Are Chemical Weapons A Game-Changer?

SYRIA-CONFLICT-CHEMICAL

Stephen Walt doesn’t see why they should be:

Does it really matter whether Assad is killing his opponents using 500-pound bombs, mortar shells, cluster munitions, machine guns, icepicks, or chemical weapons? Dead is dead no matter how it is done.

The case against direct U.S. intervention never depended on believing that Assad was anything but a thug; rather, it rested first and foremost on the fear that intervention might make things worse rather than better. Specifically, it has rested on the interrelated concerns that 1) the fall of the Assad regime might unleash an anarchy of competing factions and warlords, 2) the opposition to Assad contained a number of extremist groups whose long-term agendas were worrisome, and 3) pouring more weapons into a society in the midst of a brutal civil war would create another Afghanistan, Iraq, or 1970s-era Lebanon. These prudential concerns still apply, irrespective of the weaponry Assad’s forces have chosen to employ. And if his forces have used chemical weapons, then one might even argue that it raises the risks of intervention and thus strengthens the case against it.

Max Fisher points out that half of Americans can’t identify Syria on a map:

[B]eing able to correctly identify Syria on a map obviously does not preclude an individual from expressing strong views about the country or what Obama should do about it. But it does add a bit more credence to the perception that Syria is not exactly at the center of America’s national attention right now. And that in turn might make some sort of assertive and potentially risky U.S.-led military action in Syria, whatever its merits or downsides, a bit less likely.

What’s striking to me is that even McCain and Butters are reluctant to send in troops. And I agree with Walt that the methods of mass extermination are a little irrelevant to the corpses. Still, the fundamental fear is the following: that intervention is insane; but that letting this conflict run its course could lead to chemical weapons being used by the al Nusri brigade, the major Islamist force now swearing allegiance to al Qaeda. For a chilling update, check out this report in the Telegraph.

The size of the chemical arsenal is perhaps the fourth in the world, hidden all over the country now teetering out of the dictator’s control. Air-strikes would be unlikely to work:

“Airstrikes aren’t reliable because they can just release all the chemical agents into the air,” [Dina Esfandiary, an expert on Syria’s WMD programme with the International Institute for Strategic Studies, the London-based defence and security think-tank] said. “Alternatively, they only do half the job and then render a secure site open to looters.”

Nor, she added, would quick-fire raids by small teams of special forces be an alternative. “You would have to first secure the sites and then do a careful analysis of what was there, followed by controlled explosions. It is, frankly, a labour intensive job, and that is why the Pentagon assessed it as requiring 75,000 men. “Besides, there may be any number of caches hidden all over the place, and even if you could look for them properly – which is difficult with a civil war going on – you would run the risk of some being left behind.”

Recall that the entire rationale for the invasion of Iraq was to prevent chemical, biological or nuclear elements getting into the hands of al Qaeda. Those WMDs did not exist; but Assad’s do. And on a subway train in New York or London, just a small attack could wreak panic and havoc and death on a large scale.

Recent Dish on Syria’s chemical weapons here.

(Photo: A picture taken on April 26, 2013 shows a plastic bottle, coal, cotton, gauze, cola, and cardboard that are used by members of the al-Ezz bin Abdul Salam brigade to assemble homemade gas-masks for protection against chemical weapons, in Syria’s northern Latakia province. By Miguel Medina/AFP/Getty Images)

Quote For The Day

Islamic Society Holds Vigil For Marathon Bombing Victims

“By now we know well the opposing worldviews that characterize our struggle with extremists.  The latter promote the cult of death, whereas we—the mainstream—promote the theology of life.  They believe that only they know the will of God, which they can impose on people, whereas we believe that the will of God is represented by the will of the people.  They believe Sharia is limited to draconian punishments to terrorize people, whereas we believe Sharia is the path to God—one defined by different groups that adhere to justice, mercy and compassion.  They believe grievances are irreversible facts that should be fuel for political violence, whereas we believe grievances can be redressed non-violently, and in partnership with others who, like us, respect human dignity.  They believe that recruiting young people to serve as their warriors will be their unending revitalization, whereas we believe that the mission of Islam is entrusting Muslim youth to be ambassadors of good will and future leaders,” – Salam al-Marayati.

The struggle of our time is not between religions so much as within them. The battle is between fundamentalist certainty and religious humility; between those who see divine truth and seek to live by it, and those who think they see divine truth and want to impose it on others; it is between Islam and Jihadism, between Christianity and Christianism, between the humane ethics of Judaism and the extremist bigotry of many West Bank Settlers. Until these internal struggles are resolved, the external dangers will endure.

(Photo: A crowd gathered during a vigil for the marathon bombing victims held at the Islamic Society of Boston Cultural Center in Boston. By Aram Boghosian for The Boston Globe via Getty Images.)

Ask Dreher Anything: Cancer As A Part Of God’s Plan

Rod explains how he reconciles his faith with the illness that took his sister’s life:

Be sure to check out his new book, The Little Way of Ruthie Leming: A Southern Girl, a Small Town, and the Secret of a Good Life:

[The book follows Rod] back to his hometown of St. Francisville, Louisiana (pop. 1,700) in the wake of his younger sister Ruthie’s death. When she was diagnosed at age 40 with a virulent form of cancer in 2010, Dreher was moved by the way the community he had left behind rallied around his dying sister, a schoolteacher. He was also struck by the grace and courage with which his sister dealt with the disease that eventually took her life. In Louisiana for Ruthie’s funeral in the fall of 2011, Dreher began to wonder whether the ordinary life Ruthie led in their country town was in fact a path of hidden grandeur, even spiritual greatness, concealed within the modest life of a mother and teacher. In order to explore this revelation, Dreher and his wife decided to leave Philadelphia, move home to help with family responsibilities and have their three children grow up amidst the rituals that had defined his family for five generations – Mardi Gras, L.S.U. football games, and deer hunting.

The rest of Rod’s videos are here. Full AA archive here.

The Resilient American Upper Class

They get their success the old fashioned way:

Tufts economist Linda Loury suggests that half of all jobs in the U.S. are found through family, friends, or acquaintances.

Canadian economists Miles Corak and Patrizio Piraino look at how often men end up working at the same company where their father worked, finding that as many as 40 percent have done that at some point. The proportion rises to 70 percent among the top 1 percent in income distribution. This helps to explain why the relationship between the earnings of parent and child is even higher at the top end than it is across the population at large, according to Corak. One-third of successions between chief executive officers in publicly listed companies in the U.S. involves an incoming CEO related by blood or marriage to the old CEO, the founder, or a large shareholder. That’s bad news for the share price, according to Francisco Perez-Gonzalez of the NBER, but clearly good news for the newly appointed relative.

Misha Not So Mucha

The ginger Svengali alleged to be the mastermind of Tamerlan Tsarnaev’s conversion to Internet Islam … seems pretty harmless in this NYRB report. But read the comments as well as the short piece. Update from a reader:

It’s funny that you should note the comments on the NYRB article – Catherine Fitzpatrick is a well known “eccentric” in the Russia-watching circles. (And by eccentric I mean nutty and conspiratorial.)

Another:

Long-time reader, early subscriber here. I write to register how offended I was that you would highlight on your blog an ad hominem attack on Catherine Fitzpatrick. (Full disclosure: I knew her in NY in the ’70s and ’80s, but have not been in touch since.) She’s a long-time human rights activist on Russian and Eastern European fronts. In her work with Aryeh Neier at Helsinki Watch in the 1980s she defended, sometimes with distinct personal bravery, more dissidents than you and I ever will. She is a very well-known scholar of Soviet/Russian affairs, and her Russian fluency is so superb that she was a translator of many major books in the 1990s (including Yeltsin’s autobiography). She was an “early adopter” of all things Internet. (Her association with Second Life led, by my reading, to the controversy that led your reader to call her “nutty.”) In short, political perspectives aside, she and you (and I) have a lot in common.

Yglesias Award Nominee

“Sarah Palin is an example of what can happen when a person is consumed by bitterness and grievances. It has a corrosive effect, and over the last several years she has, if anything, become even more brittle and embittered. From a human standpoint it’s a shame. And from a political standpoint it’s precisely the countenance and bearing conservatism and the GOP need to avoid,” – Pete Wehner on Palin’s latest phony outrage at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner, something she eagerly attended not so long ago (because there was a terrifying moment when I nearly ran into her).

No, I didn’t go this year. No media entity wanted me to; and the Dish has no White House correspondent, unless you call me one, and we’d rather spend our money on, well, journalism.

Ending The Gay Ban One Troop At A Time

The Boy Scouts of America recently announced that it plans to end its ban on gay Scouts but keep the ban on gay troop leaders. EJ Graff suggests an alternative:

Instead of accepting the gay-okay-till-21 recommendation, here’s my hope: that the Scout assembly at large will instead find a way to move forward on the earlier trial-balloon policy. A few months back, the Scouts let out the suggestion that perhaps each troop could decide its policy on gay members and leaders for itself. That was, I thought, a brilliant compromise, a kind of federalism that would allow each troop to remain in sync with its community’s attitudes.

Such a policy would make it possible for individuals locally to lobby and educate their neighbors and friends. Mormon-sponsored troops could live by their own strictures, while the Unitarians or some other group could independently sponsor a gay-welcoming troop across town. That policy would allow the Scouts’ ban to fade slowly, along with antigay attitudes, until they were ready to flush it away as an embarrassment. In the meantime, yes, individual gay kids would be marooned in hostile troops as they realize that they might be, you know, like that—but no matter the policy, you know that those troops (and the families that are putting their kids in them) are not yet going to be welcoming, no matter what the Scouts’ official policy might be.

Meditation As Self-Defense

Sam Harris, a practitioner of meditation and Brazilian jiu-jitsu, connects the two:

Almost all our suffering is the product of our thoughts. We spend nearly every moment of our lives lost in thought, and hostage to the character of those thoughts. You can break this spell, but it takes training just like it takes training to defend yourself against a physical assault. You are thinking every moment and not aware of it, and the initial experience of anyone who seriously tries to meditate is one of discovering how incessant this cascade of thoughts is.

Graeme Wood sparred with Sam:

Harris likened training with an expert fighter to “falling into deep water without knowing how to swim.” He sees BJJ as a cycle of mock death and resurrection, wherein an expert may kill you many times per session. “To train in BJJ is to continually drown—or, rather, to be drowned, in sudden and ingenious ways—and to be taught, again and again, how to swim.”

Having read all this, I asked Harris to drown me.

I am several inches taller and several pounds stockier than Harris, who is 5 foot 9 and weighs 165 pounds, and I am undefeated in single combat—though only because I have never been in a fight and flee anytime I see anyone who looks even vaguely threatening. …

I soon found myself in what BJJ practitioners call a “rear naked choke,” which, while less alarming than it sounds, is lethal if applied unmercifully. At one point, I resisted by pushing my jaw between Harris’s elbow and my throat. That didn’t help. “He can choke your whole jaw into your throat,” [instructor Ryron Gracie] said. “It affects the carotid—through the jaw!” He said this with an air of Isn’t that cool? Later, once Harris had let me go, I had to agree: Yes, very cool.