Blessed Be The Time Lord, Ctd

A reader writes:

I am reminded of an observation that George Orwell made about England:

The common people are without definite religious belief, and have been so for centuries. The Anglican Church never had a real hold on them, it was simply a preserve of the landed gentry, and the Nonconformist sects only influenced minorities. And yet they have retained a deep tinge of Christian feeling, while almost forgetting the name of Christ.

In that spirit, I view the Doctor as a very English interpretation of Christ:  An eccentric fellow who wanders about doing good deeds, will bend the rules in the causes of justice and compassion, attracts followers who seek to emulate his example — and of course, periodically gives his life so that others may live, and is then resurrected.

Exactly. Jesus with a sonic screwdriver and a sense of fun.

Comedian-In-Chief

Ben Yagoda applauds Obama’s executive wit at this year’s Correspondents’ Dinner:

He’s got impressive comedy chops to start with: the poker face, the sense of the proper cadence of a line, the willingness to pause for a long beat while he looks off into the middle distance, in the manner of Hope or Benny. He has a trademark delivery, the way he barks out a huh! after setting down a premise. And nothing but God-given talent can explain his skill at milking or playing off a bit. The only wall this president wants to tear down is the fourth one, as he deftly riffs on the joke he’s just made:

I’m also hard at work on plans for the Obama Library. And some have suggested that we put it in my birthplace, but I’d rather keep it in the United States. (Laughter.) Did anybody not see that joke coming? (Laughter.) Show of hands. Only Gallup? Maybe Dick Morris? (Laughter and applause.)

Then, at another point:

Of course, everybody has got plenty of advice. Maureen Dowd said I could solve all my problems if I were just more like Michael Douglas in “The American President.” (Laughter.) And I know Michael is here tonight. Michael, what’s your secret, man? (Laughter.) Could it be that you were an actor in an Aaron Sorkin liberal fantasy? (Laughter.) Might that have something to do with it? (Applause.) I don’t know. Check in with me. Maybe it’s something else. (Laughter.)

Now, note the Dick-Vitalesque “second term, baby” in his opening bit, the “what’s your secret, man?” and “check in with me” in the one above. The truly remarkable thing about Obama as standup is that he really is the coolest guy in the room. This may be the nerd prom, but he is no nerd. Hearing him deliver jokes, you sense he’s actually listened to his teenage daughters talk (“I was like … “) and paid attention to what they’re interested in. (“Take the sequester. Republicans fell in love with this thing, and now they can’t stop talking about how much they hate it. It’s like we’re trapped in a Taylor Swift album. [Laughter.]“)

Are Small Donors The Solution?

Ezra Klein doesn’t believe that limits on the size of campaign contributions will be a panacea for our political woes:

We tend to assume “small donors” hail from that mythical, much-beloved class of people known as “ordinary Americans.” They’re not. Even if tens of millions of Americans are donating, hundreds of millions of other Americans aren’t. The tiny minority that donates is different from the vast majority that doesn’t: They’re much, much more ideologically polarized. What individual donors tend to want, [senator Chris] Murphy [D-CT] said, is partisanship. “When I send out a fundraising e-mail talking about how bad Republicans are, I raise three times as much as when I send out an e-mail talking about how good I am. People are motivated to give based on their fear of the other side rather than on their belief in their side.” …

Just as big money is corrupting, small money is polarizing. And it’s polarization that probably poses the bigger threat to American politics right now. Big money, for example, generally wants to raise the debt ceiling. Small money is one reason Republicans in Congress came close to breaching it.

Mijin Cha pushes back:

Where to start? Well, how about with the most recent election, in which highly ideological big donors played a critical role in moving the GOP to the right —  both during the primaries and the general election.

Think of a mega donor like Foster Friess, a hard right Christian conservative, who single-handledly kept Rick Santorum in the race and helped foster a climate in which Mitt Romney tacked right. Or think of the role played by the Club for Growth, which spent over $20 million to help knock off moderate GOP Senate and House candidates in the primaries. Or how about those Koch brothers, the life-long libertarians, who spent tens of millions of dollars in the last election cycle.

One reason the Republican Party finds it so hard to move in a more moderate direction is because deep-pocked groups like the the Club for Growth and NRA threaten to primary any congressional member who steps out of line. It’s these well-financed enforcers that are the main problem, not Michele Bachman’s small donors.

Maligning Millennials

This embed is invalid


Marc Tracy unloads on Joel Stein’s new cover-story (paywalled), which tries to take millennials down a peg:

[W]here it does say things, Time and Stein reveal themselves to be guilty of taking culturally and ethically specific ideas about how people should live their lives as normative facts. …

[F]rom Stein’s opening litany: “[Millennials’] development is stunted: more people ages 18 to 29 live with their parents than with a spouse, according to the 2012 Clark University Poll of Emerging Adults.” For one thing: it’s the economy, stupid! Thousands of words on, Stein dutifully nods toward other possible valid reasons for this development, such as greater, technologically enabled control over fertility. But that is not even the point. “Stunted” is one of those words that linguist Paul Roberts would have called “colorful.” Stein is making not only a forensic observation, but also a moral judgment. Millennials are delaying maturity, leaving home, marriage, having children, and the rest—and that is wrong of them. Thank God Joel Stein is here to set us right!

And from later on:

“They’re financially responsible; although student loans have hit record highs, they have less household and credit-card debt than any previous generation on record—which, admittedly, isn’t that hard when you’re living at home and using your parents’ credit card.” “Responsible,” too, is a moral word masquerading as an empirical one. To write an article about young people that minimizes student debt at a time when it, indeed, is at a record high, is astonishing enough. To imply that, in contrast to low household and credit-card debt, all of this student debt is not “responsible” betrays an incredibly poor understanding of how student debt has gotten as high as it has.

One of the most popular Dish threads from last year was “Letters from Millennial Voters” – read it all here.

The Fracking Debate

Readers continue it:

I’ve been following Josh Fox’s “Ask Anything” series with particular interest. As a native Pennsylvanian, I’ve been outraged by the gas industry’s aggressive and arrogant rush to turn Pennsylvania’s forests and farmlands into industrial areas.  As recently documented by this USGS report, this rapid industrialization of Pennsylvania’s forests with so many new roads and pipelines is fragmenting habitat that is really important for wildlife (among other apparently expendable things like clean water, air, public recreation, solitude, etc.).  The USGS released another report in March about the habitat fragmentation issue, which receives almost no coverage whatsoever.

A reader complained that “it’s obvious that Fox isn’t at all interested in presenting a fair (but biased) assessment.” That may be true. But I’m fairly more concerned about the gas industry’s propaganda that permeates the media. You cannot turn on cable TV without seeing an ad about the amazing benefits of “clean” natural gas. Give me a break. You may be able to say that burning natural gas is “cleaner” than coal or oil, but it is certainly not “clean,” particularly when you consider the process of exploration, development, production and transportation.

As for Mr. Fox’s presentation, full disclosure: I’ve never seen Gasland, so I’m not sure how the issues were presented.  But the reason I never saw Gasland is because I’ve lived Gasland.

I grew up in the oil and gas fields of northwestern Pennsylvania.  I’ve seen firsthand what happens when the oil and gas industry infiltrates and dominates your area.  Anyone wanting to know how good turning your region over to the oil and gas industry is need look no further than the “incredibly prosperous” towns of Oil City, Warren, and Bradford in northwestern Pennsylvania.  I invite anyone to visit these towns to see the rewards that await you if you only sign over your mineral rights for some short-sighted profits.

Unfortunately, the rest of Pennsylvania is getting to know all too well the reality that has existed in northwestern Pennsylvania for more than a century thanks to the oil and gas industry.  So much of Pennsylvania’s state forests in the north-central part of the state have been leased to the oil and gas industry over the last several years that the agency charged with managing those state forests, the DCNR, is concerned about its ability to maintain its status as a “sustainably managed” system by the Forest Stewardship Council.  Between Governors Rendell (a Democrat) and Corbett (a Republican), there’s been a bipartisan appeasement to the oil and gas industry that simply sacrificed hundreds of thousands of acres of state forest land, consequences be damned.

Finally, you state that “if it provides energy while lowering carbon emissions, I’m for it.”  Please, get out of Manhattan and for god’s sake visit some of the areas in Pennsylvania where “fracking” is allegedly “lowering” our “carbon emissions.”  I guarantee you it will take no longer than 10 minutes to see how ridiculous a statement that is.  Regardless, Bill McKibben repeatedly cautions that the only number that matters is the global amount of carbon in the atmosphere.  Thus, even if America allegedly reduces its emissions by transitioning away from coal to natural gas, that reduction only matters if that coal remains in the ground and is not dug up and shipped overseas to be burned.  Do you think the coal industry is just going to stop extracting coal because America relies more on natural gas?

Another suggests:

The dissenters that you published may want to read this article, “Fracking Would Emit Large Quantities of Greenhouse Gases,” in Scientific American.

Another reader:

I’m opposed to fracking. When I was still working for a newspaper, I did a couple of stories about people who were investigating fracking, so I wasn’t dealing directly with sources who were doing fracking or having their landfracked. I am intrigued by fracking because I took a couple of courses in geology in high school and so the actual process of fracking was something I wanted to know more about. I became opposed to fracking for several reasons.

First, I don’t like the way fracking disregards property lines on the surface, so that it’s difficult to allocate where the natural gas comes from and who should profit; I don’t like the unsettled law and I don’t like having mineral rights separated from surface rights (mostly because I grew up in a state where there wasn’t much mining or oil drilling).

Second, I don’t like the way fracking pumps undisclosed chemicals into geological strata to free up natural gas. Iffracking used water and say, baking soda, I’d say fine, go for it. Those are known quantities over the long run. But I am seriously concerned about water quality and have been for years, and I worry that we don’t know enough about how all aquifers are recharged to say with authority that fracking chemicals won’t circulate into aquifers eventually. I am very conservative about messing with water sources.

Third, I don’t trust regulation or corporations in general in the long run. Fracking advocates say the casings for the wells are securely enclosed and will last for years, protecting the water supply. That may be true. But there will be fracking contractors who don’t adhere to state-of-the-art standards and there will be weak or unethical regulators, so there will be instances of failure. Until we know how costly failure will be – in terms of water resources damaged, maintenance and containment of fracking fluids, and maintenance and containment offracking wells 50 to 100 years from now, I don’t trust fracking. I would want to see long-term bonds posted for each individual well-head, and I would also want to see regulators who don’t make mistakes or get complacent by doing active research on maintaining water quality and mitigating well failures.

My problems with fracking are that I can’t trust government to take in enough money to pay for problems caused by fracking many years from now. I can’t trust government to keep that money only for dealing with fracking without wasting it. I can’t trust corporations to always put water quality and public safety above profit margins, and I don’t trust lawyers, lawmakers or the courts to protect the rights of individuals when it comes to profits from resource extraction that can’t be tracked in ways that reflect the ownership interests of people who own the land at the surface, whether or not they always owned the mineral rights, never owned the mineral rights, or sold the mineral rights.

I think protecting the water supply is more important than lowering carbon emissions through fracking, but that leads to another discussion I won’t get into here – my bias is toward solar-powered roofs on every house and solar-powered skins on vehicles, with distributed energy production that decreases reliance on a grid powered by fossil fuels; I also favor funding more research into nuclear power production through fusion rather than fission.

Previous Dish on fracking here.

Face Of The Day

Julia Gillard Visits Papua New Guinea

Traditional dancers perform ahead of the arrival of Australian Prime Minister Julia Gillard at Jackson International Airport on May 9, 2013 in Port Moresby, Papua New Guinea. The trip is the first official visit for Gillard to the Pacific Island nation and the first visit since former prime minster Kevin Rudd visited in 2007. The three-day visit will include trips to a local market and primary school as well as tours of the Exxon Mobil Liquefied Natural Gas plant and the Bomana War Cemetery. By Chris McGrath/Getty Images.

Combating Military Rape, Ctd

A reader writes:

It would be nice if what your reader said was true: that the nearly 40 percent increase in rape occurred because victims now feel more comfortable reporting it. (I said “victims” and not “women” because more than half of rapes in the military are done to men.) The nearly 40 percent jump was for cases of sexual assault reported in an anonymous survey. The number of reported rapes has stayed about the same. This shows the opposite of what the reader said – that no progress is being made in making victims feel that reporting their rape will lead to anything positive.

Another:

The most surprising thing about the public discussion of military sexual assault is that no one has said “duh.” Think about it – the military:

Is composed largely of men in their sexual prime;
who are in peak physical condition;
who are trained to be aggressive and violent;
who are deprived of the opportunity for normal sexual relationships for months at a time;
who are subjected to enormous stress and fear of death.

Take a lot of guys in their horniest ages, whip their bodies into prime shape, teach them aggression and violence, show them they might not live much longer, and deprive them of most opportunities for sex. What the hell do we think is going to happen?

This is not to excuse sexual assault at all. It is, rather, to indict the military establishment’s unpreparedness or unwillingness to deal with it. They should have seen it coming a mile away.

The Benghazi Party

TO GO WITH AFP STORY By Otto Bakano -- T

[Re-posted from earlier today]

Responding to the idiotic conventional wisdom that Obama just doesn’t have the schmoozing skills to be an effective president, Norm Ornstein loses it:

“Didn’t any of you ever read Richard Neustadt’s classic Presidential Leadership? Haven’t any of you taken Politics 101 and read about the limits of presidential power in a separation-of-powers system?”

No, it seems, they haven’t. It’s a terrific piece, because it grapples with actual history:

No one schmoozed more or better with legislators in both parties than Clinton. How many Republican votes did it get him on his signature initial priority, an economic plan? Zero in both houses. And it took eight months to get enough Democrats to limp over the finish line. How did things work out on his health care plan? How about his impeachment in the House?

No one knew Congress, or the buttons to push with every key lawmaker, better than LBJ. It worked like a charm in his famous 89th, Great Society Congress, largely because he had overwhelming majorities of his own party in both houses. But after the awful midterms in 1966, when those swollen majorities receded, LBJ’s mastery of Congress didn’t mean squat.

And the GOP Obama faces is arguably the most partisan, factional and deranged that it has been since I started observing it in the mid-1980s. Zero votes for a modest stimulus in the worst recession since the 1930s right after a new president’s astounding electoral victory? Total, hysterical and futile opposition to healthcare reform – rather than working to make it better? Mitch McConnell’s entire strategy of simply denying Obama a second term, regardless of what he did or did not do (and failing)?

If you want to be obstructionist douches in the American system, oppose everything and anything Obama wants in the House, and demand a 60 vote super-majority to pass anything in the Senate, then that is your prerogative. But the GOP is offering nothing constructive on healthcare, nothing that can seriously be accomplished in a two-party system on the debt and entitlements, nothing but Captain Hindsight on Syria, and nothing on climate change, or gay rights. Nothing. The few of them who have championed immigration reform are going to face a storm of hostility from their base – and will endure a media hazing from the “conservative” media industrial complex.

Nonetheless, Obama is schmoozing on.

And nonetheless, he has guided the economy to a sustainable recovery – unlike any other developed nation. He got his stimulus through; and he got universal healthcare. He ended two draining, bankrupting, failed wars. He presided over a civil rights revolution – and played a key role in nudging it to fruition. He has created a coalition that, without gerrymandering, would command majorities in both Houses, and may well become a durable realignment to his party’s favor. If immigration reform passes, the substantive legislative achievements will be huge.

This is how to make sense of the over-coverage of Benghazi on the right. Some, like Butters, just want to save themselves from primary challenges; others see this as an early opportunity to bloody the woman who might crush them in 2016. But all of it is a sign of desperation. I keep asking myself: this is all they’ve got? This is what they want to place in front of the public in a time of great challenges at home and abroad? This?

You don’t need to turn a lamentable piece of government incompetence and some weak, shifting talking points into Watergate and Iran-Contra combined if you actually have a popular and constructive set of proposals for Americans to weigh. They have already derailed four careers (Susan Rice’s and three State Dept officials) and ended one entirely at the State Dept. And yet they are still breathless for more accountability, even as they are running on fumes.

Some Republicans seem to think this kind of negative nihilism is a way back to power. They need to remind themselves that Roger Ailes’ need for ratings is not the same thing as the GOP’s need for votes.

(Photo: Getty Images).

The Daily Wrap

Today on the Dish, Andrew engaged readers over Hawking’s Israel boycott, considered the implications of Sanford’s SC victory, glimpsed the GOP’s 2016 strategy in the Benghazi hearings, and railed against the obstructionism on the right. He marveled at the Tao of Drudge, found an English deity in the Doctor, and blasted those who prevented the burial of Tamerlan Tsarnaev while a reader compared him to Lee Harvey Oswald.

In political coverage, we rounded up responses to the Benghazi hearing, the Right continued to reform, and Frum defended Heritage. Reihan pondered the possibility of a 2015 surplus as Minnesota joined the marriage equality movement and the Feds tried to contain 3D-printable guns. Steve Brill’s healthcare exposé yielded results, Simon Shuster tied the Boston bombers to radical Islamists, and Kevin Spacey and Steny Hoyer debated the cynicism of Washington. Climate change got its day in court, Skeptical Science provided us with one-line responses for climate deniers, and Ohio voters approved local fracking.

In assorted news and views, Veronique Greenwood examined sensory curiosities, we drew parallels between the venus flytrap and our brains, Meher Ahmad explored married couples who stayed together by living apart, and Randy Frost found beauty in hoarding. Wiretaps moved into the 21st century, Jon Ronson profiled Kim Dotcom the non-pirate, and tech worked its way into our family trees.

Elsewhere, Doug Wignall lauded architects as political heroes, Gideon Lewis-Kraus griped about Yelp, and Fallows recognized the elegance in yesterday’s Google doodle. Politico erected a paywall, Tim Park sought out translators’ heavy touches, and Brandon Connely remembered a stop-motion legend. We browsed a London art fair in the FOTD, visited Venezuela in the VFYW and took to the skies for a VFYW bonus, and Between Two Ferns brought monogamy to spring break in the MHB.

– D.A.