Province On Hold

Good news: Iraqis are balking at 58 permanent military bases for the US in their country:

"The points that were put forth by the Americans were more abominable than the occupation," said Jalal al Din al Saghir, a leading lawmaker from the Islamic Supreme Council of Iraq. "We were occupied by order of the Security Council," he said, referring to the 2004 Resolution mandating a U.S. military occupation in Iraq at the head of an international coalition. "But now we are being asked to sign for our own occupation. That is why we have absolutely refused all that we have seen so far."

Why good news? We have no business sitting around the Muslim Middle East for the rest of our lives. If the Iraqis are to become more independent and self-governing, removing an occupying army is a good start. A decision of this magnitude should not be made by an out-going administration regardless of the evolving views of the American people. Americans deserve to debate this as well as Iraqis. And then there’s the question of trusting a government that can come up with locutions like this one:

"The idea that the U.S. will have a normal, diplomatic and military presence, and need access to facilities — not necessarily our facilities, but need facilities — is permanent."

What is a normal military presence? And when did it become normal for one country to be stationing troops in the heart of another one?

How Liberal Is Obama’s Record?

Some appear to be interested in that question. One rigorous method – much more rigorous than National Journal’s annual grab-bag – proposes the following:

By this method, Obama is liberal, but not that liberal. He was the 21st most liberal senator in the 109th Congress and has been the 10th or 11th most liberal thus far in the 110th. The surprising result is John McCain, who rates as the 8th most conservative senator in the 110th Congress, the 2nd most conservative in the 109th, and the 5th or 6th most conservative in the 108th.

But much more moderate in the 107th.

Carter Clone

Jennifer Rubin on McCain comparing Obama to Carter:

The McCain camp wants and needs desperately to have a simple and easy tagline to conjure up bad thoughts about Obama in the way “Bush’s twin” or “Bush’s clone” works on the imagination of the anti-Bush crowd. Carter may not be “it,” but you can see the wheels turning at the McCain camp as they ponder how to knock down Obama’s lofty image and get voters to think about Obama’s actual policy proposals and their likely results.

The trouble is: Bush is a Republican version of Carter. And memory of his legacy is a little fresher.

The Prius

Greener than Reihan suggested. A reader adds:

I’m disappointed that you lent so much credence to Reihan in the Prius-bashing, who lends so much credence to that Wired article without at least noting that soon the Toyota Prius will be switching to a lithium battery, which will change that calculus completely.

It’s true that the Prius does have a bit of a green footprint issue vs. a used car, but that’s kind of a silly argument to make considering the fact that the used car is clearly a different product than a new car, and a different market. It’s a bit unfair in an apples to apples way to pick the most fuel-efficient used-car you can find and put it up against a new car, where it has a built-in advantage immediately in its carbon footprint because it’s used! Why not a new Prius vs. a used suburban? I wonder who would win that comparison?

   

Also, it’s silly to assume a used TERCEL or GEO METRO is going to be a plausible product for most people since the reliability of those cars and whatever longevity might be left on a used one is dubious at best. You might as well urge "green living" by using your coffee ground three or four times before you throw them out. Sure it’s an awful beverage or has no actual flavor left by the fourth time, but hey, it’s greener so that’s the choice a green must make! These arguments trying to bring in crazy scenarios about using old cars that Reihan even acknowledges are death traps all just seem like silly contrarianism.

Bush Lied?

Many dissents from my view that the administration did not lie about Saddam’s WMDs or even his potential links with al Qaeda. They recklessly oversold dubious intelligence and exaggerated his threat. I don’t think this makes them less culpable for the botch-up. This commenter at the Economist captures the point:

Is "lying" the appropriate benchmark?

In the business world the benchmark is "due diligence". In issuing a prospectus, for example, it is not sufficient that it contains no "lies". On the other hand, it is not necessary that the undertaking be guaranteed of success. The required standard is that those responsible for promoting the undertaking demonstrate that they have exercised due diligence before selling it to the public.

It is odd that a country may go to war on a standard of diligence lower than that required to float a company.

Bush lied about torture. He didn’t lie about the intelligence on Saddam’s WMDs. He just failed to do due diligence.