The Case Against Brooks

Radley Balko issues an invigorating response to David Brooks’ recent paean to authoritarian conservatism. The really weird thing about the enthusiasm for big government’s "moral guard-rails" is that the period in which government was kept under control – in the 1990s – every social indicator improved. As Radley reminds us:

Seems to me that technology, relaxed public attitudes, and consumer choice have given Americans more lifestyle freedom over the last 15 years than we‚Äôve ever had before. Yet not only is our national moral fabric not unraveling, it appears to be as durable and fibrous as it’s ever been.
So why exactly do we need more moral guardrails from the government aimed at restricting behavior? …  We handle our liberty just fine, thanks. The vast majority of Americans don’t need government-imposed ‘guardrails.’ Family, friends, churches, and other support networks more than suffice.

This used to be one of the benchmarks of conservatism. Now, it’s a minority view.

Conservative Books

A reader observes:

Godless I have often chuckled at the titles that head conservative bestsellers these days (as a resident of liberal Ann Arbor, they’re usually lined up for me in the discount section of my bookstore). Nowhere has the decline of rational conservatism into rabid partisan rhetoric become more apparent.

I always hoped someone would write a parody of these books, punctuated of course by some absurdly hateful title. However, I now realize it would be almost impossible to exaggerate the bloodthirsty verbal attacks that now define popular conservative writing. After all, what warped description of liberals could one come up with that has not already been taken.

Deliverus Terrorists? Done (Hannity). Death-lovers? Yep (Ponnuru). Treasonous? Absolutely (Coulter). Mentally disabled? Sure (Savage). And the ever popular, godless (all of the above). By equating liberalism with Nazi fascism, Jonah Goldberg has used the last and most desperate of all attack methods. In their attempts to incite hate (and sell books) these writers have created the closest thing to a parody of the conservative movement I could have imagined.

My favorite is still Sean Hannity’s "Deliver Us From Evil: Defeating Terrorism, Despotism, and Liberalism." Yep: terrorists and liberals, the same evil. But that guy is now a very, very, very rich man.

(Update: I forgot to mention Jon Chait’s analysis of the same phenomenon. Worth a chuckle.)

Meltdown in Basra?

Some disturbing news, if Juan Cole’s analysis of an al-Zaman/AFP report is correct:

[Majid al-Sari, adviser to the Minister of Defense,] said that for the last month, Basra has been afflicted by a mass of assassinations, equalling one each hour of the day. (That would be 24 a day, and 720 for the month). Sources in the city allege that the police are helpless to intervene, and indeed refuse to go out to the crime scene to attempt to capture the assassins, since they would take fire from tribesmen supporting the assassins, who belong to their tribe.

Al-Zaman’s sources told it that Basra is in chaos and dominated by militias and lawless gangs. Automobiles with darkened windows cruise the streets, armed militiamen within, who impose their law on the city. These sources blamed Kuwait and Iran for the situation, alleging that their intelligence services are funding and arming the Iraqi militias for their own purposes. Tribal firefights between the Marsh Arab Al-Bait Sa’idah tribe and the Bani Mansur are common– as is fighting between Bani Ammar and Al-`Ashur. The sources say that Basra is without authority save that of the militiamen. The major political parties are unable to dampen down the violence because they are so divided against one another.

Elsewhere, the violence continues to rage, while the politicians continue to dither over the composition of the new government.