Dan Savage has some fun with a Utah TV station’s online poll.
Category: The Dish
“Prodded Animals”
David Runciman on American polling:
…in an election like this one, the polls aren’t there to tell the real story; they are there to support the various different stories that the commentators want to tell. The market is not for the hard truth, because the hard truth this time round is that most people are voting with the predictability of prodded animals. What the news organisations and blogs and roving pundits want are polls that suggest the voters are thinking hard about this election, arguing about it, making up their minds, talking it through, because that’s what all the commentators like to think they are doing themselves. This endless raft of educated opinion needs to be kept afloat on some data indicating that it matters what informed people say about politics, because it helps the voters to decide which way to jump. If you keep the polling sample sizes small enough, you can create the impression of a public willing to be moved by what other people are saying. That’s why the comment industry pays for this rubbish.
He’s a little excessive, I think. But close analysis of polls at this stage of the race strike me as ridiculously premature. Until the Clintons leave the stage, we have no inkling of how an Obama-McCain race will feel, how the contrast will affect allegiances, how policy – especially with the complex and shifting landscape of Iraq – will impact the decision. I expect Obama to get a big bump from finally resolving the nomination, but this will fade as well. In late September, we’ll get the first real feel from polling about the race. Congressional races are, of course, different. And extremely grim for the decadent Republicans.
Gin, TV And The Web
This is one of those essays so brilliant and fun and provocative it stays with you for a while. It’s by Clay Shirky and it’s about social surplus – or how human beings manage modernity. It’s hard to summarize, so here’s a taste:
If I had to pick the critical technology for the 20th century, the bit of social lubricant without which the wheels would’ve come off the whole enterprise, I’d say it was the sitcom. Starting with the Second World War a whole series of things happened–rising GDP per capita, rising educational attainment, rising life expectancy and, critically, a rising number of people who were working five-day work weeks. For the first time, society forced onto an enormous number of its citizens the requirement to manage something they had never had to manage before–free time.
And what did we do with that free time? Well, mostly we spent it watching TV.
We did that for decades. We watched I Love Lucy.
We watched Gilligan’s Island. We watch Malcolm in the Middle. We watch Desperate Housewives. Desperate Housewives essentially functioned as a kind of cognitive heat sink, dissipating thinking that might otherwise have built up and caused society to overheat.
And it’s only now, as we’re waking up from that collective bender, that we’re starting to see the cognitive surplus as an asset rather than as a crisis.
Hence this blog. And everything else that is exploding online. It may be more constructive than some suppose.
The O’Reilly Factor
A reader writes:
The video you posted showing Bill O’Reilly grilling the anti-gay marriage lawyer blew me away. That was a "holy shit" moment for me. What we usually see is Bill O’Reilly invite people on to his show who will support his own conclusions, and when they cannot back up their own arguments (as their arguments are often irrational), Bill usually fills in the gaps for them with his own opinions while he guests nod their heads thankfully. That’s not what we just saw.
We just saw Bill O’Reilly take someone to task for not being able to elaborate on their own opinions, and not being able to explain why what they think isn’t bigoted.
Bill O’Reilly’s opinions haven’t changed, he made that clear in the clip. But this is not indicative of his style – is it possible he feels pressure to take an honest look at an issue for once? Perhaps a pressure from home? A child or relative taking him to task? Perhaps a producer? Is public opinion of gay rights really making this much progress this quickly?
Once you accept that gay people are gay in the way that straight people are straight, and once you remove purely religious arguments from a secular debate, the case against marriage equality simply collapses. One reason I have been so eager to have this debate on rational grounds is that, if reason is your guide, the pro-gay side wins overwhelmingly. What’s left is a base-line argument for caution. But as gay marriage takes root, you see it has nothing but good effects on society as a whole. Soon, this will be over. Not yet. But sooner than some now believe.
South Park’s YouTube Classic – Mashed Up
If you missed South Park’s classic recent scene featuring a bunch of YouTube characters, this mash-up version is all of that and much more. It splices actual footage from YouTube classics with South Park animation. Made me appreciate both even more:
Obama = Carter II?
A reader writes:
"My major worry about Obama is the ghost of Jimmy Carter. Will Obama be too reflexively diplomatic?"
(1) Obama has famously said his success in Chicago politics shows he’s clear-eyed about power.
(2) At the same time, one of Obama’s strengths is that he can bring adversaries together where most negotiators cannot. Illinois law on videotaping police interrogations, etc. And one of McCain’s weaknesses is his tendency to piss off even his allies. If you had to bet on someone to succeed in delicate negotiations, would you bet on Obama or McCain? Exactly. Now, think about the international cooperation we need to salvage some shred of success in Iraq and Afghanistan. Think about the WTO. Think about international carbon trading. Think about myriad other foreign-relations matters in which the Bush administration has destroyed our credibility. Who’s more likely to get back our credibility, and secure the cooperation we need? Exactly.
(3) Obama’s campaign has so far been a masterful blend of hardheaded analysis and unmatched persuasion.
(4) What’s the single undeniable shining success in the Middle East in the last four decades? The Camp David accords between Israel and Egypt.
Six Or Half A Dozen
Poblano reviews the weird Michigan and Florida math on whether there will be half the number of delegates seated or whether each delegate will be counted as a half-delegate. Chuck Todd et al. elaborate here. No: I’m not making this up. The efforts to make the Clintons feel better about losing the nomination get abstruse after a while.
One small but obvious point: the Republicans have already penalized Michigan and Florida by halving their delegate count in St Paul. I don’t see any Republicans whining that this means voters will feel terribly affronted in both states this November. And if there are no penalties for moving primaries up in time, won’t there be mayhem in the 2012 cycle? I know the Clintons only care about their short-term interest, but one wonders if the Dems as a whole still want to be bossed around by the power-couple from hell.
Obama and Clinton: Butch and Fem?
A reader writes:
I’m gay and intensely dislike the Clintons. I have found, however, that among a sampling of my friends, masculine gays voted for either Obama or Paul with one exception. My more effeminate friends voted for Clinton citing their love of "strong women".
I think it’s identity politics at play within the gay community. Some gay men see themselves as victims. They march in pride parades to the beat of "I Will Survive" – Hillary’s current campaign theme – fighting against perceived slights with all the tenacity they can bring to bear. Other gay men see their homosexuality as one small part of who they are and, while not hiding it or feeling any shame, simply carry on with their lives without wallowing in victimhood.That is the difference as I see it. Some gay men see Alice, Maude, Rhoda, Joan Jett, Cyndi Lauper as exemplars of strength.
They watch Sex in the City and the Golden Girls and see their struggles reflected in that of women. I empathize with women, but I never identify my situation with a woman’s and these gays see Hillary’s struggle as their own. They ignore my points about Don’t ask Don’t Tell, DOMA, and how Hillary Clinton can barely bring herself to use the word "gay" in public. None of it has any effect. She’s a diva. She’s drama. She’s Regina in Mean Girls and Barack is Lindsey Lohan and some gay men will always follow the Queen Bee.
McCain, Obama, Iran
David Brooks tries to spot the difference between the way the two candidates would tackle the problem. It’s hard. And the slow management of a policy that knows no final resolution is indeed a pragmatic enterprise. But I wonder if it will be that predictable. Will the apparent waning of Sunni Jihadism embolden or quiet the Shia revolutionaries in Tehran? Is there someone in that regime we do not appreciate yet who will alter Persia’s future? Is a nuclear Iran containable the way every other nuclear state has proven to be? Could a stabler, less autocratic, more devolved Iraq tilt the balance within Iran? These are all unknowables.
What we have to try to figure out – and it’s not a judgment susceptible to advance knowledge – is how either man’s character would respond to a sudden crisis. The policy options remain alike. But character counts.
Cultural vs. Political Libertarianism
Poulos wades through the weeds.