“More Universalist Than American”

A reader notes:

That’s an Obama theme worth exploring.   America was in fact always intended as a universalistic project–the implementation of principles of universal validity, not the formation of a new quasi-ethnic identity.   Our founders were men of the Enlightenment, which is perhaps more than anything the project of discovering and applying universal principles and using these to replace superstition, prejudice and sentiment, of which ethno-centrism is a noteworthy example.   

Perhaps our  greatest figure was Emerson, who  praised the Represenative Man over the Great Man. If Obama is a universailist figure,  he is not a departure for this country, but a return to its best principles.

The Hot And Cool Revolution

Obamaemmanueldunandafpgetty

My Sunday Times column this week is an extended essay on the scale and potential of the first black president of the United States. Money quote:

Then there is the unknowable factor of Obama’s star power. No presidential candidate in modern times has drawn 75,000 people out for a primary election rally, as he did in Portland last month. No one has inspired the dozens of songs, anthems, YouTube videos and poster art that this figure has.

Obama has something that Reagan and John F Kennedy had: a charisma that seems to fit the presidency. And he is obviously more Kennedy than Reagan, with youth on his side. Give the American presidency the allure of youth and testos-terone and it is an intoxicating mass media phenomenon. His personality could do for it what Kennedy did, what John Paul II did for the institution of the papacy in his first years and what Diana did for the institution of the monarchy: it’s a fusion of op-cultural mass appeal with highly authoritative institutions.

The theatre of this is unmissable.

What was previously a theory – a fantasy of a redeemed, rebranded America – gains real traction now that Obama is the actual nominee. As the moment approaches when he could be president, that power will only intensify. It will require careful management if it is not to degenerate into cultism and messianism. But what Obama has is what Kennedy had and Diana famously didn’t: a cool and measured interior. What makes the phenomenon sustainable is this odd mix of hot and cool, of intense emotional energy around this man, centred on a very calm and collected, even aloof, individual.

(Photo: Emmanuel Dunand/AFP/Getty.)

When We Leave

John McCain hasn’t always defended staying in an invaded and occupied country for as long as it takes to construct a stable "normal" country. Of course, the consequences of leaving Iraq precipitously are much greater than Haiti or Somalia. So you can see the contrast between the 1990s and 2008 as one of context. Nonetheless, the principle of just leaving a place – and Congress’ right to do so over the wishes of the president – is not one unknown to McCain.

The Obama Effect

A perspective from today’s Times Of India:

Here’s a trivial observation that suggests why Obama, because of his eclectic and unusual upbringing, may be different: He’s the only American leader who has been heard to pronounce Gandhi and Pakistan correctly — just like it’s pronounced in the subcontinent (Gaan-dhi, not Gain-dee; Paak-isthaan, not Pack-is-tan). In other conversations, Obama has also referred to Indian success in technology fields, and drawn comparisons between his father (who came to the US "without money, but with a student visa and a determination to succeed") and the experiences of Indian immigrants.

Such empathy and "connection" to immigrants from the subcontinent is only one part of Obama’s plural multi-ethnic background and wide-ranging eclectic education (American, African, even part-Asian) that makes him arguably the most unusual and exciting presidential candidate in US history — more universalist than American.

The Home We Leave

Manzi on the home town he left but wants to see remain:

I was raised there in the house that my grandfather built. Not “built” as in “hired people to build it to his specifications”, but built as in got carpenter’s tools, nails and wood, and hammered it together with his own hands. When I was a child, a major hurricane hit the New Jersey coast. We were used to hurricanes in late summer (June, too soon; July, keep an eye; August the worst; September, remember; October, it’s over). The power would always go out, and we would ride it out together in the living room with candles and flashlights. It was kind of fun, almost like an indoor campout. This storm started that way, but got much, much worse than normal. A hurricane can look kind of cartoonish on TV when you see an anchorman being blown around by the wind in its early stages, but if it’s a bad one, it can be pretty serious business near the water. This one got horrifying.

Trees were uprooted by the wind. Cars flipped over. A brick wall that had stood for decades collapsed on the beachfront. The eeriest part was when the eye of the storm passed over us, and we looked out into the bizarre moonlit stillness, knowing what was going to start again in a few minutes. I glanced up, frightened, at my father. He smiled and told me not to worry, that the house was built solid. Which, it turns out, it was.

This house sits on a street that changes slowly. When I would come back home as an adult, the houses around us still had the same families in them as on the day I was born. Our cousins lived directly across the street, but eventually sold their house to one of my grammar school classmates. When I was in my thirties, we finally took up the wall-to-wall carpeting that my parents had put down because they had a houseful of kids. Underneath it, in the living room where we had ridden out that storm, was a simple, beautiful, geometrically-patterned hardwood floor.

Couch Potato Cultivation

Nige considers the Olympic games:

If ever there was a festival of couch potato cultivation, it’s the Olympics. It only exists, in its grotesquely bloated modern form, because of the huge worldwide TV audience – and many of the sports represented only exist, to the outside world, as a once-every-four-years TV spectacle. What sort of crowd does the average weightlifting event attract? Where, indeed, would one find such a thing? Yet, come the Olympics, weightlifting’s up there with the rest, suddenly being gawped at by millions of couch potatoes. Because the Olympics is fundamentally a TV event, it makes very little sense to build special venues for most of the events. That only leaves a legacy of expensive white elephants – the one sure Olympic legacy we can realistically look forward to. The sponsors and the TV companies should knock up temporary structures – sets, as it were – and take them down when it’s all over. As it is, the likeliest ‘legacy’ of the London Olympics will be not only rotting, redundant venues (this is already the case post-Athens) but also decades of debt – remember Montreal…

God And Politics

John Gray reviews Atheism and Its Scientific Pretensions by David Berlinski:

The truth of the matter is that religion and science are not competitors, but fundamentally different responses to the human situation. Religion begins where science leaves off. Theories of how humanity or the universe came about are strictly beside the point. Claiming to have a better explanation of the natural world than orthodox science – as creationists do – does nothing to advance the cause of faith.

Religion expresses the human need for meaning, not a demand for explanation. For those who have it, faith entails understanding the limits of the human mind and an acceptance of mystery. Even if all the problems of science are some day solved, humans will still be searching for purpose in their lives, and for that reason alone they will need religion.

Joe Windish comments.

On Heaven

A passage from James Wood’s review of Bart D. Ehrman’s God’s Problem: How the Bible Fails to Answer Our Most Important Question—Why We Suffer:

Heaven, one of the tenderest verses in the Bible has it, is where God will wipe away all tears from our faces. In her novel “Gilead,” Marilynne Robinson adds, in a line just as tender, if a little sterner, “It takes nothing from the loveliness of the verse to say that is exactly what will be required.” Robinson, herself a devout Protestant, means that the immense surge of human suffering in the world will need, and deserves, a great deal of heavenly love and repair; it is as close as her novel comes to righteous complaint. But one could also say, more skeptically, that Christianity needs the concept of Heaven simply to make sense of all the world’s suffering—that, theologically speaking, Heaven is “exactly what will be required.” In the end, Heaven, it seems, is the only tenable response to the problem of evil. It is where God’s mysterious plan will be revealed; it is where the poor and the downtrodden, the sick and the tortured, will be healed; it is where everything that we went through on earth will suddenly seem “worth it.” […]

But Heaven is also a problem for theodicists who take the freedom to choose between good and evil as paramount. For Heaven must be a place where either our freedom to sin has been abolished or we have been so transfigured that we no longer want to sin: in Heaven, our will miraculously coincides with God’s will. And here the free-will defense unravels, and is unravelled by the very idea of Heaven. If Heaven obviates the great human freedom to sin, why was it ever such a momentous ideal on earth, “worth” all that pain and suffering?

The difficulty can be recast in terms of the continuity of the self. If we will be so differently constituted in Heaven as to be strangers to sin, then no meaningful connection will exist between the person who suffers here and the exalted soul who will enjoy the great system of rewards and promises and tears wiped from faces: our faces there will not be the faces we have here. And, if there were to be real continuity between our earthly selves and our heavenly ones, then Heaven might dangerously begin to resemble earth.

Ross comments here. (Hat tip: Matthew Boudway)