Dissent Of The Day

A reader writes:

Is it accurate to use the term "occupiers" – if it is meant in a colonial sense – when the Iraqis have the power to and may well reject long term basing of US forces? Do bilateral and multilateral defense agreements (such as with Korea, Japan, etc.) negate use of the term "occupier"? Assuming the positive trajectory in Iraq continues, is it not now possible that a Shiite-led and nationalist Iraqi government may realize strategic advantage in the long term basing of US army and air forces as a defense against Iran? Wouldn’t that strategic basing – based upon a bilateral agreement – be of enormous strategic benefit to Iraq, the region and ironically Israel?

Wouldn’t the arrangement be of enormous strategic disadvantage to Iran and Syria?

Wouldn’t the continued presence of US support forces and trainers continuing to sustain what is emerging as the finest Arab army in the mid-east be of enormous strategic advantage vis-a-vis Iran, Syria and Sunni radicalism?

There will have to be a sustained US presence with the Iraq army for reasons of military logistics and training – shouldn’t that presence work to the advantage of Iraq and the US?

All good questions. When a country is invaded, when the foreign power’s troops are in every city and region, and when the occupying army demands 58 permanent bases for the indefinite future, "occupation" seems a perfectly appropriate term. Of course, it does make a difference if the Iraqi government supports this – but when the Iraqi government is entirely dependent on the occupying forces to stay in power, then the actual sovereignty of that government is a little more suspect than most.

I can see the long-term strategic goals of a permanent military presence in Iraq. But it strikes me as an unwise intervention in the historic lands of Islam and a long-term source of anti-Western and anti-American resentment. It is a very radical expansion of America’s post-Cold War goals – and one that should be put to the American people. In the medium term an Iraq free of American troops should be the goal.

Where Crime Now Is

Hanna Rosin’s Atlantic piece on section 8 vouchers – and the suburbanization of violent crime – is well worth a read. It’s a case study in unintended consequences. Money quote:

In the most literal sense, the national effort to diffuse poverty has succeeded. Since 1990, the number of Americans living in neighborhoods of concentrated poverty—meaning that at least 40 percent of households are below the federal poverty level—has declined by 24 percent. But this doesn’t tell the whole story. Recently, the housing expert George Galster, of Wayne State University, analyzed the shifts in urban poverty and published his results in a paper called “A Cautionary Tale.” While fewer Americans live in high-poverty neighborhoods, increasing numbers now live in places with “moderate” poverty rates, meaning rates of 20 to 40 percent. This pattern is not necessarily better, either for poor people trying to break away from bad neighborhoods or for cities, Galster explains. His paper compares two scenarios: a city split into high-poverty and low-poverty areas, and a city dominated by median-poverty ones. The latter arrangement is likely to produce more bad neighborhoods and more total crime, he concludes, based on a computer model of how social dysfunction spreads.

Is Google Making Us Stupid?

Nicholas Carr’s cover story in the current Atlantic strikes close to home. Teaser:

For me, as for others, the Net is becoming a universal medium, the conduit for most of the information that flows through my eyes and ears and into my mind. The advantages of having immediate access to such an incredibly rich store of information are many, and they’ve been widely described and duly applauded. “The perfect recall of silicon memory,” Wired’s Clive Thompson has written, “can be an enormous boon to thinking.” But that boon comes at a price. As the media theorist Marshall McLuhan pointed out in the 1960s, media are not just passive channels of information. They supply the stuff of thought, but they also shape the process of thought. And what the Net seems to be doing is chipping away my capacity for concentration and contemplation. My mind now expects to take in information the way the Net distributes it: in a swiftly moving stream of particles. Once I was a scuba diver in the sea of words. Now I zip along the surface like a guy on a Jet Ski.

Pond-skater, pond-skater. And I wonder why I learned TM.

“The Old Lion”

Hitchens attacks Mandela for not speaking up about Zimbabwe:

By his silence about what is happening in Zimbabwe, Mandela is making himself complicit in the pillage and murder of an entire nation, as well as the strangulation of an important African democracy. I recently had the chance to speak to George Bizos, the heroic South African attorney who was Mandela’s lawyer in the bad old days and who more recently has also represented Morgan Tsvangirai, the much-persecuted leader of the Zimbabwean opposition. Why, I asked him, was his old comrade apparently toeing the scandalous line taken by President Thabo Mbeki and the African National Congress? Bizos gave me one answer that made me wince—that Mandela is now a very old man—and another that made me wince again: that his doctors have advised him to avoid anything stressful. One has a bit more respect for the old lion than to imagine that he doesn’t know what’s happening in next-door Zimbabwe or to believe that he doesn’t understand what a huge difference the smallest word from him would make. It will be something of a tragedy if he ends his career on a note of such squalid compromise.

Rigging The Vote

From Joshua Hammer’s dispatch on the situation in Zimbabwe:

At this writing, there seems little question that, without coordinated action by African leaders in neighboring countries, the chances of a fair second-round election are virtually nil. The Zimbabwe Electoral Support Network has been crippled by police raids and intimidation of its volunteers, and won’t be able to deploy many observers at Zimbabwe’s nine thousand polling stations. The New York Times reported that the regime has terrorized thousands of teachers, many of whom served as poll monitors and sided with the opposition during the first round. "The teachers are terrified," I was told by one Zimbabwean journalist.

"They helped to run these polling stations, and many had their houses burned down as a result." The army and police are expected to be deployed in far greater numbers than in March. And despite expressions of defiance, the huge displacements of population will make it difficult for the MDC to get out the vote. "People we’ve met in the hospitals have told us, ‘we’re not going to vote for people who beat us,’" I was told by a Zimbabwean journalist. "But the rural communities have been disrupted, and people may not be able to get to their polling stations."

Bush Lied, Ctd

A reader writes:

Forgive me, but I’m studying for the Bar Exam right now and I think this debate has provided me with a good review opportunity. In the criminal law, there are four classes of mens rea ("guilty mind") that can be used to justify the imposition of criminal sanctions: intent, knowledge, recklessness, and criminal negligence.

Intent requires the desire to act to bring about a foreseeable prohibited purpose; to be charitable (for this exercise), I think it can at least be argued that the President did not intend to provide the public with misleading information.  It would certainly be difficult to prove.

Knowledge requires awareness and practical certainty that the information he was providing was false. Easier, but still tough.

But it is almost impossible to contend that the President was not reckless (consciously disregarded the risk of error) or criminally negligent (grossly deviated from the care than a normal person would exercise) during the run up to war. So I guess the question of whether Bush lied turn on whether you think the "crime" of lying requires intent/knowledge to mislead, or simply recklessness/negligence with respect to the truth of the information.

Now, you could argue that disseminating incorrect information in such an important context is a strict liability offense, but I have to get back to the books…

Christianists and Bananas, Update

Inside_a_wildtype_banana

The dude conceded the point eventually, apparently. A reader adds:

The banana in question is a Cavendish Banana, which actually are asexual offshoots of larger, bulkier banana plants. These supermarket mutants bear little resemblance to their progenitor, the wild banana, which is a green oval-shaped thing full of large seeds and liquid (see above). The domestication of the wild banana began between 5000 and 8000 years ago, and only after thousands of years of farming and breeding (one can call that evolution if one wishes) did they even begin to slightly resemble their celebrated yellow hue, curved shape and ‘natural’ wrapper.

Christian apologetics has certainly deteriorated over the centuries. From Saint Thomas Aquinas and Rene Descartes with their long treatises to washed up child stars with poorly constructed ‘common sense’ appeals in only 800 years. The fruit, I suppose, has fallen far from the tree.

The comic strip Jesus and Mo deals with the issue here.