It’s one thing for a journalist to give speeches to college audiences. It’s another to be paid by big corporate interests. And it’s another thing entirely to bask in corporate speech-making while condemning it in your columns.
Category: The Dish
A Question Of Empire, Ctd.
A reader writes:
Oh Andrew, come on. Can we have a reasoned debate about the long-term military presence in Iraq without having to wade into Chomsky-level rhetoric about the "expansion of American empire." The U.S. is a democracy negotiating with the elected leaders of a country over a military alliance between two nations. This is not the British in Malaysia. And we have already ceded to Iraqi demands regarding immunity for private contractors, authorization by Iraqi leaders in regards to military operations, and not using Iraq as a base of operations against other countries.
McCain’s point is correct. Americans, by and large, do not care about U.S. service members being stationed overseas. Your primary objection to a U.S. military presence in Iraq, as far as I can tell, is so called blowback–the idea that a U.S. presence in Iraq will incite Islamic extremist to terrorist activity. The debate, therefore, is whether or not the strategic benefits to a military presence outweigh the costs of inciting Islamic extremists. If, however, that is the primary calculus, then certainly the question over our strategic alliance with Israel would be as important a question as our presence in Iraq. But as far as I can tell, the difference on that question between the two candidates is practically nil. Oddly enough, the American public does not seem too vexed about the "expansion of American empire" into Afghanistan.
I’m struggling with this word "empire", because it is indeed excessive in the respects my reader points out and yet all the euphemisms seem to miss the point as well. Here’s why: the US, without a second UN resolution, invaded a country, destroyed its regime, enabled chaos and near civil-war, and then helped establish a divided, but elected, government and wants to retain 50 bases in defense of that government. 50 bases. And yet the government itself seems deeply ambivalent and divided about this, the opposition strongly opposed, and Iraqis leery. Muslims everywhere would regard such a large US presence as an affront. The issue could even prompt serious weakening of a newly confident Maliki government. Yet we keep pressing for such a presence and the Republican nominee seems not to bat an eyelid at the decades of troop presence this could entail.
What do we call this? It’s a good question. The troops in Germany, Japan and South Korea were established there to contain and deter the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union has passed away and yet still the troops remain. The troops were sent to Iraq to remove what we were told was a serious threat to the security of the US in Saddam’s regime. Saddam’s regime has passed away, the WMDs have been revealed as paper tigers, and yet still the troops remain. We were told this was to avoid chaos; but now we are told that even if chaos is averted and some stability restored, the troops must stay. The stated reason? Anti-terrorism. And what if the Iraqi government says it can control internal terrorism? Why would we need 50 bases then?
What I’m getting at is the constant drift in which what was unimaginable yesterday is now the baseline for today. Can we at least take a step back and think through what this means for the long term?
I should add that I’m a little surprised by my own resistance to this idea – and see it as in part a response to being burned so badly by the neocons these last few years. A stable democratic Iraq is obviously a great thing – for Iraq, the region and our security. But my own view is that if this wonderful scenario were to eventually transpire (and that remains a huge if), the point is Iraqi independence and freedom – not military dependence on and political cooptation by the US. We invaded to liberate, not to control.
What I fear is that the Bush administration and many neo-conservatives are claiming one thing, while planning for another; and after the last eight years, the trust level is low. I fear they want a permanent presence in Iraq to reassure Israel; and to pursue the option of war with Iran. I fear the bases are there to detain, contain or attack the regional Shiite power, Iran, and to reassure the regional Sunni powers that the US military will protect them. If this is the agenda, please let us know. Let the American people examine and debate it. Have McCain own this position rather than refer to it as a premise as if we already know what it is.
Here’s what it is, it seems to me: an irrevocable new step in American enmeshment in the Middle East, with unknowable consequences. It could well be seen by Shiites as a de facto alliance with Sunni Arab powers to contain a resurgent Shiite renaissance in Iran and Iraq. Or it could be viewed, if the US is seen as synonymous with a Shiite government, as a lingering source of suspicion and grievance by Sunnis. Or both, depending on the moment. In a lull in an immensely complex and shifting conflict, we risk deciding by default on getting even more deeply involved in an ancient religious war in a combustible Middle East. And the purported enemy at the root of all this – terrorism, Sunni or Shia, depending on the need of the time – is so amorphous it can be used to justify invasion and occupation almost anywhere.
If it isn’t empire, it is something perilously close. And we need to discuss it as a major issue in this campaign.
(Photo of an Iraqi soldier by Chris Hondros/Getty.)
Bobby Jindal: Errant Catholic Exorcist?
This will bum out the theocons. A reader notes:
You may not realize that what Jindal did is strictly forbidden to Catholic laity.
The Catholic Church takes the possibility of demonic possession very seriously, albeit very rare, and because of centuries-long experience that dabbling by the inexperienced (whoever well intentioned they may be) in this area is rather disastrous, decrees the following in Canon 1172 of the Code of Canon Law (1983):
Can. 1172: §1 No one may lawfully exorcise the possessed without the special and express permission of the local Ordinary.
§2 This permission is to be granted by the local Ordinary only to a priest who is endowed with piety, knowledge, prudence and integrity of life.
One wonders if any of the ultramontane crowd at The New Oxford Review bothered to ask Jindal if he had such permission or criticized him severely if it did not.
I love Dish readers. They seem to know everything.
Home Cooking
Stephen Dubner makes some ice cream and some points about locavores. More often than not, locally eaten and prepared food is less efficient, less green, and, in my case, much less tasty.
“One Penis Up, One Penis Down”
I loved this: it’s a series of YouTube movie reviews with two old codgers – "ReelGeezers" – ranting on intelligently about "Superbad." They also review "Sex And The City."
Long, long ago, I tried to persuade Barry Diller of all people to put on a political talk show including only those over 70 years old. Call it: The Old Timers. The great thing about the old is that they don’t give a shit any more, and tend to say what they think. Imagine Mike Gravel debating Bob Dole with Frank Mankiewcz and Helen Thomas. Maybe not. But you get the point. And YouTubes are once again leading the way.
Time Out?
I’ve been feeling adrift myself these past few days. Drained, flat, a little cranky. A reader writes:
After some informal polling, my friends and I (Democratic, Republican and Independent) are taking a political time out now that the Democratic primary is over. We were absolutely obsessed with the primary, and we desperately need a break. The daily (hourly?) back and forths between McCain and Obama are of no interest to us right now (and also are very silly).
We will check in periodically, but until August (or the vps are selected), we’re all getting back to our normal lives, such as they are. It’s not personal. We just need a little space for ourselves. So Andrew, Josh, Arianna, Keith, my friends at the New Republic and on the Trail, we’ll talk in two months.
I understand the feeling. In retrospect, this primary campaign became a total mini-series of adrenaline and drama rushes. We’re in the depressive detox recovery stage now. And the Obama-McCain contest seems oddly dull and currently trivial – at least to me, it does. How does one get it up for the Jim Johnson story?
Quote For The Day
"The ex-president revealed to a crucial number of people something that many of us already knew: he is a raging psycho. It’s very gratifying to see more people catching up to that now," – Christopher Hitchens, on Bill Clinton, yesterday.
Hispanics And Obama
Encouraging news for the Democrat from the NBC poll:
By 62% to 28%, Hispanic voters support Sen. Obama. "That does not bode well for Republicans" in the Southwest, the Republican pollster added, in swing states such as Nevada, New Mexico and Colorado, where Hispanic voters are numerous enough to tip the result. Sen. McCain, who comes from a state with a large Hispanic population and has favored liberalizing policies toward illegal immigrants, has hopes of matching Mr. Bush’s record of winning more than 40% of Hispanic voters.
But this has got to worry Team O:
White suburban women, who make up 10% of the electorate, prefer a Democrat to be president by 11 points, 47% to 36%, the poll shows. And if Sen. Clinton were the nominee and the election were held now, she would beat Sen. McCain among this group by 14 points, 51% to 37%. Yet Sen. Obama loses to Sen. McCain by six points, 44% to 38%, among the same group.
A Sudoku Mistrial
Well, if you’d been on a jury for 66 days …
Whittling Away The Electoral College
A PEW report on states getting rid of the electoral college:
Maryland last year became the first state to approve a "national popular vote" compact that would allocate all of its 10 electoral votes to the candidate who wins the most votes nationwide, rather than to the candidate who garners the most votes in the state, as is the case under the Electoral College.
New Jersey, Hawaii and Illinois have since followed suit and passed laws that would allot their collective 40 electoral votes the same way. Identical bills are moving in Massachusetts, New York, North Carolina and Rhode Island, which have a total of 62 electoral votes.
These bills do nothing on their own and would take effect only when states that collectively have at least 270 electoral votes pass identical measures, since a candidate needs 270 electoral votes to win the presidency.
