Take it from Alberto Mora, former Navy general counsel:
Category: The Dish
The Neo-Imperial Route
Karl Meyer compares Britain’s 1930 agreement with Iraq to the one America is trying to arrange:
The "strategic alliance" that President Bush is proposing eerily resembles, in spirit and in letter, a failed 1930 treaty between Britain and Iraq that prompted a nationalist eruption in Baghdad, a pro-Nazi military coup and a pogrom that foreshadowed the elimination of Baghdad’s ancient Jewish community. […]
According to press reports based on leaks from the Iraqi Parliament, the pact envisions giving the Americans rights to as many as 58 military bases and control of Iraqi airspace. It would grant immunity from Iraqi laws to American military personnel. And it would empower American officials to detain suspected terrorists without the approval of Iraqi authorities.
Joe Klein responds:
It is probable that the Maliki government will want a U.S. military presence, for the time being. But the rules governing that presence should be similar to those accorded the U.S. military in countries like Japan and Germany–i.e. without the right to act unilaterally on Iraqi terrain. Any intimation that the U.S. is forcing conditions on the Iraqis will result, as Meyer notes, in long-term resentment and reaction–and continued violence against our troops.
In the end, as I’ve written here before, there is no good rationale for a permanent U.S. military presence in Iraq; it will be a permanent irritant. And this seems one of the clear foreign policy differences in the presidential campaign: McCain wants a long-term presence. Obama doesn’t.
Whose Wife Is More Of A Victim?
A pretty depressing exchange between Obama and McCain. Both men can really do better.
The View From Your Window
Swing State Bounce
Quinnipiac has Obama leading in Pennsyvania, Ohio, and Florida. Nate Silver:
Obama’s lead nationally is still relatively small — we have it at somewhere between 4 and 5 points — but looks to be an unusually robust one in terms of the Electoral College. Rick Davis can probably give these numbers about another week or two to settle down before he has to start thinking about some fundamental changes in his candidate’s messaging.
The last argument of the Clintons evaporates.
Who Trusts Bush?
A graph showing countries’ confidence, or lack thereof, in Bush’s foreign policy.
On The Cutting Room Floor
A reader writes:
As a film editor, I know all about the issues involved with the length of films. You are often challenged by a couple things. One, the length of the script that was approved to start shooting. Usually the first cut of a film is about an hour longer than the finished film, give or take, but that’s what everybody agreed to shoot, knowing the fight over what to keep in or what to cut would inevitably come later.
Secondly, to make those cuts later can be tricky, involving all kinds of editorial slight-of-hand. And then when pushed to an extreme to reduce the length, you inevitably lose breathing room, character development, continuity or even comprehensibility. Then you end up firing up the other set of critics complaining about plot confusion. So sometimes you’re damned if you do, damned if you don’t. It’s easy to walk out of a theater saying, "They could have cut 20 minutes out." While the sentiment may be completely justifiable, often achieving that can be tough as you negotiate between the various parties involved.
That said, Stravinsky felt the same frustration saying many symphonies "finish too long after the end." And then there’s Mark Twain who said, "I didn’t have time to write a short letter, so I wrote a long one instead." Being concise is a challenge, a battle that is often lost in film cutting rooms all around the world, apparently…
Another View From Abroad
A reader writes:
I was in Europe the past two weeks and it was absolutely stunning. Everywhere I went, people wanted to speak to me about Obama. An old woman sweeping the street in Lisbon stopped me when she heard me speaking English and said: "American? Obama?" I could only shake my head and smile since I don’t speak Portuguese. The doorman in Frankfurt, the waiter in Munich and the hotel receptionist in The Netherlands all bent my ear for about 10-15 minutes about how they are so looking forward to having Obama as President. Notice that they didn’t say "your President" or "the American President" – it was simply "President". Everyone feels like they have a stake in this election. I hope the American public understands just how important it is that we get this one right.
Finally, at a medical conference a doctor from Angola came up to me with tears in his eyes and implored for me to vote for Obama. I told him that I was an Obama supporter and he thank me over and over. As he left, he said to me "Only in America. Only in America."
Producing The Right Kind Of Babies
Kerry Howley writes about fertility panics:
For those who, with good reason, worry about the solvency of transfer programs in an age of population decline, replacement immigration looks like a partial solution, and therefore xenophobia is part of the problem. But for many if not most of the people preoccupied by fertility rates, immigration is no solution at all. The question isn’t about whether the United States, Singapore, or France will be without people in 2100; it’s about what kind of people will populate those countries: what they will look like, what they will teach in their schools, what God they will bow before. Mark Steyn’s America Alone warns that within a few generations Europe will be a Muslim continent. When Pat Buchanan discusses depopulation in The Death of the West, he does not proceed to suggest we replace children of European descent with Mexican laborers. Pro-natalist policies in Quebec, Singapore, and until recently Israel implicitly target a preferred ethnic group, attempting to fill the future with the demographics desired by the current political class.
Will Wilkinson, Megan, and Ross respond.
(Photo: Roslan Rahman/AFP/Getty.)
Independent Joe
Chait takes aim at Lieberman:
Lieberman explains that he calls himself an "independent Democrat" because the Democratic Party’s foreign policy ideals "exist in me today independent of the current Democratic Party, which has rejected them." This is a wildly egocentric interpretation. Democrats started questioning the war because the war was going badly, while Lieberman remained–to borrow a phrase–in a spider hole of denial.


