Dissent Of The Day

A reader writes:

We know from Bob Woodward’s reporting that Bush was himself shocked at the paucity of evidence, but chose to characterize manifestly flawed intelligence as strong. Whether that is lying is an ontological question that requires no absolute answer. If Bush was merely mistaken, he has paid next to nothing for an enormous error; amazingly, Americans re-elected him long after his Iraq adventure went south. If he was knowingly deceptive, the Press and official Washington have let him get away with monstrous war crimes. In any case, there is a dearth of outrage. The charge of lying is one way of indicating that Bush has not been held to account in a manner proportionate to the consequences of his failed leadership.

I don’t think there has been a dearth of outrage on this blog at the incompetence and misjudgment and parsing of the truth that has characterized the Bush administration. And my endorsing of Kerry in 2004 – despite serious, deep disagreements with him – was a function of my own attempt to hold Bush responsible.

I just don’t believe that the decision to go to war was a function of conscious, pre-meditated deceit. It was close to the line of deceit, and may have gone over in the mind of Dick Cheney, but it was not an entirely trumped-up fear about Saddam. It was a reckless overstatement and a wilfully blind refusal to see grays in among the blacks and whites. In the traumatized aftermath of 9/11, I was as guilty of that as anyone, but although the administration should have known better – and had more access to the intelligence than I did – I still don’t believe they lied outright in the way some now claim.

My own outrage has always been more acutely directed at the torture policy (and lies about it) and the pig-headed refusal to change course in the Iraq occupation until it was almost too late.

The Nuclearization Of Asia

Not bombs – energy:

Japan: Japan has 55 units in operation, 2 under construction, 11 planned, also 17 research reactors. Japan generates 29% of its electricity from nuclear power. By 2015, nuclear contribution is expected to increase, especially if emission targets under the Kyoto Protocol are met. Longer term plans are to double nuclear capacity (to 90 GWe) and nuclear share by 2050…

China: 10 units in operation, 5 under construction, 13 planned, 50 proposed; also 13 research reactors. is moving ahead rapidly in building new nuclear power plants, many of them conspicuously on time and on budget.

I’m with McCain on this one: any energy plan that does not have a major nuclear component is not carbon-serious.

Keeping Pints Honest

A blogger on a mission:

Jeff Alworth, a Portland, Ore., beer blogger, university researcher and a founder of the Honest Pint Project, has been testing suspected short-pouring bars, in some cases measuring his beer-glass capacity by the men’s room sink. His group collected more than 400 names in two weeks for an online petition urging state regulators to enforce a 16-ounce rule. And at one point, he was posting the names of bars that didn’t measure up on his Web site. But in response to complaints, he now has taken to listing the names of establishments serving full pints in bigger glasses.

Beer blogger?

A Liberal Conservatives Can Live With?

Steve Chapman on Barack Obama:

As liberals go, however, opponents of Big Government could do worse. On economic matters, like the mortgage crisis, he’s more respectful of property rights and free markets than, say, Clinton. His health-care plan rankles many liberals because it doesn’t force everyone to buy insurance.

While Obama has criticized various free-trade agreements, he’s also written that in today’s world, "it’s hard to even imagine, much less enforce, an effective regime of protectionism."

The Race Obsessives

Ta-Nehisi Coates on the range of opinion within the black community:

One of the most poisonous ideas to emerge out of the cultural wars of the 80s and 90s was this portrait of black America as a hotbed of radical leftists who spend their days berating Jews, demanding reparations, and thinking of new and exciting ways to make white folks feel guilty. I think that image has come to dominate because so many public intellectuals working in the arena of race began to confuse the debates occurring in the sociology departments of elite campuses and in the salons of the Upper West Side, with the debates that rank and file black folks have amongst themselves. No disrespect, but New York City and the Ivy Leagues may be the most distortive influences on the picture of black life, short of BET.