Judicial Activism In History

From Arthur Sutherland’s 1954 article on segregation and the Supreme Court:

Man has never succeeded in defining justice, and this is well; any definition might exclude what he would later wish to preserve. But the Supreme Court had no trouble in deciding on what was not justice; it was not justice to exclude the Negro child from the school where the white children could go. And that judgment day was a great day. As I write, the papers are full of reports of governors calling together educational commissions to consider what shall be done; and in two or three states there are reported a few—surprisingly few—hurt and indignant utterances from public officials. This is not remarkable. For generations men have felt deeply and resentfully about this matter. People against whom any court decides are apt to be exasperated, and say things in immediate hurt which a little later they realize they do not wholly mean.

Kristol’s Intent

Daniel Koffler on Kristol:

…it’s true that throwing up a wall of bullshit to deflect attention from your candidate’s deeply unpopular views is a potentially effective means of helping him creep to victory on the strength of contentless non-issues — like, say, whether his opponent is an insufficiently patriotic crypto-Communist. But to conclude that’s all Kristol is up to doesn’t give him nearly enough credit for a long-term vision, at least when it comes to tactical moves in the Republican party’s internal turf wars. Campaigning on xenophobia, guilt by association, and red-baiting has desperate and unintentionally self-parodic qualities this year that it didn’t have as recently as 2004. The likelihood is that John McCain will lose; if and when he loses, the multilateral truce among neos, paleos, reformists, and GOP hacks — which is about as fragile as the truce in Basra to begin with — is going to shatter before Obama’s victory speech ends.

The neocons are in a decidedly weak position. Fairly or not, it’s their foreign policy more than anything else that has made the name of the GOP radioactive — and even worse for Republican partisans, has destroyed the party’s nearly 40-year-old, frequently decisive advantage on national security. And though the Republicans somehow stumbled into nominating their only candidate with a prayer of victory, they exposed the neocons to even more risk by choosing, in John McCain, the most prominent exponent of their philosophy in American politics. Honest neocons like Lawrence Kaplan readily concede that neoconservatism’s future rests on McCain’s shoulders. Kristol, on the other hand, is trying to reframe the debate to obscure its ramifications for his ideology in case McCain loses.

John Schwenkle responds here.

Al Qaeda Against Marriage Equality

In case you were wondering:

At his arraignment here Thursday, the alleged 9/11 mastermind said he would not accept any attorney, even a fellow Muslim, “who is sworn to your American constitution.” Displaying a surprising understanding of such concepts as federalism and dual sovereignty, Mohammed referenced recent decisions by state courts in California and Massachusetts under the powers reserved to them under the Tenth Amendment.

“I consider all American constitution” evil, he said, because it permits “same-sexual marriage and many other things that are very bad,” he told the military judge, Col. Ralph Kohlmann. “Do you understand?”

A Samaritan-Free Road Ctd.

A reader writes:

Actually, the scene in that video isn’t too bad.  As a volunteer EMT for a few years I responded to exactly two pedestrians hit by cars, and both times well meaning bystanders pulled the patient our of the street and tried to prop up their heads – exactly what you don’t want when your biggest concern is a head or neck injury.  Other than stopping traffic, keeping the patient’s head and neck still, and talking to them to keep them calm, there really isn’t anything to do until the ambulance gets there.

A police officer was on the scene in about one minute, a very prompt response, so one of the witnesses probably called for help right away.  They probably couldn’t have gotten help any faster unless they’d been hit by the actual ambulance.

It sucks to sit and watch people not rush over to help, but it’s easy to forget how surprising and stressful those situations can be when they’re not just little scenes on the computer screen.  Bystanders feel scared and helpless during emergencies, and most people just don’t know what to do.  The impulse to walk away and let someone else deal with it is usually a reaction to those feelings, not an expression of callousness.  The real callousness is evident after the adrenalin wears off.  A better example of non-Samaritanism would be a video of people walking past a homeless person trying to get some sleep on a sidewalk or park bench.

Has Hewitt Finally Lost It?

Maybe I’m missing something, but Hugh Hewitt keeps posting images from TUCC’s church bulletin as if they contained something scary or shocking or revelatory. I can’t find anything in them even faintly remarkable. Donating a kidney to another member of the congregation? Instructions on how to get an EITC tax credit? Help for Katrina victims? Is Hewitt now muttering aimlessly in a dark room somewhere?

But there was this classic:

Even voters hostile to Israel ougth [sic] to wonder about Obama’s naivete about the issue.

Wha?