Felix Salmon ponders why people spring for expensive wine but stick with cheap food.
Category: The Dish
Bad Timing
Jim Tankersley on the ironies of the 2008 Democratic calendar. If the Clintons decide to wage a guerrilla war against Obama for the next three months – overtly or covertly – the late convention could be the cruelest irony of all.
The Sky Is Falling?
A reader writes:
I’m a professional astronomer, and I actually study near-Earth asteroids (NEAs) for a living. I’m only too happy to question NASA’s priorities and whether more funding should go to investigating the impact hazard, but in the interest of fairness and clarity, I’d like to make a few (hopefully short) points with respect to Easterbrook’s video.
1) There have indeed been an explosion of NEAs discoveries in the past decade or two. But this has largely been by design; Congress charged NASA with finding at least 90% of all asteroids with diameters of 1 km or larger by the end of 2008, and with that new focus the rate of discoveries has gone up. In addition to finding the 1 km asteroids, smaller ones (in some cases small enough to fit in your living room) have also been found. But in my opinion, this is the best way to leverage our resources: a small increment of money will allow a thorough enough search of the neighborhood that we’ll be able to characterize what’s out there and determine where we need to focus next.
2) Another part of the problem is that there is no real consensus for what the threshold of risk is at which we would act. If we decide an asteroid with a 1% chance of an impact is too dangerous to leave alone, then 99 times out of 100 we will have acted in vain. And unfortunately, our data is rarely precise enough (simply because of the distances and sizes of the objects) that by the time we have even determined if there is a 50% likelihood of impact, it may be way too late.
3) Finally, the legal ramifications are really murky. The United States could undertake an asteroid deflection, and there are at least a few other countries that could also do it if they put their mind to it. But it would require a level of spacecraft reliability that we just don’t have. What happens if in an attempt to avert an impact into Europe, NASA accidentally nudges it into Bangladesh? What if a smaller impactor would hit the Indian ocean and destroy some smaller island nations, but there was ample time to evacuate everybody? What if nuclear weapons were required for deflection (as indeed they might, since the gravity tractor idea is ill-suited for some cases)? Now, what if instead of us deciding those questions for instruction to NASA, the Russians or Chinese decided to take the lead?
I think it’s good that this debate is happening. But I think I can assure you that in terms of immediate threats to your health, you should focus instead on making sure you exercise and eat lots of fiber.
How To Deal With Clinton Now
Stan and Kyle’s approach to Cartman (the closest cartoon equivalent to Hillary Clinton) is worth considering:
The Unvetted One II
Ross wonders why Todd Purdum’s article on Bill Clinton is only coming out now:
…if you’d asked me nine months ago to list the major roadblocks to Hillary’s near-inevitable nomination, I would have put her husband’s possible tomcatting right up there with her Iraq War vote. In the event, the Big He did end up having an impact on the race, but it was public gaffes that mattered, not his private vices. I’m not sure what to make of the lack of coverage on this front: It could suggest that there’s vastly more smoke than fire where Clinton’s post-Presidential priapism is concerned; it could suggest that Clinton’s handlers are really, really good at putting out the fires in question (though it doesn’t sound that way from Purdum’s piece); or it could suggest a conspiracy of silence on the part of the media, based on a fear of pulling the trigger on stories that could get them accused of gossip-mongering or invading the Clintons’ privacy.
The latter, Ross, the latter.
Take Your Pick
972 different ways to count the popular vote.
Post-Post-Modern Conservatism
A flattering post over at The Politics Of Scrabble:
While Sullivan reaches into the past of conservative thought to remind the listener of the roots of the tradition, he also takes the ideas of those founding thinkers and brushes them up against the complexities of a post-modern world. Sullivan updates the thoughts of this ideology to acknowledge that life is infinitely more complex than any of our models and conceptions will ever been capable of capturing, a truly post-modern notion. And yet, Sullivan suggests that there is a way forward that avoids both paralysis and disregarding or over-simplifying these complexities, which he takes to reside in a modernization of classic conservative principles.
Such a conservatism would be nuanced, dangerously sharp, overwhelmingly thoughtful, and potentially very powerful. This is the ideological rebirth upon which I have been musing of late. The question that remains is whether Sullivan’s is a lone voice in the wilderness, or the prescient clarion call of a coming titanic shift.
I’m fine with the wilderness. But I do believe that conservatism has to come to terms with modernity more comprehensively than it seems to have in the US right now. In fact, there are many powerful elements within it that seem rooted in a terror and loathing of modernity. My attempt to explain my thesis at Cato is in two Youtubes here and here.
Expensive Medieval Churches
Tyler Cowen flags this post by Bryan Caplan:
Religious architecture and art were to medieval feudalism what advertising and commercialism are to modern capitalism: A rather effective way to build support for the status quo using aesthetics instead of argument. My claim, in short, is that Notre Dame played the same role during the Middle Ages that fashion magazines play today. Notre Dame was not an argument for feudalism, and Elle is not an argument for capitalism. But both are powerful ways to make regular people buy into the system.
It Could Happen
A screenwriter imagines a showdown in Denver.
Remembering The Gay Diaspora
"There is a gaping hole in the Times’ coverage of the same-sex marriage issue: Any state recognition of same-sex couples applies only to couples who are both U.S. citizens.
Heterosexual citizens have the right to marry foreign partners and bring them legally into the country with the right to live and work and even seek citizenship. Homosexual citizens don’t have that right; they must either choose another citizen as a partner or leave the country in order to be with their foreign partners. I know this issue intimately because both my children have foreign partners. My heterosexual daughter was able to marry and give her foreign partner the right to live here. My homosexual son can’t do that, and his partner isn’t even allowed to enter the U.S., so he has no choice but to live in his partner’s country. The people who claim to be protecting families are not doing anything to protect mine. Instead, they’ve torn it apart. I wish the Times would cover that aspect of the gay marriage issue because there are thousands of American families affected by it," – a mother of a gay son, commenting on the story on Governor David Paterson’s decision to treat gay citizens married in other states no differently than straight ones.