Dissent Of The Day, Ctd.

A reader writes:

The discussion on your site about occupation seems, to me, to miss the point.  "Occupation" is a precise term under international law.  It is clearly defined and has strict parameters that are based on Article 42 of the 1907 Hague Regulations.  The International Committee of the Red Cross has a good FAQ page on what is an occupation here.  And you can find a pretty good overall analysis of the issue as it applies to Iraq here.

The most relevant point is when an occupation comes to an end (from the ICRC FAQ page):

The normal way for an occupation to end is for the occupying power to withdraw from the occupied territory or be driven out of it. However, the continued presence of foreign troops does not necessarily mean that occupation continues.

A transfer of authority to a local government re-establishing the full and free exercise of sovereignty will normally end the state of occupation, if the government agrees to the continued presence of foreign troops on its territory. However, the law of occupation may become applicable again if the situation on the ground changes, that is to say, if the territory again becomes "actually placed under the authority of the hostile army" (H R, art. 42) – in other words, under the control of foreign troops without the consent of the local authorities.

If we follow these guidelines, then the United States was an occupying power during the Coalition Provisional Authority period, but ceased to be so when a "local government re-establishing the full and free exercise of sovereignty" came into existence.  We can debate whether the Maliki government actually exercises its sovereignty fully and freely, but given the fact that the UN Security Council recognized a formal end to the occupation as of 30 June 2004, "occupation" is the wrong word here.

To be clear, I oppose the war and would like the troops to come home soon.  I also think that the growing opposition in Iraq to the Status of Forces Agreement represents the strongest possible evidence that the Iraqis want us to leave, and that we should take the hint sooner rather than later.  But it’s important that we use terms precisely, and "occupation" as defined in international law just doesn’t fit.

The Sixth Country

Norway has just granted same-sex couples the right to marry. And their version of domestic partnerships is abolished (although those who signed up for them can keep them if they so wish). Next week, California – only marginally smaller in population than Spain and South Africa – will join the list. Added to Massachusetts, more gay people will be able to marry in the US than in any other country in the world. In the end, America still came through as the pioneer of full equality.

Max Boot Worries

What if the Iraqis believe they can run their own country? This nightmare scenario for the neocons requires a fierce pivot away from recent claims of success in Iraq:

With Iraqi troops performing better recently in Basra, Sadr City and Mosul, Prime Minister Nouri Maliki may be starting to think that he doesn’t need the Americans after all. Maybe the Iraqis are ready to go it alone. The U.S. high command inadvertently has encouraged this illusion by stressing Iraqi contributions in its public pronouncements while downplaying the role Americans still play. In reality, while Iraqi troops are becoming much more capable, they still rely on U.S. assistance for key "enablers" such as logistics, surveillance, communications and air support. Without that help, which is coordinated by U.S. advisors embedded with Iraqi units, Iraqi security forces — no matter how brave and dedicated — would be hard put to operate successfully against such hardened terrorists as Al Qaeda and the extremist Shiite factions known as "special groups." American troops also serve a vital function as a buffer between sectarian groups still suspicious of one another.

So we are reaching a point at which the Iraqis may decide to pre-empt Bush and ask us to leave. If they do it while thanking us for the success, things could get very awkward for those trying to set up a permanent neo-empire in the Arab Middle East.

The Life Of A Hack

Keith Gessen discusses its travails:

Journalism’s pitfalls are well known. Bad magazines vulgarize your ideas and literally spray your pages with cologne. Good magazines are even worse: they do style editing, copyediting, query editing, bullet-proofing—and as you emerge from the subway with your trash bag of books (a burnt offering to the fact-checker), you suddenly realize that you have landed a $6-an-hour job, featuring heavy lifting.

Yet the biggest pitfall of journalism is not penury but vanity. Your name is in print; it is even, perhaps, in print in the most august possible venue. But you are still serving someone else’s idea of their readership—and their idea of you. You are still just doing journalism—or, worse, book reviewing. "What lice will do, when they have no more blood to suck," as the 19th century put it.

Hence I blog. It really is quite liberating.

Regrets

Bush talks to the The Times of London:

In an exclusive interview, he expressed regret at the bitter divisions over the war and said that he was troubled about how his country had been misunderstood. “I think that in retrospect I could have used a different tone, a different rhetoric.”

Phrases such as “bring them on” or “dead or alive”, he said, “indicated to people that I was, you know, not a man of peace”.

Ya think? Now how about: "We Do Not Torture". Care to revise your remarks after all the evidence has proven you a liar?