The Creepiness Of The Gitmo Propagandists

There was a particularly nauseating piece in the Wall Street Journal yesterday. It’s a defense of Gitmo from … the commander of Gitmo for the last year. It contains this priceless nugget:

Joint Task Force doctors have performed more than 370 surgeries, including restorative eye procedures, and a recent back surgery that restored movement and avoided possible paralysis for a detainee. Shortly after, that detainee sent me a note saying "Thank you, I have been wrong about Americans."

That back surgery? The prisoner in question, Abdul Zahir, detainee number 75, who is represented by Professor Kermit Roosevelt and a team of law students at Penn Law School, required surgery because an IRF team cuffed his wrists to his ankles and jumped on his back after immobilizing him.

Goldfarb, McCain and Torture

Reihan defends Goldfarb. I don’t think anyone is saying that McCain does not have the right to hire whomever he wants to. Or that Goldfarb, whom I do not know, has skills in communication. But it is surely relevant that McCain has hired someone who mocks tortured prisoners and a believer that the president as commander-in-chief has "near-dictatorial" powers in national security. Put torture and near-dictatorship together and the mix is not just about "flame-throwing."

California’s Moment

Buried in the rush of election news yesterday was the California court’s refusal to stay the civil marriages for gay couples that will start on June 17 and continue throughout the year. This strikes me as a critical decision because it reframes the debate in California. If voters are asked to decide on the abstract question of marriage equality, they respond differently than if they are asked to decide about civil marriages already in existence. Many voters simply do not want to think about this question and resent those who bring it up. If you ask Californians: "Do you favor the right of gay couples to marry?" they will divide pretty evenly. If you ask, "Do you want to undo all these couples’ marriages?" they will tend to answer no.

And what’s striking is how little furore the decision has actually provoked, and how much more restrained the backlash seems to be in 2008 than it was in 2004. A lot is due to greater familiarity with same-sex married couples, in Massachusetts and Canada. And a lot is due to the fact that we have had these marriages for years now and the world for straight people seems unchanged. Check out this McCain response to Jamie Kirchick yesterday:

I’ve always supported the unique status of marriage of man and woman. I supported a ballot initiative in Arizona, and voted for Defense of Marriage Act. But people of the states should make that decision. We do not have to recognize the decisions of other states.

I agree with it – haven’t read it, but I agree with it – but that’s a decision that the people of California will make.

It is becoming a non-issue. Which means: we win.

 

Quote For The Day

"The primaries showed that the U.S. is actually the nation we had believed it to be, a place that is open-minded enough to have a woman or an African American as its president," – Minoru Morita, a Tokyo political analyst.

The excitement the Democratic race has provoked abroad and the genuine enthusiasm the Obama candidacy generates in the developing world can only be a good sign for restoring some of the soft power squandered by the Bush administration. That was my hope last fall. So far, so good.

Misunderstanding Obama And TUCC

Steve Waldman has a terrific piece in a WSJ blog. He understands that part of what appealed to Obama about Trinity was precisely its occasional lapses into separatism and black nationalism. Why? Because Obama knew those elements were part of the urban black experience and also understood the need to include them in a dialogue in order to overcome them. From "Dreams From My Father":

“A steady attack on the white race, the constant recitation of black people’s brutal experience in this country, served as the ballast that could prevent the ideas of personal and communal responsibility from tipping into an ocean of despair…..It contradicted the morality my mother had taught me, a morality of subtle distinctions – between individuals of goodwill and those who wished me ill.”

Balancing his rejection and understanding of these themes is the nuance Obama tried to explain. Some won’t listen. More, I predict, will.

The End

Ross does a Clinton post-mortem:

Clintonism represented a distinctively Boomer strain of politics, but Clinton-hatred did as well. For Boomer conservatives, it was a reaction to the Clinton personae, his and hers — to the way Bill and Hillary embodied, in so many respects, everything that fortysomething right-wingers despised about their own peer group — joined to an anger at the First Couple’s facility for winning political battles (if not the war) in an era that was supposed to belong to Reagan’s heirs. For Boomer liberals, it was a mixture of self-loathing, sibling resentment, and the inevitable disappointment at the Clintons’ failure to live up to the idols of their youth, the brothers Kennedy … and then, more unforgivably, their failure to get out of the way when a New Kennedy came along.