 2001 or 2002, whose basic instructions were that there was no law — certainly not Geneva — that protected detainees, and that the "gloves were off" and that they could engage in widespread, wanton abuse and cruelty. Which they did.

(And as the Fay, Jones and Schlesinger Reports found, and many accounts attest, the conspicuous abuse by CIA and Special Forces in Iraq was an important contributing factor to the breakdown of ordinary norms among the regular military forces, as well.) The Pentagon and CIA would not have given these forces the green light to abuse prisoners if OLC had not previously advised that neither the Geneva Conventions nor any relevant statutes stood in the way of such abuse.

Finally, John’s broad Commander-in-Chief override theory, which was a prominent part of the DOD Working Group Report, and which was briefed to General Miller on his way to "GTMOize" Iraq, obviously conveyed the message that the President could ignore any applicable statutes and treaties, even if they would otherwise apply.

John’s legal advice, then, was a fairly direct cause — certainly a necessary cause — of the abuse in Iraq in 2002 and 2003.