1.3 million Americans don’t make a living off eBay. Oh: and Iran is not training al Qaeda.
Bush Lied? Ctd
Matt tackles the question:
…the war sales pitch was deeply dishonest. No fair-minded person could possibly deny that the overall effect of the way the administration talked about Iraq was designed to get people to believe that there was a short-term threat that Saddam Hussein would transfer a nuclear weapon to al-Qaeda for use against the United States of America. It’s equally clear that this was not supported by the evidence. But more to the point, it’s perfectly clear that the whole pitch was made in bad faith. The administration had a different, more nuanced and more medium-term set of concerns about Iraq. It believed that preventive war was the best way to deal with those concerns. And it also believed, correctly I think, that the public would not support an action of pure "anticipatory self-defense." Thus they took bits and pieces of real intelligence plus some very flimsy stuff plus some made up stuff plus some rhetorical excess and they weaved their dishonest tapestry.
Yes: but this captures the complexity of it. I bought both parts of this argument, and feel duped about one and utopian about the other. Maybe it’s better to think of the Bush administration as having acted in broad good faith, with a critical piece of bad faith at its center.
Their problem with the bad faith part was that it was subject to empirical refutation. I think they never believed it could be – there would be some remnants of WMDs, they thought, even if the scale of the effort they were describing was phony. And, boy, were they wrong. In retrospect, I think the bad faith seriously tainted the good. And, more than anything except torture, delegitimized the entire project.
And what made it even more nauseating was that no one really took full responsibility, least of all the president. The man made a joke about missing WMDs, for goodness’ sake. And most neocons seems incapable of self-criticism or even much self-awareness.
Hewitt Award Nominee
"We are entitled therefore to ask whether the Muslim world supports him because it believes he is still a Muslim. We are entitled to ask precisely when he stopped being a Muslim, and why. Another of Obama’s former classmates, Emirsyah Satar, now CEO of Garuda Indonesia, has been quoted as saying:
At that time, he was quite religious in Islam but after marrying Michelle, he changed his religion.
Did Obama embrace Christianity as a tactical manoeuvre to get himself elected? Why indeed has he dissembled about his family background if not for that end?" – Melanie Phillips. What on earth happened to her?
The View From Your Window
Tallying The GI Bill
The Numbers Guy crunches the numbers:
Opponents of the bill, including Sen. McCain, have said they oppose it because the sweetened benefits package — including an average tuition assistance of $1,700 per month — would induce more soldiers to leave active duty for university. To back this argument, they’ve cited a Congressional Budget Office study estimating that the bill would reduce retention rates by 16%, from a current rate of 42% to 36%.
But there are a lot of caveats attached to the 16% figure.
It’s hard to predict what today’s soldiers from all branches will do using numbers about their predecessors, mostly in peacetime, and only in the Army. It’s balanced somewhat by an expected increase in recruitment thanks to the allure of the benefits to undecided would-be soldiers. And the CBO estimates that the military could adjust spending elsewhere, such as on re-enlistment bonuses and advertising, to even out the expected changes in retention and recruitment…
…The 16% decrease in retention could be counteracted by spending $6.7 billion between 2009 and 2013 to boost re-enlistment bonuses. Meanwhile, the 16% increase in recruitment could be negated by saving $5.6 billion on advertising, enlistment bonuses and other measures. These numbers, too, are extrapolated from earlier studies, but they suggest that maintaining the current force structure could be achieved with an increase in spending of $1.1 billion over five years — compared with the direct cost of the benefits, about $52 billion.
Who’s The Known Quantity?
A reader writes:
Joyner says McCain is the more known commodity and Obama the lesser known, echoing a common theme among political insiders. Even the McCain campaign believes it to be true. To anyone outside the Washington bubble, though, this idea is total nonsense.
Over the past year, while McCain and the Republicans have sat on their hands and helplessly watched, Barack Obama has become an absolute pop culture and media sensation. America is literally obsessed with him. He’s a celebrity candidate who became a celebrity by running for president; he’s been discussed, debated, and argued over on television, in newspapers, in political magazines, in gossip magazines, on the internet, among every age group, every demographic, every race, and in every subset of American life. It’s easy to forget this when you’re refreshing Drudge and Halperin every two minutes as us junkies are wont to do, but when it comes to the non-political media, Barack Obama is a superstar, while McCain is a nonentity. He is barely even mentioned.
McCain had his chance to seize the narrative with both hands during the waning months of the Democratic primary. He failed. Thanks to HIllary’s campaign, Obama is as defined as he can be in the public consciousness, almost as much as Hillary and Bill Clinton at this point. Most primary campaigns fly under the radar, but this primary campaign was rated by Entertainment Weekly as the surprise TV hit of the season. What’s more, Hillary and Barack campaigned aggressively in all 50 states. McCain campaigned in about 10.
On top of all this, Obama has the lopsided money advantage, the lopsided enthusiasm advantage, the lopsided technology advantage, the lopsided earned media advantage, the lopsided paid media advantage, the lopsided volunteer and voter registration advantage, the lopsided issue advantage, the lopsided party advantage, and the lopsided ground army advantage. It’s too late for John McCain to "define" Barack Obama. That ship has sailed. In fact, it’s Obama who is very quickly defining McCain. Political insiders who have "known" John McCain since 2000 forget that the vast majority of voters have a very hazy memory of that primary election, if they have any at all. In fact, I’d guess that most voters have two impressions of John McCain: that he is old, and that he is a full-throated supporter of the Iraq war. And nothing he has done so far in the campaign has remotely challenged those impressions.
Quote For The Day
"When I say your whiteness is showing this is what I mean: You claim that your opposition to Obama is an act of gender solidarity, in that women (and their male allies) need to stand up for women in the face of the sexist mistreatment of Clinton by the press. On this latter point–the one about the importance of standing up to the media for its often venal misogyny–you couldn’t be more correct. As the father of two young girls who will have to contend with the poison of patriarchy all their lives, or at least until such time as that system of oppression is eradicated, I will be the first to join the boycott of, or demonstration on, whatever media outlet you choose to make that point. But on the first part of the above equation–the part where you insist voting against Obama is about gender solidarity–you are, for lack of a better way to put it, completely full of crap. And what’s worse is that at some level I suspect you know it. Voting against Senator Obama is not about gender solidarity. It is an act of white racial bonding, and it is grotesque," – Tim Wise on the Hillary holdouts.
Wolcott On ‘Rhoid Rage
He’s a pleasure to read most of the time – Mickey’s crankiness, Derb’s dyspepsia and a whiff of Amis’s so-bad-it’s-good prose. Here he is on the strange decline of naughty American literature:
Under Tina Brown’s editorship of The New Yorker, our homegrown literati were still capable of producing their own candid, high-toned, hot-pants hoo-ha, from Daphne Merkin’s spank-me essay to Alison Rose’s elliptical, first-person account of office adulteries (her cubicle was hopping). Now look at the magazine: a dry hole where the pilgrims gather. The latest double issue, its Summer Fiction issue, features a meditation on God and suffering by James Wood and a sextet of brief testimonials on the theme of "Faith & Doubt." "I enjoyed singing carols," contributes novelist Allegra Goodman. "I sat through Shabbat services making up my own stories about Laura Ingalls Wilder to add to the adventures in her books." Sweet Moses, is this what it’s come to? If The New Yorker persists in exhibiting spiritual growth, I foresee even further opportunistic expansion of Grade A European smut into our mind-space, which can’t be what the Founding Fathers and Gore Vidal intended.
The Obama Effect Within
Terry Michael predicts the end of identity politics:
…perhaps most important to libertarians, his election will put the Jesse Jacksons, the Al Sharptons, and the white identity politics liberals out of business. No longer will they be able to peddle victimology or mau-mau their way through the political landscape, demanding diversity training, minority contracts, or other tribal reparations from bigots they find behind every bush. The myth of unassimilable “minorities” dies when a majority white nation selects a leader “of color,” just as religious social distance was diminished when a majority Protestant country chose a Catholic a half-century before.
Stepping Up To The Barr?
A reader channels some of my own thoughts on the general election:
In similar fashion to you, I’m a moderate, libertarian-wing conservative. And while I like to think of myself as practical, I also consider my politics to be informed by political theory and philosophy. Like you, I am attracted to Obama’s temperament, but somewhat uncomfortable with his liberalism. Like you, I don’t see enough of my own conservatism in McCain to get super-excited, although I am happy to have him as the head of the GOP, given the alternatives that looked possible six months ago. But mostly, I firmly believe that the GOP needs to be punished for the last eight years. It seems to me that the most satisfactory meta-outcome for me in this election would be a strong rebuke to the GOP coupled with an endorsement of Obama’s style, but not necessarily his substance.Enter Barr as third-party spoiler. Isn’t he perfect for the above-stated purpose?
If Obama were to win the Presidency, but under conditions in which McCain would have won without Barr drawing off conservative votes, isn’t that the best of both worlds? It’s a rejection of the collectivist strands of Obama liberalism, it’s a rebuke of the current GOP, a tacit endorsement of Obama’s approach to politics and it’s a signal that the balance of power for both parties is held by a small but sizable libertarian impulse in American politics.
I cannot think of anything I’d rather see happen in November. I seriously hope you consider giving this sort of reasoning more airtime.
Will do. I’m still adjusting to post-Clinton life.
