Carter Clone

Jennifer Rubin on McCain comparing Obama to Carter:

The McCain camp wants and needs desperately to have a simple and easy tagline to conjure up bad thoughts about Obama in the way “Bush’s twin” or “Bush’s clone” works on the imagination of the anti-Bush crowd. Carter may not be “it,” but you can see the wheels turning at the McCain camp as they ponder how to knock down Obama’s lofty image and get voters to think about Obama’s actual policy proposals and their likely results.

The trouble is: Bush is a Republican version of Carter. And memory of his legacy is a little fresher.

The Prius

Greener than Reihan suggested. A reader adds:

I’m disappointed that you lent so much credence to Reihan in the Prius-bashing, who lends so much credence to that Wired article without at least noting that soon the Toyota Prius will be switching to a lithium battery, which will change that calculus completely.

It’s true that the Prius does have a bit of a green footprint issue vs. a used car, but that’s kind of a silly argument to make considering the fact that the used car is clearly a different product than a new car, and a different market. It’s a bit unfair in an apples to apples way to pick the most fuel-efficient used-car you can find and put it up against a new car, where it has a built-in advantage immediately in its carbon footprint because it’s used! Why not a new Prius vs. a used suburban? I wonder who would win that comparison?

   

Also, it’s silly to assume a used TERCEL or GEO METRO is going to be a plausible product for most people since the reliability of those cars and whatever longevity might be left on a used one is dubious at best. You might as well urge "green living" by using your coffee ground three or four times before you throw them out. Sure it’s an awful beverage or has no actual flavor left by the fourth time, but hey, it’s greener so that’s the choice a green must make! These arguments trying to bring in crazy scenarios about using old cars that Reihan even acknowledges are death traps all just seem like silly contrarianism.

Bush Lied?

Many dissents from my view that the administration did not lie about Saddam’s WMDs or even his potential links with al Qaeda. They recklessly oversold dubious intelligence and exaggerated his threat. I don’t think this makes them less culpable for the botch-up. This commenter at the Economist captures the point:

Is "lying" the appropriate benchmark?

In the business world the benchmark is "due diligence". In issuing a prospectus, for example, it is not sufficient that it contains no "lies". On the other hand, it is not necessary that the undertaking be guaranteed of success. The required standard is that those responsible for promoting the undertaking demonstrate that they have exercised due diligence before selling it to the public.

It is odd that a country may go to war on a standard of diligence lower than that required to float a company.

Bush lied about torture. He didn’t lie about the intelligence on Saddam’s WMDs. He just failed to do due diligence.

Malkin Award Nominee

"An Obama presidency would signal the final salvo by the Left in the culture wars. Obama’s advance troops have already taken over our college campuses, have bound and gagged our conservative professors, have ravished our virgins, have pillaged our stores of wisdom, and have ensconced themselves in the thrones of power in deans’, presidents’ and department heads’ offices," – Mary Grabar, Townhall.com.

The need to force Obama into the culture wars is very, very deep. And very, very boring. Hilzoy is tracking the latest "conservative" hysterics here.

Dissent Of The Day

A reader writes:

For careful readers of your blog there can be no doubt that you are endorsing Obama for president. The first time I suspected Obama had closed the deal with you is when he gave his dreadful, but honest, explanation as to why he would raise the capital gains tax. Said explanation included something about hedge fund managers and fairness. Here it is:

"Well, Charlie, what I’ve said is that I would look at raising the capital gains tax for purposes of fairness. We saw an article today which showed that the top 50 hedge fund managers made $29 billion last year — $29 billion for 50 individuals. And part of what has happened is that those who are able to work the stock market and amass huge fortunes on capital gains are paying a lower tax rate than their secretaries. That’s not fair."

Never mind whether it would be good or bad for the economy at large. No, instead the president should decide what is "fair" and legislate accordingly. What part of that do you find conservative? To me that sounds like typical leftist blather designed to get folks angry enough to vote for the guy who will stick it to hedge-fund managers and oil executives (aka straw men). You mentioned it when you live-blogged and then moved right on. Why? That’s the sort of thing that deserves a serious grilling.

What action has Obama taken that could possibly anger anyone (other than the Clintons) in his own party? I cannot come up with anything Andrew. What is new about the type of politics that has him voting the party line on anything of significance? NARAL gives him a 100%. How is that different? Saying taxes need to be raised because to not do so would be unfair is not in any way new coming from someone with a D next to their name. How about the farm bill? Was he on the controversial side or that? Hell, he even voted against confirming John Roberts. That my friend is not exactly a profile in courage.

If you have not yet decided to support Obama over McCain, you might consider beginning to explore the cons of Obama, because an increasing number of your posts tell us why Obama is transcendent and wonderful, and the rest hint at why McCain pales in comparison. Again, if you have already decided to endorse Obama, there is nothing wrong with that. But if you claim that you have not yet made that decision, and this continues, your blog will become too much like Hewitt’s was before Romney conceded. I know that you, and those who read your blog, do not want that to be the case.

So my recommendation that is worth less than two cents is this – endorse Obama outright, or give McCain some props for being one of the few bright spots on the right side of the aisle the last 8 years, the side that was supposed to represent conservatism.

I think I’ve given McCain lots of chops, and gave him a near-endorsement last December. The trouble is: McCain has been admirable in many ways, but he has not been a spokesman for the kind of conservatism I find congenial. He loves the idea of government as a salvific force, of public service as superior to private wealth-creation, of the president as national scold or corrective. And he would simply by virtue of being a Republican leader after the last eight years, enable some of the forces I find so repellent in modern Republicanism.

As for Obama, I’m not going to withhold criticism of his more collectivist impulses. Yes, that aside about taxation sent my blood-pressure skyward. There’s plenty to disagree with him about, and I’m going to watch how he approaches Iraq very carefully over the next few months. But I’m not going to decide whom to support until I have to. By all means, keep me on my toes, but I plan on running a blog that airs as much of the debate between the two candidates as fairly as I can, and call each issue as I see it.

And there’s always Bob Barr …