The Great Debate

McCain proposed a series of town hall debates. The Obama camp wants them Lincoln-Douglas style. James Joyner hopes for the best:

I continue to believe, perhaps naively, that the Obama-McCain fall matchup will be relatively issue oriented compared to recent contests. While surrogates and 527s and others will ratchet up the noise and vitriol, both candidates seem to have a natural aversion to mud-slinging.

More debates rather than fewer and less scripted rather than more would be my preference and, it seems, that of both candidates. If their campaigns don’t talk them out of it.

Ambinder wonders if McCain just blew it with his timing.

It Was The War, Stupid

Steven Hart exhumes the Clinton campaign:

This time out, as Duncan Black keeps pointing out, the elephant in the room is the Iraq war. If Hillary hadn’t decided to play it safe and let the rumpus room warriors have their way, she would be the nominee and everyone would be saying “Barack who?” She thought she was being shrewd, and it blew up in her face. That vote lost her the nomination, and yet the “analysts” and pundits are scrupulously avoiding talking about it. The war decided this primary, and it will decide the vote in November as well.

In her essay about self-respect (it’s in Slouching Towards Bethlehem), Joan Didion writes that without integrity,

"one runs away to find oneself, and finds no one at home."

I’m not a Hillary hater, but I think that sentence sums up this turning point in her political career. The country needed more from her than what she was ready to give, and now she gets nothing. 

Reality And The Clintons

A useful piece of advice for Obama from a reader:

Personally, I think Hillary needs to acknowledge that Obama won, and that she has lost, before he should negotiate anything like the veep spot, other possible policy role for her or Bill, or even using his funds to pay her campaign debt.  This business of "I’ll acknowledge reality if you negotiate with me" is the wrong place to start, and a symptom of what’s been wrong with her all along. 

Reality is negotiable to her, and that is a sign of someone who is deeply unhinged.  If she can acknowledge that she is a rational player, then he can and should think about what next steps they can take together.  Not before.

McCain’s Strongest Asset

A reader explains:

In your enthusiasm for Obama, are you missing the most obvious and probably insurmountable obstacle to his election?  It’s not race, inexperience, his pastor’s foul mouth, or his eye-popping economic policy bloat. No one but the yellow dogs will want to see a Washington dominated in all three houses of government by liberal-leaning Dems. 

The last time we had such a situation with the Rs, and I’m sure you would agree it wasn’t favorable. I would bet this will be McCain’s close, and it will win. It gets my vote.

“We Owe God A Death”

Appleyard ponders the cultural impact of extended lifespans:

Ultimately, the pursuit of life extension or medical immortality is a continuation of the ancient pursuit of the conquest of death, either by giving it meaning or by survival in this life or some other. It is the scientific version of the oldest human aspiration, which is either to evade oblivion or to embrace it with the consolatory knowledge that one’s life has acquired significance.

Shakespeare, as usual, found the single exact word to capture what is at stake here. The word is ‘owe’. Feeble in Henry V says ‘we owe God a death’. For Feeble, to be born is to be indebted. Our death settles the account. This feels like a profoundly true statement. I shall now try to work out why it is. Or why it isn’t.