Malkin Award Nominee

"Only one thing is certain: Our terrorist enemies still at large must be amazed, amused and encouraged by the continued insistence by legal elites that they be treated like petty American criminals rather than fanatical killers eager for martyrdom. It is as though the five justices and their clerks are wholly ignorant of the rising stack of books and flood of articles detailing the nature of the enemy and their creed of death," – Hugh Hewitt, responding to Boumediene.

I hope terrorists are amazed at the West’s ability to fight them without abandoning the core principle of its own freedom. It’s what they are trying to destroy.

“We Invaded To Liberate”

Baqubaalexandernemenovafpgetty

A reader fisks me bad:

"We invaded to liberate, not to control".

Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha!

Of course this is about control, and always has been. Oil, Israel, Iran. Remaking the Middle East. Securing Bush’s place in history as the Conqueror of the East, the only man man enough to take the recalcitrant desert barbarians by the scruff of the neck and bring them to heel.

Empire? We’ve been a continental empire (some would say a hemispheric empire) since at least the Mexican-American War, an international empire since the Spanish American War, and a global empire since the end of WWII, with our eastern march at the wall in Berlin and our western march at the DMZ in Korea. Democracies can be empires too. Ask the Athenians (and ask them about the Sicilian Expedition while you’re at it).

What do you mean, empire is not in our blood? We ARE the Roman Empire — at least, the Western Roman Empire. Russia, of course was the Eastern Roman Empire. The Cold War was the contest to see which would prevail. We won. Now we retake the provinces of Judea — our Holy Land, which we’ve been trying to re-take for a thousand years  — and Persia and Afghanistan, the farthest extent of our ancient Greco-Roman influence.

I agree with Ferguson: our problem is not empire — it’s incompetence.

No, I have not become a neo-con — but let’s be realistic: beyond the drive to re-take the East, there’s all that oil. We need it. They have it. Therefore we must control them. It’s that simple. It’s not even a moral question, it’s just biology: where the energy source is, the strongest will congregate. It’s not a matter of "corporate profits" — although it is that too. It’s a matter of survival. Obama will not leave Iraq either. You watch.

Fisking, fisking: one, two, three::

"What I fear is that the Bush administration and many neo-conservatives are claiming one thing, while planning for another…"

What? Hello? Are you serious? This has been going on since September 12, 2001. And explain to me, how is "claiming one thing, while planning for another", not a lie?

"…and after the last eight years, the trust level is low."

Ha, ha. If they’d just found those pesky old corroded WMD stockpiles from 1991, they could have held them up in triumph — "See? We told you so!" — but Saddam, that wily old fox, stole a march on them there. And then there was that insurrection thing. And Chalabi didn’t turn out so well either. No, the problem is not empire. It’s simple competence.

"I fear they want a permanent presence in Iraq to reassure Israel; and to pursue the option of war with Iran."

Is this a joke? Are you pulling my leg? I fear not. You really are just figuring out they always meant to have a permanent presence?

"I fear the bases are there to detain, contain or attack the regional Shiite power, Iran, and to reassure the regional Sunni powers that the US military will protect them."

I’m sorry, i don’t mean to be sarcastic, but — doh! Yes, of course — Afghanistan to the East, Iraq to the West: we have ancient Persia surrounded. Only one of us can control the ancient East. We’ve been at war with Iran for that control for decades. What do you think all this has been about? Iraq, Hezbollah, Hamas?

"If this is the agenda, please let us know."

They did. You weren’t listening.

"Let the American people examine and debate it."

Sure. Like they debated the Mexican-American War, the Spanish-American War, WWI, WWII, the Korean War, the Vietnam War. Debate all you want. That’s not how these things are decided — if you can even say they’re decided at all. (In fact the Vietnam War was the only war we’ve ever actually "debated" — or at least struggled over — and that led to the great Boomer schism you detest so much. See any irony there?)

"Have McCain own this position rather than refer to it as a premise as if we already know what it is."

But we do. We do.

(Photo: Alexander Nemenov/Getty.)

Sign Of The Times

Weddingcakedavidmcnewgetty

Dan Savage emails me an email he just got from a reader of his advice column. Telling, I think:

I am a 31 year old gay male and have been with my 27 year old boyfriend for exactly one year. This year has been absolutely amazing and he has been everything I have ever wanted in a relationship. While everything has been fantastic, we have had some issues in our relationship that center around trust and communication. Our previous relationships failed for many reasons, primarily because of infidelity and being lied to. We have at times displayed a lack of trust for each other because of being hurt in the past. I am hoping to correct my lack of trust and communications issues through therapy and proving to him over time that I will never hurt him or cheat on him.

Where it gets complicated is that on our one year anniversary, he proposed to me. I told him that I thought it was too soon and that I felt I wanted to resolve any and all of the trust issues we have before committing to marriage. Needless to say he was hurt, said that he would get over it and would look to ask me again in a year. My question is, is it possible that I have caused irreparable damage to the relationship? Should I have said yes (as I do see myself marrying him some day) while committing to a long engagement? Is working these things out before marriage absolutely necessary?

Finally, we get to work through the same issues as heterosexuals. Finally, dating and relationships have a structure that helps order them, even if that structure is recognized in abeyance.

(Photo: David McNew/Getty.)

McCain And Executive Power

Mccainmariotamagetty

Matt Welch says no one should be under any false impression:

I don’t think he’ll be hiring John Yoo, or looking actively for new methods to justify torture, but if you think that any John Sidney McCain will let something like the letter of the law, or the constitutional separation of powers, prevent him from acting swiftly to defend America’s interests (however he defines it), then you probably haven’t been paying close attention.

Ron Bailey adds:

Pace Holtz-Eakin, this issue is not of interest only to "the ACLU and trial lawyers"; pace McCain, it is not an excuse for pointless recriminations about long-ago actions that are irrelevant to "addressing the challenge we face today." As we "move forward," there are few questions more important than whether the president is bound to obey the law even when it conflicts with his own ideas about how best to fight terrorism. If McCain cannot give a straight answer to that question and stick to it, he does not deserve the vote of anyone who believes in the rule of law and the separation of powers.

(Photo: Mario Tama/Getty.)

Indefinite Detention

Poulos thoughts on yesterday’s Supreme Court ruling:

Gitmo is a hodgepodge of freaks, has-beens, brutes, and hapless extras. Some detainees ought to be there because of what they´ve done (enemy combatants). Some of them ought to be there because of who they are. But for every handful or so of those characters, there are random Uighurs and others who seem to be ´unreturnable´to their place of origin. Any commentary on Guantanamo has to start from this point of departure, I think.

But the real problem is the interminable detention period, which has no reasonable judicial excuse. The dissenters are quite right that America has offered a quite generous set of procedural protections for enemy combatants. But these are mocked when a detainee is an indefinite prisoner with indefinitely incomprehensible status. The problem is not the legal process but what happens when the federal government holds that process, at its whim, in open-ended abeyance.

A Question Of Empire, Ctd

Larison joins the debate:

There is nothing “excessive” about the word empire to describe the political and military domination of other countries.  Hegemony may be slightly more precise, but the practical difference between hegemony and empire is not very great when hegemony entails the establishment of dozens of military bases on foreign soil.  Perhaps people who believe that Washington and Baghdad are merely negotiating a bilateral “status of forces” agreement as between two equal, sovereign states also think that the Batavian Republic was a free and independent state that just had a very friendly relationship with France.  Oh, but that couldn’t have been imperialism–France was democratic at the time!  France and the Batavian Republic also made a treaty, one that was quite disadvantageous to the Dutch but a treaty all the same, so that must have made the ensuing occupation all right.   

If there is one good thing that might come out of the disaster of the war in Iraq, it is that the absurd, excessive and naive faith that democracies are never aggressive and imperialistic may be shaken at least a little.    

Internet Books

Ross’s response to Carr’s article and to Max Boot’s dissent:

I’ve made a related argument in the context of blogs, arguing that the web is very good for certain forms of writing – the highly political and the highly personal chief among them – and very bad for others; by extension, I’d say that the web is very good for certain forms of book-writing (shorter forms on the one hand, and forms that require large amounts of research on the other ) and very bad for others (forms that require large amounts of serious reflection to write, and to read).