McCain’s Judgment in 2007

About as good as Obama’s in 2002:

The fact remains: he was right about the surge. Not necessarily about what to do next, or what our long-term goals in Iraq should be, but about the need to reduce violence and reach a minimum level of stability before we could expect any political progress. He was not just lucky-right; he was right because he understood the military requirements, and how a measure of military success might give the Iraqi government room to maneuver.

Andrew Sprung has some illuminating testimony from Gates’ confirmation. I hope I’ve acknowledged, with due caution, the fact that McCain was right and I was wrong around a year ago. I don’t think the skeptics should be blamed for not giving the Bush administration the benefit of the doubt. But I do think they’re wrong to deny the success since. Where that leaves us, of course, is a different question. And one in which Obama – unfairly perhaps – has the advantage.

Contra Greenwald

Joe Klein defends the FISA compromise. As often with Joe, and despite my sympathies with Glenn’s anger at Bush, I can’t disagree:

My feeling, from the start, has been that the NSA data-mining operation is a necessary tool in the hunt for terrorists who mean to do us harm–but that the FISA law needed to be updated to include civil liberties protections and limitations guiding the use of the program. The Bush Administration–as usual, arrogantly and outrageously–thought it didn’t need the legal authority to conducting the NSA operation and then–as usual, outrageously–tried to use the legitimate Democratic call for legislation as a "soft on terrorists" political bludgeon.

I favor the compromise because I believe the civil liberties encoded into the law are important, and because I wanted to deprive the Bush Administration, and the McCain campaign, of the political bludgeon.

Yes, the telecoms acted in a questionable manner–and yes, there were companies like Qwest that refused to comply, but in the end,as I’ve written before, their cooperation with the government, at a moment when just about everyone was freaking out about the terrorist threat (i.e.–right after 9/11) was understandable. Prosecuting them now, for past actions that will become legal when this bill is passed, is analogous to prosecuting doctors who performed abortions before Roe v. Wade after the court ruled…or prosecuting speakeasy owners after prohibition was overturned. Of course, if the telecoms engaged in actions that would be considered illegal even after the FISA compromise is passed, they should be prosecuted.

Obama, Lincoln, Cunning

A reader writes:

As a Chicagoan who has watched Obama emerge on the national scene, I couldn’t agree with you more about his cunning and charisma. Before things really started ramping up, people asked me whether he had a chance against the Clinton attack machine and I said "I look at all his opponents on both sides of the aisle and think, you poor, sad fools. You don’t even know what you are getting into."

Every time I read articles about this I think about Herndon’s statement about Lincoln:

"That man who thinks Lincoln sat down calmly and gathered his robes about him, waiting for the people to call him, has a very erroneous knowledge of Lincoln. He was always calculating, and always planning ahead. His ambition was a little engine that knew no rest."

That describes Barack Obama to a tee which is precisely why he is such an incredibly deadly politician.

The Drilling Canard

Think of it in the same light as the pork-busting campaign. Although it appears as a solution to a problem, it’s actually a trivial effort designed to distract from the real challenge: fiscal balance and energy independence, respectively. To put it plainly:

I don’t know about you, but I’m embarrassed when the president of the US, allegedly the most “can-do” nation in the world, repeatedly goes to the Saudis and begs for increases in oil production to sustain our ridiculous habit. Just as futile, drilling in and around the US for oil is nothing more than searching the couches for loose change, and the analogy holds when you consider just exactly what you can buy with loose change- almost nothing.

On Pornography

A reader writes:

It strikes me that Ross bases his argument on the assumption that the porn watching offends the non-watching partner. In that case I can understand his claim that the watching constitutes a form of adultery, though I strongly disagree. Surely it is, at most, an act of dishonesty — one that has to be weighed against the right to privacy that persists even within the closest of relationships.

But, of course, his original assumption doesn’t hold in many cases. I watch porn; so does my girlfriend. Sometimes together, sometimes alone. Individually, it’s a turn-on; mutually, a happy addition to our sex lives. We’re hardly unique. The key is that we both know about the other’s porn-watching and heartily approve of it. There’s no betrayal involved. There’s friendship. And some other delightful things that also begin with F.

More broadly, Ross’s stance raises the question of what constitutes an adult relationship. Images on paper or screen cannot possibly form the basis of a relationship, adult or otherwise; and without a relationship, surely there can be no adultery. More importantly, his stance would force "offending" porn-watchers to one of two conclusions: continued deception of their partner — a sort of sexual stealing-from-the-cookie-jar — or submission to their partner’s sense of propriety — what we used to call peer pressure. Both are infantilizing.