Jim Haynes: Best Case Scenario

Marty Lederman pores over the evidence:

If Haynes casually concluded, without explanation, and in the midst of a torrent of military lawyers telling him that the conduct would be illegal, that the techniques did not violate any of those legal restrictions, even though many of those techniques plainly do violate some of those legal restrictions, and where few, if any, of the techniques is "humane" — well, in that case, William Haynes is the least responsible and least competent attorney in the history of the Executive Branch.

And yet that is the account to which Haynes testified yesterday.

Boosting Moderate Islam

Steven Cook doesn’t think it’s a good idea:

A smarter position is to avoid theological discussions altogether. As with all faiths, there will be heated debates between competing groups within Islam over the proper interpretation of sacred texts and the relationship between religion and politics. Yet because these arguments are so opaque to outsiders, policymakers should resist the urge to jump in. Given that moderation is in the eye of the beholder, Washington should not have an ideological litmus test for whom it wishes to engage. Rather, policymakers should focus on identifying those who can contribute pragmatic solutions to the many problems we confront in the region, “moderate” or not.

Surge Update

Abe Greenwald:

"Seven of the 18 benchmarks relate to Iraq’s national security. We can just about put a check next to each one. We can even look at some of those and marvel at the low expectations behind them. Number 9, for example: "Providing three trained and ready Iraqi brigades to support Baghdad operations." There are far more than three battle-ready brigades in Baghdad. The galvanization of Sunni Awakening groups who have wrested their country back from al-Qaeda and the decisive efforts of Iraqi forces in Basra and Sadr City have been the two most vital developments of the entire post-Saddam period."

Point taken. Can we leave now?

The Joys Of Euro-Soccer

A great little free-associative blog-post on the continent’s favorite sport and the questions it raises:

What else could have us feeling sorry for Switzerland and cheering for Austria? Isn’t Europe a more harmonious entity without the English? Would Brussels be paralysed by protests today if Belgium had qualified? And would Ireland have voted No if they were in the tournament?

Part of the fun of football is the way in which it overturns the international order of power politics. The US, Russia and China can be expected to top the medal charts in the Olympics, as usual, but Croatia had already triumphed over two of the Great Powers – England and Russia – in qualifying before beating Austria and Germany last week. Up next: Turkey, the former Ottoman Empire. Most of Europe got a, er, kick out of Croatia’s victory over Germany last week, in what everyone was too polite to call the Group of the Third Reich. We could all feel sorry for Poland once again as Germany beat them with two goals from a player born in Poland, Lukas Podolski.