Warring Atheists

Alain de Botton proposes a secular religion:

…a secular religion would use all the tools of art in order to create an effective kind of propaganda in the name of kindness and virtue. Rather than seeing art as a tool that can shock and surprise us (the two great emotions promoted by most contemporary works), a secular religion would return to an earlier view that art should improve us. It should be a form of propaganda for a better, nobler life.

Norm Geras is hostile to the idea. Botton’s remarks echo those of Wassily Kandinsky. A snippet from his book Concerning The Spiritual In Art, originally published in 1914:

If we begin at once to break the bonds which bind us to nature, and devote ourselves purely to combination of pure colour and abstract form, we shall produce works which are mere decoration, which are suited to neckties or carpets. Beauty of Form and Colour is no sufficient aim by itself, despite the assertions of pure aesthetes or even of naturalists, who are obsessed with the idea of "beauty." It is because of the elementary stage reached by our painting that we are so little able to grasp the inner harmony of true colour and form composition. The nerve vibrations are there, certainly, but they get no further than the nerves, because the corresponding vibrations of the spirit which they call forth are too weak. When we remember, however, that spiritual experience is quickening, that positive science, the firmest basis of human thought, is tottering, that dissolution of matter is imminent, we have reason to hope that the hour of pure composition is not far away.

Marriage Going Nuclear?

Chris Crain:

The battle over same-sex marriage is about to go nuclear. Not because it may impact this year’s presidential race, as some have worried. But because the skirmishes will now multiply into a multi-front struggle that will determine whether access to civil marriage for the rest of us comes sooner or much, much later…In the other 48 states, gay newlyweds returning from California will over time be raising issues that will challenge not just the state constitutionality of marriage bans but their federal constitutionality as well, along with the holy grail: the constitutionality of the federal Defense of Marriage Act.

Count me unconvinced. There is a very clear consensus now in favor of federalism working its magic. Even without DOMA, the states’ autonomy in this area has very clear precedents. And the toxic federal government interpretation of DOMA – the Clinton clauses that deny gay couples any federal recognition whatsoever – may well be repealed in the next Congress anyway.

Not Talking To Terrorists

Michael Walzer has a concise defense of always talking to enemy governments, but drawing the line at terror organizations. With this caveat:

We make an exception when the gang is holding hostages–its members may not care about innocent lives, but we do. In such a case, the goal is to save the hostages and then, if we can, capture or kill the gang members. There is no ongoing business to be done.

That is the standard doctrine, and yet Israel, a strong exponent of this doctrine, is not only negotiating with Syria but also with Hamas (through the mediation of Egypt). This approach seems to be the right one, not only because Hamas is holding an Israeli soldier, but also because it isn’t just a terrorist organization—though it is that—but also the government of the Gaza strip. It is a kind of regime standing in for a kind of country. The significance of those two words, “kind of,” is reflected in the fact that the negotiations with Hamas are also negotiations with the Egyptian mediator (which could, but so far hasn’t, cut off the movement of weapons into Gaza).

What Clinton Faces

Clintonstanhondaafpgetty

An empathetic account of what she’s now going through:

"I knew in my bones I was going to lose. Each morning from that point forward I awoke with a vague sense of dread, realizing that I would have to spend the day smiling and shaking hands and pretending that everything was going according to plan… I am not suggesting that politicians are unique in suffering such disappointments. It’s that unlike most people, who have the luxury of licking their wounds in private, the politician’s loss is on public display. There’s the cheerful concession speech you have to make to a half-empty ballroom, the brave face you put on as you comfort staff and supporters, the thank-you calls to those who helped, and the awkward requests for further help in retiring the debt.

You perform these tasks as best you can, and yet no matter how hard you tell yourself differently — no matter how convincingly you attribute the loss to bad timing or bad luck or lack of money — it’s impossible not to feel at some level as if you have been personally repudiated by the entire community, and that everywhere you go that word "loser" is flashing through people’s minds. They’re the sorts of feelings that most people haven’t experienced since high school, when some girl you’d been pining over dismissed you with a joke in front of her friends, or you missed a pair of free throws with the big game on the line — the kinds of feelings that most adults wisely organize their lives to avoid."

Guess who?

(Photo: Stan Honda/AFP/Getty.)