The Future In Iraq

Joe Klein – who seems on the question of Iraq to be in eerie synchrony with the Dish – posits:

My guess, backed by reporting, is that four years from now, if current trends continue, there will be about 30,000 U.S. forces stationed at 3 or 4 bases in Iraq–a troop level that Barack Obama would probably endorse. It is extremely unlikely, given the natural truculence of Iraqis (for which they are famous in the region), that those 30,000 would be allowed to remain in perpetuity.

I could live with that. Could McCain?

Re-Mixing Radiohead With Extra Snark

It doesn’t sound good, but that’s not the point. A snarky Brit explains:

Radiohead held an online contest to remix "Nude" from their album – "In Rainbows" This was quite a difficult task for everybody that entered, as Nude is in 6/8 timing, and 63bpm. Most music that’s played in clubs is around 120bpm and usually 4/4 timing. It’s pretty difficult to seamlessly mix a waltz beat into a DJ set. This resulted in lots of generic entries consisting of a typical 4/4 beat, but with arbitrary clips from "Nude" thrown in so that they qualified for the contest.

Thom Yorke joked at the ridiculousness of it in an interview for NPR radio, hinting that they set the competition to find out how people would approach such a challenging task. I decided to take the piss a bit, as the contest seemed to be in that spirit.

Based on the lyric (and alternate title) "Big Ideas: Don’t get any" I grouped together a collection of old redundant hardware, and placed them in a situation where they’re trying their best to do something that they’re not exactly designed to do, and not quite getting there. It doesn’t sound great, as it’s not supposed to.

The music starts about a minute in:


(Hat tip: Creative Review)

A Change Election

A new poll shows how true this still is:

Here’s one question from today’s NBC News/Wall Street Journal poll that we’re releasing early: 59% say it’s more important to have a president who will focus on progress and moving America forward, versus 37% who would rather the president protect what has made America great.

Advantage: Obama.

Dissent Of The Day, Ctd.

A reader writes:

The discussion on your site about occupation seems, to me, to miss the point.  "Occupation" is a precise term under international law.  It is clearly defined and has strict parameters that are based on Article 42 of the 1907 Hague Regulations.  The International Committee of the Red Cross has a good FAQ page on what is an occupation here.  And you can find a pretty good overall analysis of the issue as it applies to Iraq here.

The most relevant point is when an occupation comes to an end (from the ICRC FAQ page):

The normal way for an occupation to end is for the occupying power to withdraw from the occupied territory or be driven out of it. However, the continued presence of foreign troops does not necessarily mean that occupation continues.

A transfer of authority to a local government re-establishing the full and free exercise of sovereignty will normally end the state of occupation, if the government agrees to the continued presence of foreign troops on its territory. However, the law of occupation may become applicable again if the situation on the ground changes, that is to say, if the territory again becomes "actually placed under the authority of the hostile army" (H R, art. 42) – in other words, under the control of foreign troops without the consent of the local authorities.

If we follow these guidelines, then the United States was an occupying power during the Coalition Provisional Authority period, but ceased to be so when a "local government re-establishing the full and free exercise of sovereignty" came into existence.  We can debate whether the Maliki government actually exercises its sovereignty fully and freely, but given the fact that the UN Security Council recognized a formal end to the occupation as of 30 June 2004, "occupation" is the wrong word here.

To be clear, I oppose the war and would like the troops to come home soon.  I also think that the growing opposition in Iraq to the Status of Forces Agreement represents the strongest possible evidence that the Iraqis want us to leave, and that we should take the hint sooner rather than later.  But it’s important that we use terms precisely, and "occupation" as defined in international law just doesn’t fit.