Faith and Evolution

A reader writes:

In contrast to James Dow and other adaptationists like him, my late professor at Harvard, Stephen Jay Gould, argued for a non-adaptationist origin for religious thought: our brains got big for lots of reasons having nothing to do with religion, and big brains think big thoughts about death, meaning, and the afterlife. I find Gould’s "explanation" far more satisfying than James Dow’s, mostly because it’s so simple. I would ask Dow why it is so extraordinary or unlikely that we humans simply want to know how we are here and whether we have a purpose. Why is it so odd to argue that religion is simply a natural byproduct of consciousness?

But it hardly matters what Dow’s software purports to demonstrate. He starts with assumptions that he sets out to "prove": that there is a genetic predisposition to pass on unverifiable information or that religion is socially beneficial. What he doesn’t do — something he must do for this be of any real scientific merit — is determine if his assumptions do better than other assumptions, i.e., could his software rule out the possibility that religion is successful simply because we are smart and curious, likely to believe what others say because we trust them for good reason, and likely to want to believe that we won’t die when we die?

To answer your question, no, it isn’t helpful at all.

A Poem For Sunday

Fossils by J. T. Barbarese

When he was young he used to spend the whole summer
in the abandoned slag heaps around the old mines
outside the city of Scranton. It would take him hours
to pick through the shale stacks, the sweat writing lines
in the dust on his face, and the old ball peen hammer
slung from his belt pinching his belly button.
Some days there was nothing to read but the signatures
of ice and erosion and tools. Then he’d find one,
a slate unnaturally filigreed with the fright masks
of a trilobite, ferns, the inferior commissures
of ancient clams. He would wrap them in moist newspaper
and carry them carefully home. Once his teacher asked
him to talk to the class about fossils.
          Satan plants them to trick us,
he said. When I get home I smash them to pieces.

Home News

The Dish had a record month in May, nudging out January for a new high. And on Technorati’s list of authoritative blogs (i.e. most linked), we’re now in the top 40. By my count, only four political blogs outrank us – and all four – Huff, Kos, ThinkProgress, and TreeHugger – have multiple posters. Many thanks to you, Patrick, Chris and the now-retiring bunch of interns.

The Clinton Rump

Wardmanjoshuarobertsgetty

A reader nails it:

After watching the RBC meeting come to a close, I can’t help thinking that Hillary’s slowly withering support has been whittled down to two main camps. From the nutty Clintonites in the crowd shouting "Denver! Denver!" to the disingenuous moral posturing of Harold Ickes, she’s left with what she deserves:

Hicks and Hacks.

(Photo: Joshua Roberts/Getty.)

New Math, Old Reality

Yesterday’s results don’t change much:

Obama is now 62.5 delegates away from clinching the nomination with a new magic number 2,118. This is when the nine (cut to 4.5) Edwards pledged delegates (out of 13) in Florida, who have pledged to vote for Obama, are factored in. Without them, Obama would be 67 away.

Clinton, on the other hand, would need 238 delegates.

One senses an era ending.