McCain’s Speech

From the re-branded green background to the silly attempt to capitalize on Democratic divisions to the Clintonian cooptation of an Obama meme – "a leader we can believe in" – McCain’s opening gambit in the general election was, in my judgment, underwhelming. It wasn’t the content as such. McCain will rightly brag of his support for the surge (if not the war) and will have some reason to claim he is not running for George W. Bush’s third term. It was the delivery and the response that threw me off. To be blunt, McCain can be a pretty bad public speaker. He has a mild, relatively high-pitched voice and an uncomfortable way of smiling broadly and speaking softly as he makes tough attacks on his opponent. Those attacks were greeted by louder boos against Obama than cheers for McCain. It was a strange mix of aggression and calm, of cheeriness and anger. A little weird.

The attempt to describe Obama as too big a risk is probably McCain’s best bet; and his endeavor to rebrand himself as the candidate of real change is necessary. But he will fail if he tries to describe Obama as a leftist who can’t be trusted – because the next generation doesn’t get these categories and the older generation is exhausted by them. And it is simply difficult stylistically for a man of McCain’s age and experience to describe himself as a more credible change agent than this young insurgent. McCain has to try this change meme; but it doesn’t thrill his base and it doesn’t immediately connect to the middle. This was, in my judgment, an inauspicious start.

Yes We Did

As we absorb the news that an African-American is now the Democratic party’s presumptive nominee for the presidency of the United States, a few words. No one should allow the tortuous end of this primary journey to obscure the passion and insurrection that made it possible. That passion came from a simple place, the way it often does in politics. It came from the gut instinct that we have lost our way, that the United States needs to start again after the debt, depravity, and destruction of the Bush years. It came from hope that the future need not be as bleak as it seemed not too long ago. It came from a sense that the deepest divisions were not as deep as the political class needed them to be and wanted them to be. And it came from the astonishing nostrum that a liberal, black first-term senator could overturn the biggest machine, the biggest name and the biggest dynasty in Democratic party politics.

He did it, because we did it. Because many of us refused to accept the choices we were being offered and looked to a new direction and new way worthy of the next generation. And this song is still part of the history we just made. Yes We Can:

Raising A Glass

Poulos:

At any rate, the bottom line here is that in spite of myself it seems right to at least raise a glass to Obama. He is a good American, a cool spirit, and, perhaps most important of all, a worthy opponent. His triumph is questionable in terms of small-ball politics, but neither you, I, nor the Democratic party should worry much about that. In terms of the American character, it´s an important and refreshing reminder that we can, in fact, raise the bar when it comes to our politicians, and admire the luxury of our own high expectations both conscientiously and confidently.

All of this is ruined, of course, if Obama caves and Hillary slithers onto the ticket.

Yglesias Award Nominee II

"Even if we’re going to hear it over and over, it’s true—this is a historic moment. That an African-American has a better than even chance to be the next president of the United States is an amazing thing—and heartening about this country’s capacity for progress. Also, on a more mundane level, Obama out-campaigned, out-fundraised, out-strategized, out-classed, and—yes—out-spun the Clintons. What a campaign. He and his team should be very proud," – Rich Lowry, NRO.

Quotes For The Day

"We consider the underlying fallacy of the plaintiff’s argument to consist in the assumption that the enforced separation of the two races stamps the colored race with a badge of inferiority. If this be so, it is not by reason of anything found in the act, but solely because the colored race chooses to put that construction upon it," – Justice Henry Billings Brown’s 1896 Plessy v. Ferguson

"Requiring the same substantive legal rights is, in my view, a matter of equal protection. But this does not mean the traditional definition of marriage is unconstitutional… The people are entitled to preserve this traditional understanding in the terminology of the law, recognizing that same-sex and opposite-sex unions are different. What they are not entitled to do is treat them differently under the law," – Carol Corrigan, a dissenter to the California court’s decision to grant civil marriage licenses to gay couples as well as straight ones.

The Fusion Ticket

Since I was among those who raised the option of an Obama-Clinton ticket, and aired the debate for a while, I should say that I hope at this point that Obama has the strength to turn her down – gently. He should bring in former rivals into his cabinet and should offer Clinton a cabinet post, on the Lincoln model. But to have endured the kind of campaign the Clintons ran and concede to her wishes now would be an act of weakness that the Clintons would exploit were he to become president.

Obama needs to regain the momentum and clarity of his early insurrection. He would not do that by adding Clinton to his ticket.