The AP’s Metadata

Kelsey D. Atherton spells out a key detail behind the DOJ-AP phone record story:

When the Supreme Court set the legal precedent back in 1979, phone records contained much less information. Nowadays, a phone record’s metadata includes not just the phone number, but the time the call took place, the call origin, the call duration, and the carrier.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation, a non-profit dedicated to the protection of digital rights, said in a statement released [Monday] that it “no longer makes sense to treat calling records and other metadata related to our communications as if they aren’t fully protected by the Constitution.”

Electronic communications have improved drastically since the legal precedent was set, and the amount of revealing data now transferred with a phone call is far greater than just a telephone number. But the law has yet to catch up with technology—which means the Justice Department has access to a lot more than just the numbers dialed by the AP’s journalists.

Impressionist Product Placement

dish_640px-Edouard_Manet,_A_Bar_at_the_Folies-Bergère

Maria Popova quotes Debbie Millman on the history of branding:

The word “brand” is derived from the Old Norse word brandr, which means “to burn by fire.” … In 1876, after the United Kingdom passed the Trade Mark Registration Act, Bass Ale became the first trademarked brand in the world after submitting its now-quintessential red triangle for trademark status. The act gave businesses the ability to register and protect a brand marker so that a similar icon couldn’t be used by any other company. In addition to clinching trademark number 1, Bass’s trailblazing history includes its appearances in Édouard Manet’s 1882 masterpiece A Bar at the Folies-Bergère and Pablo Picasso’s 1912 painting Bouteille de Bass et Guitare, ostensibly providing the brand with the cultural distinction of “first product placement.”

(Image: A Bar at the Folies-Bergère, Édouard Manet, 1882, from Wikimedia Commons)

Detainee Rehab

Olga Khazan profiles different countries’ “jihadi recovery programs” as a way to brainstorm what should happen to Gitmo detainees. The Saudi approach:

At the Mohammed bin Naif Center for Counseling and Care, alleged militants enjoyed buffet meals and classes in everything from Islam to art therapy. Their strategy? Have imams explain to the men that not everyone can issue a fatwa — an Islamic legal pronouncement — only religious leaders can. Some of the men had apparently been issuing fatwas from their al-Qaeda cells, according to CNN, therein committing their entire group to radical action.

When they graduated, the men in the Saudi program received a lump sum of $2,665 and $700 a month for their first six months on the outside. The government then helped them find jobs and wives. “I have good life, a good wife,” Khalid Suliman al-Jhari, a former Guantánamo prisoner, told the Christian Science Monitor. “I believe that this idea is working because the people … are honest about fixing [ex-jihadis]…. It’s not just a job.” …

A just-built Riyadh facility that can house up to 228 people offers luxury as an incentive to drop extremism: “In between sessions with counselors and talks on religion,” the AFP reports, “prisoners will be able to relax in the center’s facilities which include an Olympic-size indoor swimming pool, a sauna, a gym and a television hall.” Behave well, and you get a two-day break to spend with your wife.

The Fracking Debate, Ctd

Readers from both sides of the divide tell their stories:

The oil and gas industry has been fracking wells for decades. It is not a new technology. I have worked in the industry for more than 30 years and took classes in the early 1980s on fracking. The majority of wells in Oklahoma have been fracked. The water supply has not been affected adversely. Having toured the water treatment facility in Tulsa there was no mention of contamination from oil and gas drilling and there have been thousands of wells drilled in northeastern Oklahoma since the early 1900s.

The major change in the drilling of oil and gas wells is that prior to the last decade most wells were vertical wells, meaning that a hole was drilled to a certain depth and the producing formation was fracked sending the fracking material into the zone so the oil and/or gas would be freed and sent to the surface. The amount of oil and gas that could be recovered was limited to the area around the vertical hole.

In recent years technology has improved to where a vertical hole is drilled to the desired formation and then it turns at a right angle and the hole is drilled horizontally for the length of one or two sections.

After the well is completed, it is fracked in that formation. The recovery with a vertical well was limited to as far as the fracking reached horizontally into the formation. The recovery from a horizontal well is much more efficient since the pipe runs horizontally through the formation. The well is fracked at predetermined intervals along the horizontal line. New technology also allows for a number of wells to be drilled from one drill site rather than the need for several drill sites.

The oil and gas industry is like any industry. Most of the players are responsible and it is the few bad actors that give the rest a bad name. The risk of pollution and danger are much more likely to happen when a well is depleted and it is not properly plugged and abandoned. Luckily the records we have today are very good and what took place in the early 1900s is not happening today.

Also it is important to remember that the oil and gas companies are in the business to turn a profit. The cost to drill a horizontal well is between $5,000,000 and $15,000,000 depending on depth and length of the horizontal leg. The well has to produce a lot of gas at $3.50 and/or oil at $90 a barrel to pay out. It is in the companies interest to make sure that the hole is secure and that the pipe does not leak or break. The amount of oil and/or gas in a formation is finite, and the oil company hopes that there are enough reserves to recover the drilling costs and make money far in the future. Wells are not all equal and many do not pay out.

I lean liberal and would rather live with oil and gas as a source for energy than nuclear and the question of keeping all the spent rods. Wind is also a good option but requires much more land space and, in my opinion, is a bigger eyesore than oil and gas development. I do worry about the amount of water that is used but there are ways to clean it up. There is also an online resource to find out the chemicals used in wells called Frac Focus.

Another is much more worried about the water issue:

I am the Director of Admissions at a small “environmentally aware” independent boarding school in Ohio that has considerable land resources. With the contraction of the independent school market that followed the recession in 2008, our school has seen a precipitous decline in enrollment and is located in a rural area that has traditionally been economically depressed. As you can imagine, we are a prime candidate for the oil and gas companies to woo into signing away our mineral rights. We have held out thus far. In my position I have been able to see the influence with which oil and gas companies have exercised to their benefit.

First, they work heavily with municipal leadership. Since these municipalities are cash strapped, mayors and city counselors are eager to bring money (doesn’t matter how much) into the town. Our head of school has been “called” into meetings with the mayor, who insists on breakfast and lunch meetings with representatives from the O & G folk. As it turns out, on top of the lease agreement that is signed for say, $6,000 per acre (a hefty sum for an area that has seen nothing but net population decrease since the 1950s), the company then goes out of its way to grant “gifts” to institutions that sign away the mineral rights. For example, our town has recently signed the property of the public high school to the O & G people. A week later, the company decides to spontaneously gift a sum of $40,000 to the high school. Same with the hospital. This is done with fanfare at a public event (in this case, a Chamber of Commerce meeting with local business owners). Though this is presented as a gift in the interest of being “corporate citizens,” in reality this is a signing bonus that is agreed upon before the lease is signed. The cherry on top.

The amount they are offering is chump change compared to both the net profits they will make in addition to the “unseen” costs of unregulated drilling. With the inflow of workers from out of state, rents in the area have skyrocket, pushing lower income residents out of town. They aren’t using local labor, and since wells only last 1-2 years, the influx of money to the local economy is only temporary, and is used to plug budget gaps that will just come up again in the near future. Retail and services benefit with the influx of new people, but will contract again in 8-10 years when the company moves on to greener pastures, leaving the town worse than where it started.

I must apologize, as I seem to be ranting, but there are two environmental angles that haven’t been covered as far as I have seen.

One is clearing. A local teacher found himself approached by the company, asking to lay pipe foundations across his property. In the contracts, the company stated that clearing 50 feet of forest on either side of the pipe was necessary for maintenance of the line (100 feet across). This would have effectively leveled most of his property. Though he didn’t sign, there are many more people who do because in addition to the mineral rights lease, they are given a sum of money per foot of pipe laid.

The second is the volume of water used, rather than just the pollution of our groundwater. We live in the watershed of a creek that flows into the Ohio River. The same teacher referenced above had taken students towards where the creek flows into the river, and found a well-cap that had been drilled in the flood basin of the creek, with hoses drawing water directly out of the creek. Where this gets particularly worrisome is that Ohio is a “free use” state, meaning these companies can draw up to 100,000 gallons of water from the creek per day regardless of time of year. The creek cannot sustain that kind of water draw, especially during the summer when the water levels drop. Especially when you have one well-cap per square mile all drawing water from the same creek.

We got in touch with the Ohio Department of Natural Resources, who issue the permits for gas wells. They do no monitoring of the amount of water drawn, and instead referred us to three different agencies: Soil and Water, the EPA, and the Army Corps of Engineers. After attempting to get in touch with those three organizations, we realized there is no enforcement, only data-tracking at best.

These are huge problems that aren’t getting addressed because these companies are able to come into areas and dangle vast quantities of money in front of cash-strapped municipalities. This is where I disagree with an earlier reader, who said that putting this in charge of municipalities will make sure local issues are discussed. What is unfortunate is that most of the time these municipalities do not have the resources necessary to adequately assess the affect of fracking on their communities before its too late.

More views from readers here.

The Scandalfog Machine

Ambers thinks Washington is guilty of blowing scandals out of proportion:

In reality, we have Benghazi, the IRS targeting of conservative groups, and the Justice Department’s aggressive investigation into a national security leak. … To call all three “scandals,” and to create, to manufacture, a scandalfog machine and set it in the direction of the White House is to either deliberately ignore the facts underlying these three events or to eagerly make imaginative leaps in order to create the narrative of a scandal-plagued White House without any real plot points.

Lizza identifies another issue with the way Washington discusses scandals:

The larger problem with the scandal culture in D.C. is that, because each example of government wrongdoing quickly morphs into a partisan effort to attack the White House (the same was true when a Republican was President), the actual remedies for the problems uncovered become almost beside the point. A U.S. congressman will probably go farther in his party hierarchy by roughing up Obama than he will by helping to pass legislation to ensure that all diplomatic posts have adequate security. Likewise, the I.R.S. abuses suggest the need for both major tax reform and changes to campaign-finance laws, while a future dragnet of news media phone records could be prevented if a strong federal shield law were in place. Don’t hold your breath waiting for any of these policy changes.

The Traits Of An American

Like me, Conor is opposed to using IQ scores to determine immigration eligibility. He observes that “barring the hypothetical low IQ people would imply that intelligence determines worth, and that our project as a nation is intimately tied to constantly maximizing material wealth”:

I wouldn’t go so far as to say that recruiting human beings with impressive skills is illegitimate. In fact, I think it is prudent, and I’m glad that lots of talented scientists, athletes, artists, and programmers want to come here. More, please. I’m glad that lots of farm workers and janitors want to immigrate too. I recognize that the economic contributions of the two groups are different, but I don’t conclude that the low skill immigrants are less worthy of citizenship or less valuable citizens. Are they kind? Honest? Wise? Fun? Hardworking? Inclined to embrace core American values as articulated in the Declaration of Independence? To what extent do they participate in the civic process? Do they raise children who flourish? Do the best of their ethnic traditions and cultural insights enrich the American character? Do they contribute to the common defense? Are they invested in their new country? It’s amazing how often bygone immigration debates have focused on a couple narrow metrics to the exclusion of all else. There are so many important traits, and seemingly no one clamoring to measure or recruit for most of them.

The Long Game On Gitmo

US-POLITICS-GUANTANAMO BAY

Daniel Klaidman reports something I’ve also picked up from my sources: that “Obama plans to address both Guantánamo and drones—another festering, controversial element of the administration’s national-security agenda—in a broad ‘framing’ speech that will try to knit together an overarching approach to counterterrorism.”

The speech could well serve as the White House’s opening shot in its new campaign to solve the Guantánamo riddle. But Obama’s critics will be skeptical—likely branding it another attempt to bend the arc of history with mere eloquence. It would fit a pattern on rule-of-law issues, they say, in which Obama’s lofty rhetoric is rarely followed by resolute action—especially when it comes to standing up to Congress. According to this narrative, Obama expresses righteous indignation, but then is persuaded by his political team that the time is not right to fight. Or he threatens to veto legislation that shackles him on Guantánamo, but then fails to go through with the threat. The dynamic, critics say, creates a self-fulfilling cycle that emboldens congressional Republicans and weakens the president.

There’s plenty of evidence to support this interpretation of events. On the other hand, it also arguably downplays the blunt reality that any president needs to prioritize his policy initiatives. When Team Obama began its bid to close Guantánamo in 2009, it was still trying to stave off economic depression, save the banking system, and bail out the auto industry. Later, Obama chose health-care reform as his signature domestic initiative—an all-consuming political struggle that left the White House with little bandwidth to fight on multiple other fronts. Something had to give. For Obama, it was Gitmo.

His supporters also argue that instead of giving up, Obama has shifted to a long-road strategy, which sometimes requires backing down from epic confrontations in the hope that over time the politics will turn his way. In at least one area—prosecuting suspected terrorists in civilian courts—that approach may be working. Though Obama caved to criticism and backed down on trying KSM in court back in 2011, he subsequently decided to have a string of captured terrorists tried in the civilian justice system, the latest being Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, the surviving Boston bomber. Over time, the criticism has dwindled to barely a peep.

(Photo:  A protestor wears an orange prison jump suit and black hood on his head during protests against holding detainees at the military prison in Guantanamo Bay during a demonstration in front of the US Supreme Court in Washington, DC, on January 8, 2013. By Saul Loeb./AFP/Getty Images)

Combating Military Rape, Ctd

A reader writes:

As a Dishhead and an officer in the National Guard, I feel I should chime in on this issue. It’s been a disgraceful year, and the reforms called for by Sen. Gillibrand are badly needed. Frankly, the UCMJ needs to be completely overhauled and brought into the modern era. Sodomy shouldn’t still be codified, for instance. Commanders with no legal experience have way too much power over their troops, and as was seen with the Air Force officer who overturned a sexual assault court martial finding of guilt, it’s prone to secrecy and misuse.

But culture needs to change too. Have a stop over at the military subreddits and read the comments on any story dealing with anything regarding rape, sexual assault, gender issues, or sexual harassment. It’s endless choruses of “False accusations are the norm! Female soldier/Marine/airman/sailor was asking for it! You can never trust women when left alone!” with only the occasional sane person chiming in. Unfortunately, it’s an accurate reflection of the private talk that goes on in barracks, company areas, and motor pools.

That’s how you get SHARP coordinators charged with sexual abuse. That’s how you get the Air Force’s head of sexual assault prevention charged with sexual assault. That’s how you get the most lauded military officer in recent history embroiled in an adultery scandal with another military officer.

Another:

As someone (female) who served for six years in the enlisted side of the Navy, and was subject to quite a bit of “programming” on a myriad of subjects, I call bullshit on this reader. One-hour powerpoints once a quarter is not taking anything seriously. Allowing C.O.s to judge cases that might effect their manning in a negative way is not taking rape seriously.

To address the reader’s point directly, this is not an amorphous societal issue that one can hand wave away as something that will eventually fade with the cultural tides. This is a very specific issue of women having been poorly integrated into some parts of the military, seen as interlopers, and therefore deserving of any ill-treatment they might get. With a terribly bitter culture that says anything a military woman gets was ill-gotten, that a woman isn’t a real soldier or sailor, that any improvements in her standard of living must have come at the expense of a man, it’s very easy for the majority that would never do these things to look the other way.

I don’t know what would help the issue, but I know what doesn’t. Stop the “programming”. It’s designed principally to legally insulate the commander, and it implies that rape is an issue of enlisted who are dumb animals that don’t know any better. It does nothing to address male victims (I saw some appalling statistics on male rape at the 32nd St base in San Diego), and ignores officers who think that droit de signeur is still a thing. Do a better job integrating women into the professional culture, and bring more women into the service overall.

I can’t believe this is the issue that prompted me to write after eight years of reading. Thank you for raising contentious issues.