Boerne, Texas, 7 am.
The Shame Of Gitmo
Another serious study finds appalling injustice and mistreatment:
An eight-month McClatchy investigation in 11 countries on three continents has found that Akhtiar was one of dozens of men — and, according to several officials, perhaps hundreds — whom the U.S. has wrongfully imprisoned in Afghanistan, Cuba and elsewhere on the basis of flimsy or fabricated evidence, old personal scores or bounty payments. McClatchy interviewed 66 released detainees, more than a dozen local officials — primarily in Afghanistan — and U.S. officials with intimate knowledge of the detention program. The investigation also reviewed thousands of pages of U.S. military tribunal documents and other records. This unprecedented compilation shows that most of the 66 were low-level Taliban grunts, innocent Afghan villagers or ordinary criminals.
At least seven had been working for the U.S.-backed Afghan government and had no ties to militants, according to Afghan local officials.
In effect, many of the detainees posed no danger to the United States or its allies. The investigation also found that despite the uncertainty about whom they were holding, U.S. soldiers beat and abused many prisoners. Prisoner mistreatment became a regular feature in cellblocks and interrogation rooms at Bagram and Kandahar air bases, the two main way stations in Afghanistan en route to Guantanamo.
Every fair observer of the detention and interrogation of the Gitmo inmates comes to the same conclusion. It needs to be closed down. And the stain will endure for a very long time.
HRC Busted
This blog has long described the useless organization called the Human Rights Campaign as a tool of the Hillary Clinton campaign. But the scale of the group’s enmeshment with the Clintons is revealed by Michael Petrelis’s research into the campaign contributions of all its major figures. The final tally? Drum roll:
Hillary Clinton: $4,300
Chris Dodd: $3,000
John Edwards: $ 750
Bill Richardson: $ 500
Barack Obama: $ 0
In the end, they couldn’t even fake it. When Obama got the nomination, the news of HRC’s endorsement was made on the HRC website by a college intern! The trouble, of course, is that the fusion of gay rights with the Clinton machine – fatal to gay equality in the 1990s – has not exactly given the lobbying group much cachet with the next potential Democratic president.
Meanwhile, Solmonese’s record on Capitol Hill is, despite his breathless promises a while back, non-existent.
They still haven’t passed their hate crimes bill; the employment non-discrimination bill is still in limbo (they were insisting it should be the priority over marriage and the military two decades ago!), Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell still stands, and HRC didn’t even ask the presidential candidates what their position was on the HIV immigration and tourism ban on their election questionnaire. One reason the US still has the same HIV immigration and tourism policies as Saudi Arabia and Yemen is because the US chief gay lobby group is more interested in selling tchotchkes than standing up for gay people or people with HIV.
But fear not: they have persuaded Christian Siriano to design a "fierce, fabulous, flawless" t-shirt for the summer. This is what the suckers still give them money for.
Face Of The Day
White House Press Secretary Dana Perino is blasted by wind from Marine One as US President George W. Bush and his wife, First Lady Laura Bush leave Windsor Castle after visiting Britain’s Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh in Windsor, Berkshire, west of London, on June 15, 2008. By Saul Loeb/AFP/Getty.
Benedict, John Paul II, And Child Abuse
If you want to know how the current Pope handled very credible, very well-documented and overwhelming evidence that a very powerful associate had long been a child-abuser, check this clip out: The abuse-case that caused the Pope to lose his temper – to the point of a prissy smack – was Father Marcial Maciel. Until his death earlier this year, Maciel ran a large, far-right Catholic cult called the Legionaries of Christ. The Legionaries and their lay counterpart, Regnum Christi, are very powerful entities in the new Catholicism, given special protection by Pope John Paul II and much favor under his successor. And at the core of the Legionaries, like many religious cults, was a sexual abuse ring designed to please the founder. Secrecy was maintained by indoctrinating many members at a young age, and enforcing vows of silence on all topics related to Maciel. This cult-like stricture is still causing grief and suspicion in many parts of the Catholic world, most recently in the Baltimore archdiocese.
The reason I bring this up today is because journalist Jason Berry, of the Hartford Courant, has a new and gripping documentary on Maciel and the abusive cult-like practices he pioneered. It’s called "Vows Of Silence" and it carefully exposes the appalling facts of the enmeshment of the last two Popes in covering up sexual abuse and protecting a serial predator. Maciel was a sadly twisted gay man, who committed many acts of abuse, pederasty and pedophilia against other men and boys under his control. He is also a hero to the theoconservative movement, the leaders of which have yet to come to terms with his appalling record.
Much of this the Vatican eventually conceded – but never held Maciel fully accountable for, part from asking him in his final years to recede from public view. More to the point: Maciel’s abuse was known to Pope John Paul II and Pope Benedict XVI for years, and they did nothing about it. The Maciel case is important because it reveals the current and former Pope to be knowing, conscious protectors of a child abuser and shows how the sick sexual dysfunction at the heart of the Catholic hierarchy was abetted and fomented at the very, very top. Here’s the movie trailer. I watched the film the other night and even after following this issue for years, was shocked at the gravity and specificity of the charges. The theocons still deny Maciel’s guilt, of course. But many of them have long stopped valuing truth over power.
What Obama Brings
If you had to sum it up, it would be an ability to listen – genuinely listen – to the best arguments of his opponents:
Not so long ago, the phone rang in my office. It was Barack Obama. For more than a decade, Obama was my colleague at the University of Chicago Law School.
He is also a friend. But since his election to the Senate, he does not exactly call every day. On this occasion, he had an important topic to discuss: the controversy over President George W.
Bush’s warrantless surveillance of international telephone calls between Americans and suspected terrorists. I had written a short essay suggesting that the surveillance might be lawful. Before taking a public position, Obama wanted to talk the problem through. In the space of about 20 minutes, he and I investigated the legal details. He asked me to explore all sorts of issues: the President’s power as commander-in-chief, the Constitution’s protection against unreasonable searches and seizures, the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, the Authorization for Use of Military Force and more.
Obama wanted to consider the best possible defense of what Bush had done. To every argument I made, he listened carefully and offered a specific counter-argument. After the issue had been exhausted, Obama said that he thought the program was illegal, but now had a better understanding of both sides. He thanked me for my time.
This was a pretty amazing conversation, not only because of Obama’s mastery of the legal details, but also because many prominent Democratic leaders had already blasted the Bush initiative as blatantly illegal.
He did not want to take a public position until he had listened to, and explored, what might be said on the other side. This is the Barack Obama I have known for nearly 15 years–a careful and even-handed analyst of law and policy, unusually attentive to multiple points of view. The University of Chicago Law School is by far the most conservative of the great American law schools. It helped to provide the academic foundations for many positions of the Reagan administration. But at the University of Chicago, Obama is liked and admired by Republicans and Democrats alike. Some of the local Reagan enthusiasts are Obama supporters. Why? It doesn’t hurt that he’s a great guy, with a personal touch and a lot of warmth. It certainly helps that he is exceptionally able. But niceness and ability are only a small part of the story. Obama also has a genuinely independent mind, he’s a terrific listener and he goes wherever reason takes him.
A skeptic would nonetheless note that Sunstein did not change Obama’s mind – no more than Obama’s ability to see the appeal of Justice Roberts did not prevent him from voting against. I stand by what I saw over a year ago: the man is a liberal, but one of the most intelligent and reasoned in a very long time. In my view, he has the potential to provoke as reasoned a conservatism in response. Just not quite yet.
Marijuana (0)
Just a glimpse into the literal insanity of keeping marijuana illegal:
The Florida report analyzed 168,900 deaths statewide. Cocaine, heroin and all methamphetamines caused 989 deaths, it found, while legal opioids — strong painkillers in brand-name drugs like Vicodin and OxyContin — caused 2,328. Drugs with benzodiazepine, mainly depressants like Valium and Xanax, led to 743 deaths.
Alcohol was the most commonly occurring drug, appearing in the bodies of 4,179 of the dead and judged the cause of death of 466 — fewer than cocaine (843) but more than methamphetamine (25) and marijuana (0).
In the drug war, rationality and the law are at odds.
Clitoris Envy
Time to get some, guys:
By imaging the pelvises of healthy humans – rather than dissecting dead ones – [an Australian urologist, Dr Helen O’Connell] has found that the live clitoris is even larger than she first thought.
"There’s nothing quite like the shape of a clitoris," she said. "The glans are dense with nerve endings and receptors – all the vibration and sensation is there." The bulk of it is shaped like a pyramid, she said.
Its base forms the external genitalia or vulva; its triangular "walls" are wrapped around the urine-carrying tube known as the urethra and the vagina. When aroused, the whole structure becomes engorged.
Just thought that it was about time a gay male blogger kept you up to date on these things.
A Huckabee Veep Gamble?
Ross on Huckabee as a McCain veep:
A McCain-Huckabee ticket, then, would make sense only if McCain were running a very different sort of campaign–if he were in the mood to blow up the GOP in the name of "creative destruction," as his neo-conservative admirers famously urged him to do back in 2000, rather than betting that he can hold the fracturing, feuding Reagan coalition together long enough to achieve one last victory. Picking Huckabee would represent a gamble that the future of the party lies with some odd amalgam of right-wing heterodoxies; that many of the movement-conservative institutions that served the GOP during its rise to power need to be attacked, rather than reformed; and that the best way to push the Republican Party beyond its current impasse would be to run a ramshackle, ideologically confusing, shoot-from-the-hip campaign and hope it turned out OK in the end.
Matt’s related thoughts:
McCain needs to choose between playing it safe and piloting himself to landing at 47 percent of the vote, or doing some outside-the-box that risks blowing up his coalition and leaving him with only 40 percent but also provides an outside chance that the gamble will pay off. The rational choice is for McCain to play to win. But his problem is that his campaign is going to be run by professional political operatives. If these guys run a respectable campaign and lose at 47, nobody’s going to blame them — McCain was facing an ultra-charismatic opponent in an adverse political climate. But if they run an outside-the-box campaign and wind up losing in a landslide, then their reputations might be badly hurt.
Obama’s Father’s Day Sermon
Text here. Youtube – somewhat different – below. His anger at the beginning only comes across when you watch it:
A reader writes:
The first time I saw Barack Obama speak was at the Apostolic Church of God on 63rd and Dorchester in the spring of 2004, and it was virtually the same speech that the senator gave today (might have been Father’s Day then as well; don’t recall).
It was the best speech I’d ever heard, and it was no less impressive because he gave it from perhaps two or three 3×5 note cards tucked in his breast pocket. Anyway, shortly after that (as my apocryphal tale would have it) I told my parents that Mr. Obama would certainly be president one day. I didn’t believe it would be so soon, of course. It was the directive to action, the appeal to personal responsibility, and the eminently conservative call to lift up one’s own children. Great leaders ask for sacrifice.
I love that speech.
We’re lucky to have this guy at this point in history – black and white. Really lucky.



