“I said to a minister I know: have you thought this through? Because you’re doing the law of succession, too. When we have a queen who is a lesbian and she marries another lady and then decides she would like to have a child and someone donates sperm and she gives birth to a child, is that child heir to the throne?” – Norman Tebbit, former chairman of the Conservative Party, on the bill for marriage equality in Britain.
Question Of The Day
A reader writes:
I agree with your poll that the Daily Wrap wasn’t useful enough to justify the time commitment. But could you do some kind of end of day “thing”? I did like the wrap because I knew when I got to the end-of-the-day’s posts. Is there something easy or similar that can be a final thought, or a final feature to close out the day’s posts? Thanks for the consideration!
I think I’m going to re-post my favorite post of the day. And maybe add a couple of links to other posts I think may be worth a second or first look. How’s that?
The Sanity Of The American People, Ctd
Blumenthal finds that Obama’s approval ratings are holding steady:
The current HuffPost Pollster estimate of Obama’s job approval rating, based on the combination of all available public polls, is 47.6 percent. His approval rating has been declining since the January inauguration, but at a glacial pace, erasing gains made during and after the fall campaign. However, a closer look at the most recent daily tracking polls shows no dramatic change in the past week.
Maybe it’s because, as yet, there is no real scandal. Even the IRS targeting of dubious Tea Party (c)4s is beginning to seem less insane as we discover the scale of their sleaze and the bipartisan calls for oversight. The AP leak was a very serious one, exposing a crucial agent inside a dangerous Yemeni Jihadist cell. Benghazi? There’s very little there there. Nate Silver credits the economy for Obama’s resilience:
Based on the historical relationship between Mr. Obama’s overall and economic approval ratings in the poll, you’d predict that his overall approval rating would be 53 or 54 percent given an economic approval rating of 48 percent. Instead, it’s 51 percent. So it may be that the talk surrounding Benghazi, the I.R.S. and the Justice Department has negatively affected Mr. Obama’s approval rating by two or three percentage points, but that the economy has lifted his numbers by about the same amount.
Ezra sees Obama’s poll numbers as evidence that “scandals are likely to simply harden the Democratic perception that Republicans are out to get Obama, and the Republican perception that Obama is a corrupt president”:
“People respond along party lines,” writes Alan Abramowitz, an Emory political scientist who predicted last week that the polls would remain unchanged, “just like members of Congress. Republicans believe the worst of Obama, but they already believed the worst of Obama. Democrats (correctly) see Republicans pushing these things because they are out to get Obama and stop his agenda and/or they think Obama is responding correctly to the problems that do exist. So it’s like almost every other issue or controversy.”
Except for Independents who, I suspect, are somewhat bored/exhausted by the Washington minutiae. And every day the GOP obsesses about these details, they fail to propose any set of sane policies to address the national problems. In the end, that matters. Under Clinton, at least the GOP had an agenda, other than pure oppositionism. Seth Masket notes that, during the Lewinsky scandal, Clinton famously saw an approval rating bump. The causes of that bump that may also apply to Obama:
One [theory] is that the public largely sympathized with Clinton. Not that they approved of his behavior—far from it—but that they felt that his affair did not warrant impeachment or the media firestorm that surrounded it, and they registered their dissent with the media and with overly enthusiastic congressional Republicans by supporting him.
Another theory, offered by John Zaller, my advisor when I was in graduate school, is that the public generally doesn’t factor scandals in when evaluating presidential performance. What they do care about are the same things they care about during elections: peace, prosperity, and moderation. The intense scandal coverage caused people to pay attention to politics in a non-election season. They evaluated Clinton’s performance and generally judged him to be running things well.
I suspect they think the same of the current president. With good reason.
Very Small Town America
An Oxford American mini-documentary, featured above, lost a National Magazine Award earlier this month to Romney’s 47% video on Mother Jones. Kevin Hartnett reflects:
There’s a lot of joy and some sadness, too, in Tiny Town, a small-scale world housed in Hot Springs, Arkansas. The elaborate model was carved and assembled over the course of 68 years by Frank Moshinskie and today it’s managed as a modest tourist attraction by his son, Charles. … The movie shows Charles–who’s no young man himself–telling about how the display began as a decoration beneath his dad’s Christmas tree and grew over seven decades into an ensemble that includes scenes from 21 different states in the country. There’s a replica of Dodge City from the television show Gunsmoke, a little Niagara Falls, and an island cabin tucked among the trees. Charles says his dad liked to carve figures that move, so Tiny Town includes kids poised on teeter-totters, a sheriff sticking up some poor soul, a floating hot air balloon, and a circling airplane. The whole thing is marvelous, but it becomes more acutely melancholic when Charles climbs into Tiny Town to show the audience around: He’s ostensibly a giant, but really the model’s smallness starts to reflect our own.
Update from a reader:
The touching video you posted today of Frank Moshinskie and his “Tiny Town” reminded me of another talented folk artist whose life work has become a beloved roadside attraction. I had the pleasure of visiting Barney Smith’s Toilet Seat Art Museum in San Antonio, Texas a few summers back. Mr. Smith is a warm, lively soul in his 90s who shows no signs of slowing in his passion for making art out of toilet seats. Barney said, “I was a master plumber before I retired so I was comfortable with the medium.”
I made a short video of our visit. Here’s a link.
“Racists Love Race Science”
Freddie DeBoer has a new post on the race and IQ debate that deserves to be read in full. A key part:
People insist: hey, you’ve got to let the science be the science, you’ve got to look at the facts, you’ve got to let them make the case. And I try. I read their essays. I follow their links. I do make a good faith effort. But I do not make that effort with similar credulity or sympathy that I do when I read someone write about tweaking the Earned Income Tax credit or make an argument about alcohol licensing. Why? Because one of these arguments has been used for the perpetuation of a system of chattel slavery and racist domination. That’s why. And, sure enough: whenever people pop up to tell me, “Here, check this link, read the facts,” and I click and read around, and then I follow more links, inevitably, I end up at Stormfront or similar houses of explicit racism. Inevitably, the people who are arguing about inherent black and Hispanic tendency to be unintelligent are also arguing about “black aggression” or “hypersexuality” or “inherent tendency to criminality.” This will apparently come as a shock to Andrew: racists love race science.
Is the correlation between belief in race science and racism 1? No. But it’s a lot closer to 1 than it is to 0. Is that dispositive of the question? Of course not. If there’s a racial bias towards low IQ, and if IQ is really an adequate gauge for real-world, lived intelligence, then the truth will out, just as it will if homosexuality is pathogenic. But to pretend as if people who are pushing the idea of inherent racial inferiority in IQ don’t tend to be the kind of people who believe all sorts of racist things is stupid. It’s moronic. It’s exactly the kind of willful failure to see connections that Andrew is accusing other people of.
I do not doubt that many of those pursuing this question are doing so for ugly reasons. Probably a hefty majority. That should make one especially leery of their arguments and make one very aware of the need to use empiricism almost pathologically. But, of course, one reason why this area is so clogged with racists is that non-racists don’t want to go there. My worry is that not going there will only rebound against the case that such data should not in any way be used for public policy. If affirmative action is finally abolished, we may be able to get race as an identifier out of policy discussions altogether. But what happens if affirmative action goes and we have universities that are overwhelmingly Asian-American and Jewish? What will liberals do then? Another important section from Freddie:
I appreciate that Andrew has, as he always does, engaged with criticism and opposing opinion on this issue. But I am frustrated by Andrew’s continuing ahistorical credulity on this issue, his tendency to read the people making these arguments with the most possible charity. And he matches that with a distinct lack of charity for those resisting them, the constant invocation of liberal piety and political correctness.
I would like very much for Andrew to consider whether his long history with this issue, and the attendant criticism he’s received, has rendered him too ready to see those pushing the race-IQ connection as principled empiricists untouched by emotion or animus. To posit that they are sober-minded, rational minds merely pursuing the scientific truth disinterestedly while their opponents are motivated by groupthink and emotion is a pretty great way to make yourself gullible on an issue where gullibility has profoundly negative consequences.
I cannot analyze myself – but I’m sure I am affected by my history on this. One part, as I’ve written before, is that my entire education was made possible by an IQ test at age eleven, which gave me entrance to what Americans would call a magnet school. I owe a lot to that test – and it was initiated by the left. Today’s liberals forget that testing IQ was once a leftwing idea. It was designed to rescue the poor from the trap of poverty by giving bright kids from poor backgrounds a swift entry to the British elite. That was the left of the 1940s – and you can look up Keynes and eugenics for further insight into how socialist this idea was in origin. Another part was, indeed, the reaction to my convening a debate on “The Bell Curve” at TNR, in the best-selling issue in that magazine’s history. I saw how some liberals really do not believe in free debate where race is concerned.
But I do not believe that critics of the whole project are fueled by groupthink or emotion alone. There’s a very solid case against race as anything meaningful in our culture, and an even stronger case that in the process of constant miscegenation, we are rendering the whole idea of race moot. I sure hope so. There’s also a strong argument that IQ is of extremely limited use – and, in fact, misses a whole range of intelligences that are often more important to our lives and cultures as humans.
I just refuse to wish the data away. The data shocked me when I first read it, and shocks me still.
Pop Goes The Easel
Image Duplicator is an exhibition featuring artists who have re-appropriated the works of Roy Lichtenstein, the pioneering appropriator of comic book art:
According to the Tate Modern – home to an exhibition of his work until May 27 – he is one of the true greats of the twentieth century. His paintings are worth millions, and even those with little knowledge of or interest in art will instantly recognise prints such as Whaam! and Drowning Girl.
But the trouble with Lichtenstein’s work, says [curator] Rian Hughes, is that most – if not all of it – is appropriated from comic book artists without credit or compensation. “Almost every painting [Lichtenstein] ever did was appropriated without asking permission or paying royalties. If he was a musician, he would be facing a copyright lawsuit,” claims Hughes. …
So why has this been allowed to continue for so long? Hughes believes it’s symptomatic of a widespread snobbery towards commercial art. “If you unearthed a rare song and sampled it, people would take great delight in pointing out the source material. Yet in the art world, the source material – particularly when it is created by commercial instead of fine artists – is often treated as if it is some kind of cultural clip art – “low” art that fine artists will elevate to “high” art,” he says. “[W]hat we’re really hoping to do [with Image Duplicator] is encourage people to celebrate good art regardless of where it came from,” he says.
(Image: Dave Gibbons’s re-appropriation of Whaam!, inspired by illustrations by Irv Novick, courtesy of Orbital Comics Gallery)
Programmed For Your Personal Pleasure
Bill Wasik considers the next step in the tech revolution – a world in which our appliances talk to one another and anticipate our next moves:
Think about where you spend most of your waking hours: your office, perhaps, or your living room or car. There are all sorts of adjustments you make over the course of any given day that are reducible to simple if-then relationships. If the sun hits your computer screen, then you lower a shade. If someone walks in the door, then you turn down your music. If there’s too much noise outside, then you close your window. If you have a Word document open but haven’t finished writing a sentence in 10 minutes, then you brew another pot of coffee. Would you want to automate all of these relationships? Not necessarily. But you might find that automating some of them would make your life easier, more streamlined.
Deciding what to call it is a whole other matter:
Some have called it the Internet of Things or the Internet of Everything or the Industrial Internet—despite the fact that most of these devices aren’t actually on the Internet directly but instead communicate through simple wireless protocols. Other observers, paying homage to the stripped-down tech embedded in so many smart devices, are calling it the Sensor Revolution.
But here’s a better way to think about what we’re building: It’s the Programmable World. After all, what’s remarkable about this future isn’t the sensors, nor is it that all our sensors and objects and devices are linked together. It’s the fact that once we get enough of these objects onto our networks, they’re no longer one-off novelties or data sources but instead become a coherent system, a vast ensemble that can be choreographed, a body that can dance.
The Sky Phone
In a new series called “Stupid Calculations,” Josh Orter estimates “the size of the screen that could be made if the displays were ripped out of every iPhone ever sold and combined into a single colossus”:
[T]he Kubrick-inspired monophone would stretch 5,059 feet into the sky and have a base measuring 2,846 feet across (Central Park is 2,640 feet wide). Its surface area would take in 2.07 billion square inches. That’s 14.39 million square feet or 330.54 acres.
Should We Kill Cursive? Ctd
From our reader poll (blue=yes, orange=no):
That 39% jumps to 50% among readers 35 and older, while only 28% of millennials say they use cursive. Among female readers, 63% use cursive, while only 30% of male readers do the same. And among all readers, a minority of 41% believe teachers should stop teaching cursive to children. Below are some remaining thoughts on the popular thread:
Cursive defenders all point to the supposed note-taking benefits of cursive. That’s absurd – if we wanted to teach a useful form of writing for transcription, we’d teach shorthand. Beyond that, writing faster encourages the wrong kind of note-taking. We shouldn’t be trying to transcribe whatever we’re listening to, but instead to synthesize it and take down notes about the key points. A professor of mine in law school banned laptops for exactly that reason – it encouraged transcription, not note-taking. Once I stopped trying to write down everything, my notes were far more useful, because the only thing they contained were the important parts.
These days, I take notes constantly just as part of being a lawyer. I do it on paper, with a pen. In print. Cursive wouldn’t help, so why did I learn it? The last time I wrote in cursive was the sworn statement on the bar exam. Before that, on the LSAT. It just has no relevance to modern life. For everything that isn’t taking a verbatim transcript, print is at least as good as cursive (and typically easier for others to read). For verbatim transcripts, shorthand is better. For long-form writing, typing is better. What benefit does cursive have left?
Another reader:
The only reason we’re having this discussion is because most of us, for more than 100 years, have been taught only the (frankly horrible) “Palmer System” of cursive handwriting.
The Palmer Method is a style of cursive composed of an entirely different set of letterforms than the manuscript (“printing”) we start with, and requires a dexterity unattainable to most 3rd graders. The result? Most people never give a thought to any remedial handwriting practice, and they rarely pass beyond whatever facility they may have had when they were eight.
Austin Palmer’s primary goal was to sell his textbooks and materials. In this, he was wildly successful. The Palmer Method’s quirky letterforms are an artifact of this (the better to differentiate your product). And they’re just plain difficult to achieve – born of an era that considered denial of the body a virtue, no thought was given to natural movement.
Compare this to the various types of Italic/Humanist miniscule. These are easily formed, easily read letters, and for the most part, the only difference between the manuscript and cursive forms are whether or not your raise your pen. No entirely new alphabets, no frankly tortured letterforms-as-trademark (I’m still confounded by Palmer’s capital F and lowercase r). Thornton’s Handwriting in America: A Cultural History is a nice overview of what Palmer hath writ, and Inga Dubay has made several very good instructional works that serve as wonderful introductions to a more suitable hand.
Another reader injects some cursive in the Dish:
Another:
Wow, your anti-cursive-teaching readers are talking about cursive like it’s copperplate calligraphy! It’s just cursive, folks! It’s actually lazier than print! You don’t have to pick up your pen. As someone who, quite literally, cannot draw a straight line without a ruler, I’m sympathetic to the people who had a hard time with cursive, but I think their bad experience doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be taught. I think it means teachers should allow that a small fraction of their students will never master it and stop docking their work for being a bit unsightly.
My case for why learning cursive is not a waste of time:
1) It’s taught in elementary school, where part of the goal is to get you familiar with how your hands work, learn about what’s in the larger world, and learn a useful skill. Doing drills is good for practicing fine motor skills, whether or not you ever succeed in the task. Cursive is used extensively in the world, and one needs to know it.
2) Cursive is one of the few times in early ed when we learn that there are multiple solutions to a problem. Yes, keyboarding is another solution to the problem of putting words to paper. But I remember having my mind blown a little bit in third grade when I learned that a giant, curly 2 was actually a Q. That a printed and cursive “f” were very different. After learning cursive, I was even able to puzzle out other fonts, whereas before I had no clue. But once I knew the various forms each letter could take, the number of written items I had independent access to, without having to get an adult to read it for me, went up enormously.
3) Any number of documents throughout the years have been written in cursive or other script. Anyone wanting to do genealogy or historical research had better have some familiarity with cursive. And without the drilling in it in elementary school, they probably wouldn’t.
4) Cursive aside, writing clearly is a useful skill. Whether or not you use it beyond that class is up to you, but the vast majority of us write things down. Cursive – or some pidgen version of it – is generally faster than print. Learning to write faster is useful. It’s not like calligraphy, with specific styles and harder rules, and slower execution. Third graders don’t have much room to negotiate with teachers, but maybe they should. We had one kid in our 5th grade class that was allowed to turn in assignments from a dot-matrix printer due to his abysmal handwriting, and the fact that his family had an early computer. Because our teachers were reasonable people. He tried, they negotiated, and came to a workable solution. Everyone else could write sufficiently well. Even me with my spastic fingers.
Morgan Polikoff gets the last word:
Since my quote started the Dish thread on cursive, I thought I’d go one more round. Before I start, I thought I’d mention just how amazing this story is to me. I did a one-off interview with the LA Times about cursive, and it’s become the most talked-about thing I’ve done or written (somewhat humbling to this academic who’s trying to do good research on other, much more important policies). The key point to me is that every single pro-cursive argument that’s made is very easy to rebut. Just running through the ones that have appeared in this thread:
1) Handwriting builds muscles and hand/eye coordination. True, but this applies to print and cursive – no evidence cursive is better than print.
2) There is a need write quickly and legibly. Actually, there rarely is (basically note-taking and test-taking in school is the only time in life this is needed). But if speed was the concern, keyboards are way faster than cursive. And if keyboards aren’t nearby and speed is paramount, we should teach kids shorthand.
3) Handwritten notes are more meaningful than typed. I agree with this, but again it applies to print and cursive.
4) Signatures need cursive for security. Actually this is not true. But if we were really concerned about security, we’d have moved past signatures now anyway – they’re not very secure at all. How about retina scans or fingerprints?
5) It can be beautiful. This one I agree with, but it’s hardly a reason to spend lots of instructional time on it. Needlepoint is also beautiful.
6) There’s plenty of time to do it. Well, to do it well takes a lot of time, and our teachers are already very strapped for instructional time. Furthermore, cursive isn’t included in the new Common Core content standards adopted by 45 states. Asking teachers to add things on top of the content standards dilutes the messages of those standards and leads to a cluttered, mile-wide inch-deep curriculum (which we already have).
7) Writing beautifully deepens our connection with the language. Not sure exactly what this means, but I don’t see why it wouldn’t also apply to print. Calligraphy is more beautiful than cursive – let’s teach that.
8) Not everything we teach has to be “useful.” This one I can buy as well. But it’s not an argument for keeping cursive per se, just an argument for a different philosophy about what to teach in general.
9) Research says it helps the brain. Actually almost all of the research is about handwriting instruction in general, not cursivehandwriting in particular. Including basically every study linked in the article cited by your reader.
10) Dyslexic kids learn well from cursive. This one does have some merit, but then the Yale Dyslexia Center says keyboarding is much better than cursive.
I could go on, but you get the point. There just isn’t a compelling reason that cursive should be taught to every student. Irealize this is some kind of cultural hornet’s nest I’ve stumbled into, but can we please just move on and let this thing die? As with gay marriage, we all know it’s going to happen sooner or later. Let’s get there sooner and save everyone the grief.




