Political Suicide?

Dayo Olopade:

Iraq is not an island, but DC sure is. And here I’ll inject my own pessimism: It would be political suicide for Obama to change his stance on Iraq–even though it is clearly the right thing to do. We’ve reached a point wherein hand-waving rigidity is lauded as righteousness (in both parties) and nuance is punished swiftly. Never mind that Obama drafted his plan for withdrawal a full 18 months ago, or that the drawdown from the surge is behind schedule, or that Maliki is emboldened by recent successes, that Bush is kicking the can down the road, or that General David Petraeus has declared that we won’t know we’ve made progress "until we’re six months past it." The pitchforked mob will have the flip-floppers, dead or alive.

But the Obama campaign, it seems to me, is fueled by the opposite conviction: that we can use reason in politics, not dumb-ass Morris-Rove tactical blather. On an issue as profound as this one, there is no need for a U-turn; the goal is still withdrawal of all troops as soon as is prudent. That’s all Obama need say: that he wants us to leave entirely as soon as makes sense. He was against the war from the beginning, which makes him a far more credible advocate for withdrawal than McCain.

I guess I would never have supported Obama if I thought he were incapable of prudent, pragmatic adjustment in policies. We’ll see.

The Limits Of The Surveillance State

Sometimes governments have too much information for their own good:

Cover every square inch of the city with CCTVs and you’ll get so much information that you’ll never make any sense of it. Scotland Yard says that CCTVs help solve fewer than 3% of all crimes, while a study in San Francisco found that at best, criminals simply move out of camera range, while at worst they assume no one is watching. Similarly, if you take fingerprints from every person who applies for a visa – or worse still, from every person in Britain who has to carry one of the proposed new biometric cards – you will fill the databases with chaff that slows down searches, generates endless false matches, and threatens everyone in the database with the worst kind of identity theft.

Quote For The Day

"As a witness sitting here in a hearing, I feel like I have some obligation to say something about this. And I’m very limited, I think, in what I can say. But if the subcommittee has been informed that there was a total of three minutes of waterboarding, I would suggest the subcommittee should go back and get that clarified, because that I don’t believe is an accurate statement," – Dan Levin, formerly of the president’s Office Of Legal Counsel.

Marty Lederman has a helpful summary of Dan Levin’s testimony yesterday here.

Mission Accomplished!

Oilfieldtobymelvillegetty

Today is a good day to re-read my friend Jim Holt’s alarmingly prescient piece in the LRB last fall when he declared the Iraq war a great success:

The value of Iraqi oil, largely light crude with low production costs, would be of the order of $30 trillion at today’s prices. For purposes of comparison, the projected total cost of the US invasion/occupation is around $1 trillion.

Who will get Iraq’s oil? One of the Bush administration’s ‘benchmarks’ for the Iraqi government is the passage of a law to distribute oil revenues. The draft law that the US has written for the Iraqi congress would cede nearly all the oil to Western companies. The Iraq National Oil Company would retain control of 17 of Iraq’s 80 existing oilfields, leaving the rest – including all yet to be discovered oil – under foreign corporate control for 30 years.

Ta-da! The deal just announced for US oil companies is not just any old deal. It’s a series of no-bid contracts:

Imagine. At the precise moment when demand for oil was the highest in history, a recently democratized country with enormous reserves had the chance to sell extraction contracts to the highest bidder. This was a country that desperately needed the revenue to help rebuild its schools, power grid and water supply after a long internal conflict. So why did it hand out the contracts with no auction at all?

Because the US told them so. You don’t get to conquer a new province and not get any spoils, do you? Who needs ANWR or a carbon tax when you can drain Iraq at record high oil prices?

(Photo: Toby Melville/Getty.)

Responding To Manzi

A reader writes:

Manzi is, from what I’ve read of his stuff (and I haven’t read it all), absolutely right.  Pure cap-and-trade/regulatory programs, including Kyoto, are basically worthless and dead.  I say this as a flaming leftist environmentalist, but it wasn’t Manzi who convinced me.  It was Michael Shellenberger and Ted Nordhaus, in their 2004 essay(pdf), "The Death of Environmentalism."  The pair has since gone on to write a follow-up book and maintain a blog, but for a quick introduction the original essay is a 30 minute read and worth every minute.

The core premise is that the model of environmentalism that emerged from the 70s was all about a combination of saying "no" to various forms of pollution and building regulatory structures.  At all points, economic expansion was seen as a problem, not as a benefit.  All of this has failed miserably to do anything about global warming, for which we’ve had good evidence for 15 years.

S&N argue that fundamentally, climate change remediation simply won’t happen until it’s tied to a program for job creation, economic growth, and a vision of a future that doesn’t solely focus on a better environment, but also focuses on a better life for us all.  Here, they and Manzi agree.

Where they depart, and where you’ll probably get indigestion, is in that they recommend a strong program of environmentally advantageous economic stimuli, from a national sustainable energy initiative, state investment in rail infrastructure, and a general focus on investment over regulation.

So add another argument into the mix.  There’s the old debate, with the Lieberman-Warner mess on one end, still trying to use the techniques that fought acid rain and smog on global warming, and the deniers on the other end covering their ears and screaming.  The new debate has Manzi on one end saying, "it can’t be done, so quit trying," and Shellenberger and Nordhaus on the end saying, "proper government investment means economic growth and greenhouse reductions."  My guess is that by the time 2012 rolls around and we’re doing this Presidential thing all over again, we’ll be thoroughly ensconced in the new debate.

How Much Stronger Is Today’s Marijuana?

The drug czar would have you believe it’s 30 8 times the strength of the 1970s. No one doubts that pot is now a lot stronger than it once was – although it varies widely. That’s the genius of modern agriculture. But so what? Jacob Sullum makes a point that seems lost on the pleasure-police:

With stronger pot, people can smoke less to achieve the same effect, thereby reducing their exposure to combustion products, the most serious health risk associated with marijuana consumption. Yet the ONDCP inexplicably warns that higher THC levels could mean "an increased risk" of "respiratory problems."

Huh? And why do they never mention vaporizers? Vaporizers – the norm in parts of the pot subculture – remove all the smoke side-effects and still allow THC absorption. But the pleasure, of course, remains.

Why Rugby Is Like Opera

That’s what you get when you switch your sports writers with your culture writers as the Guardian just did. One former rugby player now sports writer – admittedly French – had an epiphany:

Talking afterwards to the tenor Jonas Kaufmann, who played Cavaradossi, I came to the conclusion that there is a parallel between what you feel during a top-class rugby match and what an artist feels on stage – and it’s not just the roar of the crowd. The people who are watching influence how you behave: they were viewing Kaufmann and driving him forward, just as they used to inspire me. I could empathise with Kaufmann’s total concentration on the performance, and the way he had to become one with the orchestra, who gave him the power to go beyond the norm. There is a physical aspect to opera, certainly; but more than that, on stage you see what in rugby we call "automatisms" – where you become conditioned to move and act by pure instinct. I had a sense of two completely different worlds coming together.